Fate Cakes

Amazing place. I enjoyed the cookies I tried so i decided to have her make a birthday cake for my daughter. It turned out amazing. The taste the presentation of it all was top notch. Thank you so much for making my baby girl Birthday special. She will even check in with you to make sure everything turned out fine.

Inquired online for my wife’s 40th birthday. Very quick response. Did a great job walking me through my options, made helpful recommendations and provided pictures for reference. Completely exceeded my expectations. The cake and cupcakes looked and tastes amazing. The cookies were absolutely giant. Packaging was fantastic. Always responsive and satisfaction follow up after the even. I felt the price was extremely reasonable given what was provided. Couldn’t ask for more. Very well done!

My daughter and I love Fate Cakes! Marie has made many cakes for different events over the years that turn out perfect every time. Our most recent cake was my favorite (pictured). We also love her sweets in the store. We most recently had a sweet similar to a zebra cake, it was sooooo good. Marie has such great customer service.

We had Fate Cakes make a 1/4 sheet cake for a graduation dinner and it did not disappoint! The cake was light and fluffy. The frosting wasn’t too sweet, just perfect! My graduate said “the cake definitely didn’t taste like a store bought cake!”

The decor was perfect for our celebration! I highly recommend Fate Cakes for all of your dessert needs!

Marie at Fate Cakes was beyond amazing to work with! Very responsive and made our vision come to light! She definitely made sure we had the best experience, service, and really cared. The cake and cupcakes tasted AMAZING and everything was so perfect! Couldn’t have asked for a better overall experience!

This was the absolute best wedding cake we have ever had. Cake was so moist, fruit filling was the perfect accompaniment and the icing was not overpowering with sweetness. The cake was stunningly gorgeous! If I could give a 100 star review I would! Marie was incredible to work with, patient kind and understanding!

We cannot recommend Fate Cakes more. Cake tastes great at a good price. She was able to capture the look we wanted perfectly. The tasting box was perfect for us to choose our favorite combo of cake, filing and icing. After the wedding, people reached out for information about where we got the cake. It’s my new go to bakery for events!

We aren’t normally cake people and contemplating just getting a sheet cake at the grocery store. We’re so glad we went this route. We’ll have to order a small one for our anniversary because it wouldn’t survive in our freezer for a year.

She’s also great for people who like to plan ahead and stay organized.

We decided to order from Fate Cakes for our daughter's first birthday party. We wanted a smash cake and cupcakes to go with the "Sweet to BEE One" theme. Marie reached out soon after our inquiry to help us complete the order. Communication was easy via text! We got so many compliments on the look and taste of the cake and cupcakes. It was exactly what we wanted and will be using them again for future events. Marie even reached out after to make sure we were happy!!

Fate Cakes is AMAZING! They have been our go to bakery for all our family events-including birthday cakes, wedding cakes and most recently, our gender reveal cake! We love the Victorian Almond flavor and she was wonderful with coloring the internal frosting the correct color. We wanted to be surprised too by giving her a sealed note from the doctor and she did a great job ensuring we didn’t know ahead of time. We will forever be returning customers!

I recently purchased a Fate Cakes custom cake and my experience was fantastic! I had called around town to ask about a gold cake for my daughter’s golden birthday and Marie was responsive, professional, and up for the challenge. She did such a wonderful job on the presentation and the cake was delicious! I recommend Fate Cakes for your sweet treat needs.

Absolute perfection! Ordered a custom OSU graduation cake and cupcakes. The cake as well as the cupcakes had buckeyes on them. All were incredibly delicious! Fate Cakes were the icing on the cake to the graduation celebration!

The entire experience was great from placing the order and working with decorator/owner to pickup. Everyone loved the well balance taste and the filing that made this such a great choice of getting our cake from Fate Cakes. I would recommend to all my family and friend for future business with Fate Cakes because how well this turned out.

Marie was so easy to work with! She reached out promptly about the details for our cake and matched my vision perfectly. The cake itself was delicious and multiple guests raved about the flavor. We will definitely be using Fate Cakes for our future birthday parties!

Have nothing but positive things to say about their cakes! Absolutely stunning and delicious as well. They were so easy to work and with collaborate with as well. We got lots of compliments on how good it tasted! Not to mention the smash cake was just the cutest 😊

Absolutely perfect experience with Fate Cakes! I just asked for a simple cake for my birthday and not only she offered one but also asked me for a design which was an unexpected detail!
I received books for my birthday so I asked for colors to match my books and she outdone herself with this amazing cake. The cake turned out better than expected, simple but with character.
I liked that we could communicate via messages and was a smooth experience. I’ll definitely go back for my kids birthday cakes!

Fate Cakes makes awesome cakes that look exactly like the photos you show them. Marie puts so much care into each cake, making it feel like it's for her own party. Not only are the cakes delicious, but the baker is also a really great person. I used Fate cakes for many of my family’s occasions. Trust me, your party will be magical and very special because she makes it with love and you’ll feel like family❤ Best bakery in Ohio, Highly recommended!

Bought my wife a cake for her 30th birthday and decided to go with Fate Cakes since they were close and had personalized options. The owner was very responsive and quick to respond to me after getting some ideas of what cake my wife would want. We were throwing a Mummy(1999) themed birthday and so we decided to go with a cake that replicated the book of the dead from the movie. It looked incredible and tasted great as well. Everyone loved as super impressed with the detail that went into it. Would definitely recommend and go back here for more.

Fate Cakes did an amazing job on our gender reveal cake! We will definitely be returning customers! Marie was so kind and understanding!! The cake turned out beautiful, and was so delicious!!

Absolutely LOVED the cake we ordered from Fate Cakes for my daughter’s birthday! The whole process was so smooth from beginning to end! It was easy to order and customize to our personal preferences. Customer service was wonderful!

As far as the cake itself, not only was the design impressive, it tasted beyond AMAZING too!!! (We went with her marble cake with vanilla frosting…. yummm!)

Overall so happy with our experience with Fate Cakes, she really helped make my daughter’s birthday so special! ✨

I'd never ordered a custom cake before, but if it's always this easy (and delicious!) I'll definitely be doing it again. I found Fate Cakes with a google search and had no idea what to expect. Marie was extremely responsive, helpful, and communicated clearly. My husband loved his Magic The Gathering themed cake and everyone thought it was delicious. My husband especially loved how the frosting tasted and as someone who doesn't really like icing very much, I can agree it was some of the best I've ever had. My favorite was the peanut butter filling. 10/10 for a great experience, a great cake and a great business!