Amici's Pizza

In town for the night a grabbed a pizza and salad. I got the general and it was excellent and loaded with toppings. Possibly the best pizza I’ve ever had. The homemade sauce is amazing! Salad was good too, croutons were great, not sure if they are homemade but they are good. I live 2 hours away and would consider making the drive for this pizza. Very good. Great job Amici’s. Also the price is fair

This place is a nice small pizza shop with a few tables inside. Most people get there pizza to go. It is very good pizza! 🍕 I would definitely suggest it if you are in the area. The staff is super friendly and nice too.

Ordered two pizzas online. Pulled into the parking lot to pick them up and an employee came out to my truck before I even got out. He asked if he had an order and went in and got it for us. The pizza is delicious and the customer service was amazing! The fact that I didn't have to get out of the vehicle with two small kids was awesome.

Great pizza! I stumbled upon the one in Gnadenhutten, and I'm delighted to have found it. It reminds me of the best aspects of Granato's deep dish in New Phila but it was cheap and quick! Sweet style sauce, crisp, tasty crust, plenty of cheese. Highly recommended.

The pizza was loaded with toppings! The sauce was amazing. My new favorite pizza spot!

Pizza is really excellent. Great service, friendly employees. Clean dining area and restrooms. Restrooms are upstairs. I don’t believe it’s handicapped accessible.

Coach Al and the staff ALWAYS dishing out fantastic pizza.

Top 3 slice of all time!

Great pizza subs wings Stromboli @ a fare price! Plenty of toppings and also check out other location in Gnadenhutten!

First time getting food here and I love it!! All this time passing and I find a gem!!! Still tops !!! Never change a classic..they are great!!! Well as this posting they have definitely changed....last few times we order always the same foods.....yet were always mistakes ..despite repeating it a few times...still got them wrong ....gonna not order from here for awhile....too many mistakes

Everything was great 1st time customer, we will be back!!

Excellent Pizza! The Salads looked great as well!

The cauliflower crust pizza is very good as well.

Great to see this place doing so well. It was a huge part of my childhood, when it was Village Pizza, and the new incarnation is just as good! Glad to see the young people still have a great place to hang, and it's just a great place for the whole family! The service is impeccable, fast and more than efficient! The food is phenomenal! Highly recommend this little piece of history. The new owners and management are doing great things!

Best PIZZA in Coshocton!!!!!! U get what u pay for. They need open a shop in Coshocton. Only 1 complaint. THEY HAVE NO RED PEPPER FLAKES. So bring ur own pepper flakes an get a great PIZZA!!!!!! LOL

Just moved nearby and didn't think I'd find cauliflower crust but they had it! Reasonably priced and honestly it's the best one I've ever had. Got takeout and it was ready in 15min. Definitely will be back.

First time trying Amici's, good pizza for a good price! Got an extra cheese pizza and it came with an excellent amount of cheese. Sauce was a little sweet and that's just not my preference but it was still an okay sauce all in all. Bread was decent. The cheese really sold the pizza for me though, quality taste. Definitely would order again!

We frequently get pizza from here when we travel to Coshocton. One of the locals we play puckleball with suggested it and it hasn't disappointed yet.

Service since COVID has been call in and describe your vehicle, once in the parking lot they bring out a receipt to pay and sign and then bring out the food. Everyone has been friendly and courteous

Excellent Pizza, perfect crust, not to thick just crispy enough. Fresh veggies were fabulous. Our Pizza had the best smoked bacon we have ever had. Polite, quick service, great price for quality of handmade pizza. Our only draw back was, the sauce is a touch sweet for our taste, but still a number pick of the local joints.

You have to understand small-town Dynamics to understand how big of a deal it is to admit this is the best pizza I've ever had. If you enjoy a sweet sauce, this is the best sauce I've ever had. And toppings are fantastic. In the morning at reheats and it's still of better quality than anything can get.

Closest thing to park Street without the drive and wait. Owner seems very classy, never lets my dad leave without sending him with a fresh pizza.

The General pizza is awesome. It should get an award for small town pizza.

Great food, everything tastes great.