Mudd Valley Cafe & Creamery

We came to the market because we were staying by for the weekend. The milkshake and ice cream were delicious! I believe the ice cream comes from the Smith Dairy that is located in Ohio. The market was also very cool but we didn't buy anything. We were with a group of friends who wanted to attend.

The food was amazing. The service is placing your order and waiting to pick it up. However, they were very friendly. I had the Rueben with Sweet Potato fries, and my wife had a BLT. Both were fantastic!

Now I tried there Flatbread pizza it had good flavor now I would like to see the other things there. Now the service was really good and so polite. The decor was a little bit cafe and a little bit of a touch of home with the fireplace. The place was so clean. How would ever think to find a cafe in a grocery store such a great little treasure.

We always stop by here when we are in the area. We always order the grilled chicken breast sandwiches. For sides I always have their macaroni salad. My wife always orders their sweet potato fries. They offer several different items on the menu. Everything we have tried is delicious. They have a kids menu. Our grandkids enjoyed their hot dogs and hamburgers and french fries. The kids even get a coupon for ice cream. The employees are always very friendly. The restaurant is very clean and the atmosphere is very nice. I am certainly glad we came here a found this place. It is upstairs but you have 3 options to enter the restaurant. You can enter from the outside stairs on the east side. You can enter the store and you can take the stairs or the elevator.

Super duper fun. The food was great and priced super well. Their "stacks" are awesome. Like an American Chipotle build a bowl.

Lot of great choices here and neat dinning experience being above the store. Make sure to get some ice cream down stairs too.

A simple place to eat with the family on a budget! Food is good. Order, pick up then self serve.

This place is a hidden gem! We have been coming to Amish Country for years and just found it. The food was *so* fresh and tasty and the prices are great! We will definitely be back!

The creamery was also fantastic! Amazing ice cream!

Sweet and sow burger was great! Clean restaurant with interesting, old metal signs.

We visit Amish country often but were not aware of this cafe and were pleasantly surprised. Large seating capacity, friendly staff, and the food was exceptional and reasonably priced. I got chicken salad on croissant with potato salad, hubby got a great burger and big portion of waffle fries. We will definitely be eating there again

Great cafe inside of Walnut Cheese Grocery store. Good selection of food and prices are fabulous. Highly recommend it. Try the ice cream sundaes and the root beer floats you can't go wrong

It's nice to have a place to feed a family of 4 for less than $50, and the food is actually good! My only complaint is that they use canned mushrooms - those things should be illegal for human consumption!

We always get sandwich, side and drinks which are special prices. We sat in front of a fireplace with a nice warming fire going. Great atmosphere.

My Dad and my Husband got the Reubens and really liked them. They have a nice build your own bowl/wrap or salad that they will plate up for you. You order your food and get a beeper to get it when it's done. There is lots of seating and it is decorated wirh lots of old memorabilia. There is an elevator that is located inside the store about 50 feet from the entrance. It was a rough walk for my dad so I got him a cart to lean on.

A lot of food for the money. Pleasant staff and nice atmosphere. Likes being able to see the store below while eating.

Fast service and decent prices with GREAT food. The stacks are my favorite. Theyre like a create your own burrito bowl. Sandwiches are great roo, though. We always stop here for lunch when we are in the area.

Top notch place! Best and messiest turkey club ever.

Super clean ….. GREAT FOOD and GREAT service !

You may not expect much from a cafe above a grocery store, but they had GREAT food and quite a bit to choose from. They have what they call stacks, which are like burrito bowls and it was so good and a huge portion. My husband had a burger which also tasted awesome! We would def eat there again. Great place!

The best grilled chicken sandwich I've ever had. Plan on sharing your fries....so many!!