Peace Pie

Unique spin on the ice cream sandwich. Tons of filling flavors and sure to please even the stingiest of pallets. The staff were super friendly and willing to explain and offer suggestions...

These are great sandwiches. Ice cream combos are excellent . Will definitely be back.

Terrific ice cream sandwiches! Recommended by a neighbor at our beach rental, we had to try a 6 pack of pies. The kids loved them. Will come back again before our vacation is over. I had the Elvis ♥

$7 is a bit pricey for an ice cream sandwich, but you've got to try one for yourself! Peace Pies are amazing! I love the Key Lime Pie!

I wish I could give them 10 stars. We love this place so much! Icecream cookie sandwiches with some pie filling in them too! Everything is so good there, we can't decide so we get the Baker's Choice. So Peace Pie decides. We take turns reaching in the bag blindly to see what we get. It's a fun family outing and soooooo good. I went there today and the lady recognized me as a frequent stopper. She gave me a rewards card with a few stamps already on it. I appreciated it so much!

Love Peace Pies!! Such an awesome concept: merging ice cream sandwiches and pies into one. There are a ton of great flavors, everyone that works there is super friendly and helpful, and the location is right at the border of Margate and Ventnor. Definitely recommend!

Simply the best. I even go here when I have dinner at Stella right next store and I love that place. Can’t pass up a peace pie.

I mean you take shortbread, mouse, icecream, and your favorite flavor and you put it all together in the palm of your hand? This is the most delicious icecream dessert I've had! They are very frozen when they come out of the freezer it is best to wait a moment. Peace Pies come in multiple flavors and are 5 bucks each i think. They are 2 shortbreads with a layer of piefilling then slab of ultra hard ice cream then some more topping! It is ridiculous how good these things are. If you like the taste of cinnabon, then get cinnamon bun, salted caramel, or french toast. Apple is highly recommended by my daughter! I have tried keylime also another delicious one!. Chocolate Peanutbutter there are no words..
The people who work at these stores always know their flavors. They musy get asked 50 times a day (by me) because we just ask which is this? N this? N that? There is also a punch card so ask when u go in..buy 10 get 1 free n u will buy 10 eventually!!

Ice Cream sandwich meets pie filling. What more can you ask for? An abundance of.flavors and options and they've made the experience easy during covid with a door made into a window. You can pick up, call.ahead, and order there.

Delicious. So many flavors and choices. Ice cold. Love the salted caramel and the vanilla ice cream (on whichever pie) is some of the best I've ever tasted.

You have to just taste it to believe it. This is such a unique and amazing desert creation. I hope they open more locations! Just be warned- if you try one, you'll definitely be coming back for more

The best ice cream sandwich we've ever had. We drove an hour to the shore and went to Ventnor just so we could get Peace Pie.

Definitely a delicious treat! I have tried at least 6 flavors and none left me disappointed. Will continue to indulge here :)

Excellent ice cream sandwiches

Love those Peace Pies. Unique combinations, great ice cream. Have been to their Cape May branch as well.

Phenomenal sweet treat. Get one for each hand. No judgement here. Staff is spectacular. Can’t wait to get back!

The Irish Potato Peace Pie is one of their best kept secrets. Wish they had it year round!

Excellent product!! Great variety of flavors Yumm!!!

Peace Pie is the absolute BEST. Delicious assortment of flavors.

You wouldn't expect these to be so good but they are, by far, the best ice cream sandwiches.