Clayton's Toys

Great local toy store. Even had some Buffalo Bills stuff. They have a good selection of classic books, stuffed animals wooden puzzles to great Halloween costumes.There is more parking in back to the right side, so don't try to squeeze in the insanely tight spots in front of the door.

Best toy store in Buffalo NY.
Has tons and tons of toys!

Always a treat to visit Clayton’s. They have good, quality toys and provide personal service. They have toys that stand the test of time. You can’t beat their classic offerings as well as their new discoveries.

First time here. Not sure what took me so long. What a wonderful shop for unique toys and gifts. It's definitely worth the trip.

Old school toy store. Very well stocked with a wide variety of products (original scratch and sniff stickers!), helpful staff and reasonably priced. Highly recommended.

Best hometown toy shop. My kids loved the shelves of toys and experience. Highly recommend to anyone.

Cute and small toys! My kids love it! Birthday and Christmas gifts, this is THE SPOT!

Thank you so much! This is where I got my dog and a few other wonderful toys for my children. The staff here is always so friendly and helpful and gift wrapped my presents that I bought for my children as well. Whether I come here to browse or to buy, I love shopping at this store

Cutest toy store! Filled with a very well curated and a wide selection of toys for all ages. Great place for books, puzzles, and games too. Staff is super helpful and kind. I will always aim to shop here for presents for kids and babies. I think ill always end up with a better gift and experience than going to target or shopping on Amazon.

Clayton's toys store has earned some special respect over couple of years. Oldest run toy store in the US, it is also amazingly well managed. Be it - choice of excellent STEM toys across age groups or pricing of the same... Very wide range... Must visit for kids of ages 1 through 99+...

My “go-to” and for good reason! Wonderful staff, great selection and always friendly. I always find what I’m looking for here :)

What a beautiful and special toy store in the middle of Williamsville that is so welcoming. Going there with the helpful and friendly chatty staff sparks one’s imagination for play. My daughter loved it and we all found some toy or puzzles to buy. It brought out the kid in all of us!! They have a great selection of toys for infants to adults for all kinds of fun and learning play!! We need more toy stores like this around!!

Friendly helpful staff, excellent selection of toys. Much larger than it appears, but parking/ street/ access is a bit dicey. I love this toy store, it has everything you need! 👍

A lot of selections, a little bit over-proced, but still recommended.

This place is very unique, all in good ways. They have stuff here you won't find at traditional stores that carry similar categories or products. Their stuffed animals almost seem to be hand picked, as there's no abundance of one specific kind, but they do have it all, from traditional farm animals, bears, tropical animals, to kawaii cutesy stuff, all seemingly very high quality, with an expected price to match it however. They offer free wrapping of gifts here for anything you may want wrapped, and they do a great job at it, comes with a little sticker, and a cute little ribbon bow. They're very on par with professional Christmas Gift wrapping, which is a talent they're offering with every purchase. They also have a lot of baby stuff (like toys and comfort things). Things like board games and dolls can also be found here. This is one of those kinds of stores you can stop into even if you don't have anything in mind, and you'll probably find something you want to take home. Staff is also very, very friendly and great at communicating, when I came in it was almost like my family worked there, and I was just stopping by to visit them, overall, great store.

Best toy store ever. They have mood rings! Do you hear what saying people? Mood rings!! The toy selection is varied with a touch of class. Found a great STEM game here. Staff is very polite and helpful.

I truly can not express how much I LOVE this place. The ladies working there are so sweet and wholesome. I love the variety of toys they have. They have toys that are S.T.E.M., crafts, dress up, books, nostalgic "older" toys, and toys for babies/toddlers. I bring my finacé and my daughter in everytime, and both times I am amazed by what I see and experience. My daughter, being my pride and joy, often gets compliments and praise (cause really who doesn't love babies?), and she completely indulges in it, especially with these ladies! Everyone in my family leaves with a smile on their face, and I'm grateful to have found this place not too far from my home. Love, love, love, love it here.

I would have never gone into this store without reason. I had seen a toy that someone bought for one of my grandchildren there. I wanted to get another one for another grandchild.
We walked into a wonderful experience!
Clayton's was filled, wall to wall with the most amazing toys. It transported me back to wonderful childhood memories of going shopping at true toy stores with my Grandmother.
There are so many unique, adorable, imaginative toys in the shop! Be prepared to spend some quality time looking at everything.
Most amazingly, the prices are down right reasonable and affordable! Not to mention they offer unique toys that you can't find anywhere else!
Clayton's is definitely a gem. The ladies we checked out with were very friendly and helpful.
I only wish we had found this gem sooner! Fond memories, great toys and nostalgia really made my holidays so much brighter!

Workers were very helpful and knowledgeable about their products. Gave me many ideas from which I could decide. Felt very important while I was there and the gifts I chose for my grandchildren I'm sure will be a hit! Will always come back here to shop. Best toy store in town or around!!!

So many great toys, and the staff was fantastic. We brought a 2 year old into the store, and the staff was great about letting him try different toys and making recommendations. There are a couple play areas set up to keep a child busy while you shop. They have unique toys I have not seen anywhere else, modern toys, and also some old fashioned fun toys, such as a rubber band propelled boat.