Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery

ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS 😋.. THE KEY LIME CHEESECAKE ICE CREAM IS THE BEST ICE CREAM I'VE EVER HAD. THE CUPCAKES ARE MOIST AND NOT OVERLY SWEET. I USUALLY HAVE TO SCRAPE ICING OFF MY CUPCAKES BUT NOT ON THESE. CANT WAIT TO GO BACK AND TRY NEW FLAVORS.

I stopped in randomly on Friday. I picked up 3 red Velvet cupcakes and a peanut butter cupcake to take to my parents. They said they were the best cupcakes they had ever had. My Mom said the red velvet was absolutely delicious! I can’t wait to recommend them to brides. I will definitely be back to get more.

I’ve been in love with this place since I discovered it. When I got married last year I didn’t even question it, I knew I had to have them make my cake. I had already tasted most of the flavors they provided but I was delighted with the tasting session they provided for me. For my wedding, I ordered a custom cake (strawberry shortcake) and several mini cupcakes (strawberry shortcake and pumpkin spice) my wedding was Halloween themed as it was on the day and they did not disappoint! It was a way cheaper and tastier option in my opinion. Great job y’all! Can’t wait to come see you again. 🖤

They best cupcakes I have had in years.

I discovered this shop on the Yelp app and was beyond impressed! The service is super friendly and they are happy to talk you through options and personal and customer favorites. The cupcakes are really perfect in texture, fluffiness and flavor. I have only tried the cupcakes but they even do cakes and have Ice-cream too.

I recommend the Pink Vanilla Cupcake, Birthday Cupcake, or any of the filled ones like the Boston Cream Pie but I don’t think you can go wrong with any you decide on.

Amazing gluten free cupcakes. I have celiac disease and I am very symptomatic if I get “glutened” so I highly recommend this as a safe place! You may need to call ahead in advance to be sure they have gf or call ahead before the day you want them too.

The best cupcakes around! Creative flavors that keep well and don’t dry out. We loved the S’moreo and French toast blueberry. We also love the pup-cakes!

Definitely a must try if you’re in the area. They have decent amount of flavors. I did not get a chance to try a cupcake but I would definitely visit them and try it out.

This shop saved the day, after a birthday cake order was canceled by another shop. That was the best cancelation ever! It led me to this shop. The assorted cupcakes were absolutely DIVINE!!! So moist and delicious. Hands down best cupcakes in the greater Columbus area!

My husband and I ordered from Smallcakes for our wedding cake and cupcakes! Their cakes are so delicious and we got so many compliments on them!! They were easy to order from and picking up our order was also a breeze. Highly recommend this small business!

I ordered my wedding cake from Smallcakes and it was DIVINE. Truly incredible. My fiance (now husband 🥰) and I scheduled a cake testing appointment to sample different flavors and the entire process was so simple. We set up our appointment, arrived, and were given an assortment of mini cupcakes to sample (I can remember how many... 8-10, perhaps). We were told we could take the samples home to try or we could enjoy them at the bakery. We decided to stay there since I couldn't wait to try them. 😆 Eating several miniature cupcakes in one sitting was definitely a task in itself but choosing our favorite flavors was fun! Kimm, the owner, checked in on us and chatted with us about custom flavors, frosting styles, pricing, etc. I wasn't exactly the most organized bride (didn't really have a ton of structure when it came to planning the wedding lol) but Kimm helped make the cake/cupcake process smooth. I sent her photos of how I would like the cake to look, chose the flavors, and then gave her the color scheme of the wedding and told her to have fun with it. 🤩 Our guests RAVED over the cupcakes and the cake. For the cake, the top tier was wedding cake flavor and the bottom tier was cookies and creme. 😍 The cupcakes were either chocolate, strawberry shortcake, or wedding cake. Everything was so so so so tasty. The cupcakes were gone within no time! 🧁 I had people asking me left and right where we ordered from. I should have ordered more. 🤣😅 I cannot recommend Smallcakes enough. ✅

P.S. The cost for everything was beyond reasonable. Most places that I looked into charged sooo much money. After everything was said and done, I believe I paid around $200 and I'm pretty sure that price included delivery. 🤯

Ordered off of Grubhub today and am so glad I did ! The cupcakes were moist, fluffy, and aesthetically pleasing . I hate cupcakes that are sooo sweet you can barely enjoy them, these were not overbearing like that at all, they were the perfect balance . This hands down is the best cupcake place I’ve had in the city thus far . I will be returning, telling my friends, and likely getting an event catered soon . I recommend the Boston crème, strawberry shortcake, and classic white or chocolate with pink icing .

We worked with Kimm of Smallcakes Cupcakery and Creamery for our fall wedding in 2022. She was incredibly informative, assisting us with wedding cake design ideas and working with our wedding planner for timelines. She communicated in a timely manner and was always willing to answer any questions we had. We received so many compliments from the delicious cupcakes and wedding cake that Smallcakes made for our wedding. We are so grateful to Kimm and her team for being part of our special day and the amazing sweet treats! Thank you!

As beautiful as the cupcakes and cakes are they taste even better and sadly I cannot share that through a photo. Do yourself a favor and go try their cupcakes/cakes. These were for my daughters 5th bday and everyone loved them!

I order from Smallcakes for every occasion in our family. The cupcakes are great, and the custom cakes and cupcakes are always a huge hit with my family and friends. The cupcakes and cakes are not only decorated beautifully but delicious!

Had one of their cakes for my wedding. It was not only beautiful, but extremely delicious!!!!

Me and my daughter first time there today and when we got home to try to cupcake and ice cream we got she loved it so much she inhaled the cupcake in less then 2 mins 🤣
Definitely will be coming back!

Loved my birthday cake. I asked specifically for strawberry cake with cream cheese frosting. It was amazing! I will definitely order my next birthday cake from here again!

I went here on my Birthday to get some cupcakes because I have had them many times at work and there really is nothing like this. The cake it self is so moist and delicious. I got the 6 pack and spent about $22 however again these may be the best cupcakes I have tasted!! If you get a chance to check this place out or get some cupcakes from them you should. They also have Ice cream and are now making cookies. If this review helped you at all please mark as helpful and follow me for more around the world.

We ordered a smash cake with assorted cupcakes for my son’s first birthday. Working with Kimm made the process very easy. They made the cutest little tree stump for the smash cake. The cupcakes were insanely delicious and everyone raved about them. Worth every penny! Thank you for helping to make my little one’s day special.

Went w daughter and granddaughter and we ordered 3 different cupcakes. We ate them there. They were fantastic to say the least. The icing was awesome and the cake was so moist it melted in your mouth. They were so good we ordered more to take home. I also ordered ice cream and had a few bites- creamy and very flavorful. Delightful 😊