Mario's NY Pizza

Absolutely perfect!!!
Grilled chicken salad served with knots!
Baked Penne also served with knots!
Cheese Sticks homemade marinara delicious!!!
Chicken Tenders were awesome!!!
This place would be slamming during the week if they offered delivery for lunch!!!
Great service and amazing food!!!

I was very pleased both times I came here. I had the Philly Cheese steak the first time, and it was pleasing. The lady behind the register gave Buddie a few pepperonis. The next time we had the Philly Cheese pizza and chicken parm pizza with a side of garlic fries!! Wooooooow!!!!! Enrique has a great customer service 👏 👌

Best pizza in town town . 😋. You can't rely on most reviews but this is the best pizza hands down around.

By far best pizza in the area.. employees are wonderful and kind.. nice and clean atmosphere ❤❤✌

Wow! We ordered delivery. Took a little while but well worth it. I had the Margherita pizza. It was fantastic. We have found our new pizza place, eat in our for delivery. Thank you.

The staff is so nice! I went here after I got off work (around 9) and ordered a 20” butcher pizza, garlic knots and I had a beer while I waited. I got a chance to chat with the employees and hang out while my food cooked. Such a nice atmosphere. Everything looked nice and clean! I’ve lived down the road and visit the area often but this was my first stop in. I grabbed a menu so I could bring it home in case my bf wants to order from here while I’m at work and have me pick it up on my way home. 10/5 would visit again. Thank you Mario’s pizza for making a long day better❤

Some of the best pizza I have had in St. Pete. They also do delivery which is a bit rare for these quality places. Try the white pizza with olive oil and fresh ricotta. So good!

Sauce is sweet and crust is crunchy just the way we like it! Very pleased to stop by after buying fish next door. Cheap and worth coming back again. Slice of pizza & oreo cheese cake. Yummy!

We come across- town from Downtown St Pete to get this pizza if that tells ya anything. The crust is homemade and they never skimp on the cheese. Always fresh ingredients. LOVE the loaded veggie pizza with ricotta.

The pizza is amazing. The crust is perfection and the sauce... Delicious. I don't usually give reviews but the smell alone was magic, the flavor, beyond expectations! Love it, my new place.

Delicious, authentic NY style pizza! Quick service. Recommend, bring a friend. They even have a $5 lunch special (slice and a drink). And don't forget, yummy desserts!

Reliable tasty pies and parm for take out, delivery, and dine-in. Vegetarian options -- we like the spinach+veggie and veggie supreme. The garlic knots are a must.

It's the kind of NY Pizza where they call it a pizza pie.

It crisps in the oven perfectly on Day 2.

Got their Special pizza, pepperoni, onions, sausage, green peppers. All the flavors came together right with the sauce and cheese bringing it together perfectly. A very balanced pie. The dough was cooked perfectly being crispy on the outside and fluffy inside while being the right thickness to not take away from the ingredients. Will be back.

I love their pizza. I always order mine a lil heavier on sauce as the flavor is awesome. With economy I don't get to go as often as I'd like but always enjoy. Staff friendly and professional.

Really delicious pizza, my husband and I love thin crust but not all pizza places have a good one, Mario’s NY Pizza definitely has one, so that deserves a 5 stars review.
Also, I left my husband’s wallet with cash included on the table, we didn’t realize until the next day. When I went back they weren’t opened yet but the chef still let me in (they were cleaning the whole place before opening) ask a few questions and then returned our wallet with everything in it, and that deserves more than 5 stars.
We will definitely be coming back and highly recommend everyone to go, the place is super clean, they have delicious pizza and are honest people.

I've been going here for over 20 years, the quality of food is always on top, I've had pizza, chicken parmigiano, cold subs, you name it. Taste is always great. The staff is wonderful, very personable, always in a great mood and very friendly, they know my family by name. I recommend them to anyone who asks for a good slice of pizza. Go see them and get you a good meal or a quick slice! !

Awesome service, my first time there and the pizza is out of this world! I will definitely be returning frequently!

Excellent! Amazing! Love this place. Highly recommend! We work at a pizza place and zoom over to this place as soon as we get off. The guys there are very professional and polite. I'm already looking forward to ordering from them again 😋

Been going to this place since I was a kid...by far the best pizza in the bay....Inside is nice and clean, pizza by the slice deals, delivery is always fast and friendly. Just can't say enough good things about them...great friendly staff...and they actually listen when you tell them to burn your pizza (nobody else does). Must try if you haven't already.

I came into this place expecting a semi-average pizza joint, but I was honestly blown away. The staff was very nice and made things pretty straightforward for my girlfriend and I. We didn't have to wait too long for our orders to reach the table! The meatball parmesan was probably the best pizza I've had in a while. Mario's blew my expectations out the window and I'll definitely be coming back in the future.