Peppy's Pizza & Subs

I am on a mission to try every local pizza shop (Knox county), and beyond, searching for the best mom and pop pizza, I can find...

Seems I probably won't have to look to far beyond Peppys, as it's been the front runner for many years.

Always a pleasant experience. Quick and efficient staff, friendly, and the absolute best pizza!

Great for take out, or dine-in! Typically takes 30minutes or less, inside is very clean and pays homage to the community sports, and high school. There is ample seating, which you cannot find in many local shops, that gives you the opportunity to eat inside comfortably.
Prices are reasonable and in line with most pizza places.

Just a great hometown pizza joint with the best atmosphere, service, food, and prices.

Highly recommend!

AMAZING as Usual! The last time I was here was when I was 14/15 years old! This was the "hang out" when I was a kid. It's a MUST STOP for AMAZING pizza and subs and calzones aka strombolis, lol. The only thing it's missing is feta cheese, that they don't have unfortunately.

Peppy's provided one of the best pizzas I've ever eaten last night. They consistently slay the competition. Everywhere.

Best pizza in knox county Ohio in my opinion

Best pizza I've ever had. Nice thin crust. Lots'o toppings. Awesome sauce.
Usually accurate order got messed up. Because the person taking my order didn't know their menu. The women running the shift replace the incorrect pizza, but refuse to remake the other two and said she'd keep them in the warmer. Despite my objection. Sure enough it wasn't the same as fresh. Very disappointed. Don't go unless the owner is there.
The "B" crew doesn't care.

Just had a deluxe sub it down town very good

I got the all meat pizza and their take on mozzarella sticks. 5 stars. The crust on the pizza was awesome. It was light and airy with a crunchy texture. Their take on mozzarella sticks is awesome. Basically breadsticks smothered with cheese and served with pizza sauce. The sauce was awesome too. This is going to be my go to pizza place

Great little place to grab a bite to eat. We went when the power was out in Mount Vernon, even though you were very busy, the staff was upbeat and happy to help

Peppy's Pizza in my own opinion is the BEST pizza u can get in Ohio,the #1 is NY/NJ then the #2 is Peppy's for there thin crust pizza. It is absolutely delicious please fo not ever change a thing. Thank you for your service, it is always nice and welcoming and thank you for your never changing delicious Pizza. But I wish you would open a little sooner.

Hands down, the best pizza around. Love the crunch that the cast iron ovens give the crust. Fresh and delicious! Plus, a polite, wonderful crew.

Ordered two pizzas but due to a mix up only one was made. They said they would make the second pizza at no charge if I could wait! After 15 minutes or so the second one was done and I was given BOTH pizzas for NO CHARGE!!! They turned a unfortunate.mix up in to good experience for me.

Definitely check this out if you’re in the area... scratch that, make the trip if you need to. Don’t let the common small town pizza shop look fool you. Fantastic pizza and excellent upstanding service. Very clean. Very Fresh. There will definitely be repeat trips to come.

First time ever eating from here, Pizza was delicious! One of best I had. Store was nice and clean! Staff was very pleasant! Will definitely be one of my new places to order from. Im from Mansfield,Ohio

We've lived in Fredericktown now for almost 2 years and after repeated visits to all the locations around us I have to say that Peppys is hands down the best pizza in the area. I love thin crust and theirs is perfect. Not soggy and droopy like other places in Fredericktown, Bellville and Mount Vernon. If your pizza place cant get a pepperoni pizza right can they really get anything else right? Try Peppys Extra Pepperoni pizza and you will NOT be disappointed. Taco pizza is amazing as well and weighs like 3lbs. Subs are good. Apps are so so but the pizza has me coming back time and time again. If you want pizza, you want Peppys.

Friendly staff, great pizza and subs. Recommend trying it to see if it's your type of pizza too.

Although the crust is thin they make it up with lots of toppings and the cheese pizza is very cheesy lol. ( No pun attended) excellent pizzas! I’m so glad their in Mount Vernon now 👍🏻♥😍🍕

This was our first time ordering!!! This pizza is fantastic! The crust is so awesome it stays crunchy! We have a new favorite pizza shop!

Our new favorite pizza place. Pizza is ready when they say it will be, Order is always accurate. Pizza tastes great!

Great classic pizza. Small town vibes, good pies

Traveling through town and stopped here for pizza. Good dine in experience, friendly staff and pizza was delicious!