Reilly's Cafe

Stopped by on a whim for a late lunch. Very impressed with the food. Had the special which was Guinness battered fish sandwich with coleslaw. All of it was really good including the perfectly crisp fries.

Awesome food awesome dessert came in today 5/2/2024

Great find just off the highway! Homey cafe with delicious food. The burgers appear to be very popular. My son had an order of boneless bbq wings that he thoroughly enjoyed. I had the panini special with Greek chicken in a pesto sauce. Even without the cheese sauce it was plenty moist. It came with a side of homemade pesto mashed potatoes and sautéed summer squash. All were absolutely delicious. Everything tasted fresh and homemade. The service was also terrific.

Had breakfast..was great. Quick and friendly service. Looks to be family run and which is always great to see.

I had a wonderful breakfast experience at Reilly’s Cafe in Marathon, NY. This cozy diner impressed me with its cleanliness and simple yet inviting decor.

Our breakfast choice was the Farmer’s Omelet, and it did not disappoint. The omelet was a perfect blend of fluffy eggs, fresh vegetables, and just the right amount of cheese. It was hearty without being overwhelming, a testament to the kitchen's skill in creating a balanced and tasty dish.

The service at Reilly’s Cafe added to the pleasant experience. The staff were friendly and efficient, ensuring our meal was enjoyable without being intrusive. They had a good knowledge of the menu and were quick to refill our coffee.

In summary, Reilly’s Cafe is a great choice for anyone in Marathon, NY, or passing by on I-81 looking for a satisfying, well-prepared breakfast, lunch or dinner in a comfortable setting. The Farmer’s Omelet is a must-try – simple, delicious, and exactly what a good breakfast should be.

This diner is really a gem. It's one place to get high quality food prepared with care at an incredibly reasonable price. You're sure to be satisfied.

We had the new years eve specials and they were perfectly cooked. Steaks were amazing and priced very reasonable. Staff was great and food was served hot and fast.

Great food and great service! Highly recommend the Chicken cordon Bleu Salad.

Awesome place to get great food .Staff is amazing and takes great pride in taking care of their customers 👏

Reilly’s Cafe is finally opened for breakfast, lunch and dinner and the food is fresh and excellent ;) I will be coming here often.

What a wonderful cafe with great food, friendly staff and better than fair prices. And save room for the pie!

Looks like an Irish Pub on the outside, but a diner on the inside. It was just what we were looking for as we were traveling down the high way - short distance off the interstate, inexpensive breakfast menu, tasty omelets, decent coffee, local color and pleasant staff. Very much enjoyed our breakfast here.and would go back.

Had a lovely breakfast at Reilly’s Cafe! Great service is always nice but I was seriously wowed by the food. A very unexpected amazing food experience while road tripping. Looking for breakfast near marathon? GO HERE!

Tasty, homemade type food. Nice people. Good value for the $. Perfect stop when driving through the area. Much better than some lousy chain or fast food restaurant. Recommend 👍

A hidden Jem!! Breakfast was delicious and the portions were good. Everyone was very friendly, must give it a try if you’re looking for that small hometown dinner with ample seating.

A small town and everytime we pass through we stop because it has the absolute best food and the friendliest staff you could find anywhere. A very large selection on the menu, things you wouldn't expect to find in such a tiny village. Food is served hot and quickly which is really quite impressive given the menu. Only maybe 7 or 8 tables yet the prices are extremely reasonable. We've never had to wait but we always see locals that know each other. They do take out also. Just really good people and really good food at excellent prices. One of our favorite stops! It's well worth the stop on your way 81N towards Syracuse, NY and beyond and again on your way south to the Triple Cities and beyond.

Great food. Maybe helpful to order ahead if you don't want to wait. Bigger parties may want to call ahead

I stopped here on May 20th, on my way back home to Webster, NY. I had a cheeseburger and New England clam chowder. Let me first say I am very VERY picking about chowder. I have to say I was extremely impressed how great it tasted. It's homemade and it definitely shows the skills of the owner who makes it. It's a two hour drive from my house and I would totally make the trip for the chowder. I may just do that soon. The owner was very nice and so was the waitress.

We had lunch here on our way to Niagra from NJ. Excellent hospitality and food. My children were 9 and 4 and this place was friendly. Some of our fondest memories...

Beautiful luncheonette. Had breakfast there. Good food. Good prices. Nice people