Fellinis Pizzeria

We have never had a bad hoagie here. We ordered pizza for the first time for the family with their Valentine’s Day heart pizza. And even with delivery it came hot. Definitely one of the best pizza places in Elizabeth.

Ordered food at 8pm on a Sunday. While I waited a bit for delivery, it was still pretty quick given the time and where we live! The food was amazing. And the driver was very nice and professional! I can’t wait to order again!
The buffalo chicken fries are absolutely amazing!

Best food around town! Amazing customer service! Outstanding staff! Friendly and clean atmosphere! 5 stars hands down!! Thank you for a great experience!!

My four year old refused to leave me alone while ordering until the nice lady taking my order said hello to her. This is the note from my pizza box tonight. We were super pleased with the service and the food.

Wow!.. I don't know if I'm extra hungry tonight or what, but this might be the best order-in I've ever had! I order from here about once a month and its always very good. I've stopped in for pick-up orders too and the people are hard working and very nice. Small, family business. Grateful to have them right down the road!

Yum! Gyros were great and kids loved the pizza and wings.

The Western burger was amazing! For the size, the pricing was right in line! The staff is very helpful and extremely friendly. What a wonderful way to have a great dinner and end a day filled with bad news. Thanks!

Whoever the new cook is, is absolutely KILLING it. Hands down best food I've ever gotten from there. I ordered Italian meat pockets and a pepperoni roll. They were beautiful presented and tasted bomb!!!! 10/10 😊😊

I drive a school bus for a local District and I'm always looking for places to eat on different field trips. I really like small type family-owned places to eat and fellini's was perfect. One of my favorite things to eat on trips are chicken wings I don't get to eat them very much and I'm always looking for a good place for that. They offered whole chicken wings and wing dings I chose to go with the wing-dings. I was extremely pleased with the spiciness that they offered. After my meal I always like to have something sweet and the lady working there said they have cheesecake and some type of cinnamon stick made out of I'm guessing pizza crust or pizza dough. She Made Them extra big which I never asked her to do and she was very accommodating with all of my desires on what I wanted. I could not eat all of them so I shared them with the girls that I took on a field trip with and they just loved them. That's all I would not hesitate to go back there again.

Great pizza! Dough is made fresh daily! Sauce is a sweet type and our pie had lots of gooey cheese!!! Our Italian hoagie was tasty - lots 9f meat, fresh hoagie bun, and I loved that the shredded lettuce was tossed in the Italian dressing. There were many choice on the menu and specials were available every day. We got our large pizza for 8.99 with one topping. My kids just like cheese, so we passed on the topping. However there were my to choose from. We will visit again soon!!!

Service is absolutely amazing in this shop. The food is always hot and on time, and looks absolutely perfect. After experiencing service here, we won't be going anywhere else.

I say personally that this pizza place is very outstanding in the way they do/handle things like food, service, and especially within their timeframe. Everything here is great. 5/5 in my honest and personal opinion and experience with Fellinis in Elizabeth

I went here today with my 7 year old nephew and he loved it! We had the boneless wings with ranch and honey BBQ sauce. A little pricey but I definitely recommend.

Very good food! And the owner is really nice to deal with. The rest of the Staff could be alittle more friendlier, but I’m just glad their pizza tastes good!🤣

Love the food , love the service ....not one bad experience!! Eat there at least once a week!! Yikes out or delivery they are right on time!!

Fellini's pizza and hoagies are so good that we usually get them at least once a week. Very reasonable prices, take-out, delivery and dine-in available, and you can usually park right across the street from the place.
Highly recommend Fellini's Pizzeria

Just had Fellinis pizza from Elizabeth. Best pizza I have eaten in a long time. Been very disappointed in Elizabeth township pizza. FELLINI will deliver to township, give them a try.

We loved it! It was about 9pm and we wanted some gyros. Ordered and they were incredible! Completely loaded and their crispy chicken salads are to die for!

It was a hole in the wall but in a good way.

Great food, friendly service. The fried dough-sugar sticks, and the Calzone were delicious! We will definitely be back to try more things!