Damon's All American Pizza Pie

Wow awesome crust, good sauce, generous toppings, yummy cheese and piping hot!! We were driving to Hocking Hills from the Canton area and wanted to grab a pizza on our way. The pizza shop is on an old building, but don't judge a book by its cover. What a wonderful surprise!!

Food and service is great. I've never had a problem here. The inside dining needs an extreme make over tho. It looks so worn out. But I'd get there food any day. Chicken Club is soooo good!

Pizza was great. Service was friendly and quick. Highly recommend!

This was my first time eating at Damon's. My wife is from Newcomerstown and she's talked about their pizza for years. We finally went after a trick-or-treat event and got two pizzas. The 5th Inning pizza was really good. Too bad I had to share, haha.

My favorite pizza place in eastern Ohio ! Delicious pizza , great wing flavors and awesome hoagies !

We ordered pizza for lunch.
Pizza was extremely fresh, hot and tasted amazing!
Best pizza we all had in a while. Came pretty quick too.
Ordered two large pep pizzas and cheesy bread.
Both pizza and chessy bread we great!!!! Good food. If we're working a line near by again in the future we will definitely order again.

Really good food and service would recommend to anyone

They were recommended by a gentleman at the truck stop that I was at. I ordered a 12 inch pizza with just about everything on it. I forget what they called it. They delivered it in less than 30 minutes, it was hot and it tasted awesome. It feed 3 adults and I thought it was a reasonable price for what it was. $16.99 plus tip. Thank you.

Really great pizza I highly suggest it. It’s so goofy ahh 💀 and my son donquavious binglebottom went there and said he has gained 15 pounds in the last hour but I’m so proud of him because he is so goofy ahh 💀 like me. 5 star review ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

This is probably my favorite pizza place outside of Jersey. Out of all the pizza I've had, their sauce is sweet instead of being mostly tangy/acidic. Prompt, courteous service and a broad variety of menu items. This is a Newcomerstown icon and worth a visit!

Awesome food! We were traveling from LA to CT and got stuck in Newcomerstown due to snow. First off, I’m from Connecticut and I KNOW pizza. Pizza and I have a long and loving history and I’m always on the hunt for the best pie. Damon’s does NOT disappoint! Wood fired pizza is 2nd only to coal fired pizza and Damon’s pie had just the right amount of crunch, tasty crust, sauce with just a touch of sweetness and very generous toppings. We also ordered Greek salads which came with a house made Greek dressing (quite tasty) with a TON of feta, kalamata olives and banana peppers. Delivery to our motel was quick and pizza was piping hot on arrival. Highly, highly recommend!

Me and my friends go here every now and than, great place to just hangout inside and have a good time with great food and good laughs.

Don't judge a book by it's cover. This is a must stop if your are in the area and want good pizza!!

Best pizza in my town

Loved the Homerun pizza! A little dated and worn inside when you pick up, but the pizza was amazing! Great job Damon!

My hometown pizza shop. Awesome only place I buy my 🍕. Great friendly workers. Highly recomend.

Just here visiting from Texas for work and it is Great food, highly recommended. My first time here and it was very tasty.

This small town pizza place beats ANY place I had pizza before!! Italian food on a thick, delicious, golden baked crust. Try it!!

Delicious! We ordered while we were camping at Rocky Fork... totally worth driving into town!!

Super pizza and pasta. Definitely recommend. Amazing variety of choices on the menu. Prices are reasonable.