Ye Olde Pizza Pub

I think the food there tastes great. Yea it is a little soggy but i like it. Pizza is great. Everyone has there own opinion on things and thats fine. For me i like it there

I've eaten there for years and have known the family that owns it for years. Great food Great friends and a nice place to hang out.

This place used to be a favorite for many people. In the last 3 or 4 years, it has taken a turn. The food is definitely not as good as it used to be. The whole place is run by teenagers. You'll never see anyone older than 18 or 19 there. We used to LOVE the pizza, taters, and chicken wings. Now, every time we get food from there, we talk about not wanting to get it again. The quality of the food has just decreased. I got a fish fry there today that was so gross. The fish had to have been frozen. Typically, if you get a fish fry at any local pizzerias on a Friday, it's fresh, and they either beer battered it or breaded it themselves. This was 100% not done at the pizza pub. It's very sad to lose this once treasured restaurant. I have been eating there for more than 20 years. But I really don't recommend it anymore.

Good food. Pizza was good, can't go wrong with tater wedges and wings. When you get wings, ask for extra crispy!

Great place for pizza and tiny wings. It’s been 30 years since the last time I was here. The place hasn’t changed, it is still a great place to go to.

My Great Grandfather helped build this place and any time I travel home to visit it is a must. The food has never let me down and is a great place for all ages. I am so glad that they have started to allow eating in again and I look forward to returning.

I ordered here as a first time customer and was told to try it and they were right. The pizza was made the way I wanted it the wings were good as well I have really no complaints and will definitely go again

Great pizza and wings. I have tried most pizzas in the area and this is the best - the crust is the difference - fluffy not chewy. Takeout only during pandemic - unique, rustic bench seating is cozy and fun. Low lighting great for my sensitive eyes

It was our first time going there and we will definitely be back. The Antipasto and Pizza were delicious 😍

I love their mountain taters! I always get pizza and wings as well, never disappointed! 😁 I have been eating here for 40 years and I hope for 40 more! So yum! 😁

I have made going to the pizza pub a yearly thing. Thoroughly enjoy their wings, and they're pizza I'd always phenomenal. Good atmosphere. They have Boomerang playing on a projector so you get all your favorite classic cartoons. Not to mention they serve alcohol. My only complaint about the place is that it isn't very well heated. So if you go during the cold season be sure to wear a coat! Other 100% satisfied.

This place has a rustic atmosphere with a family friendly vibe..The pizza is great and the staff even better. Good service and a great attitude always makes the food taste better.😎👍

Was an excellent visit. They have a very nice salad bar and their pizza is the best around. I grew up in Jersey and Ye Olde Pizza Pub is the only place with pizza like home. Delicious crust and the sauce and toppings are the best. Have been there many times and will continue to go back.

I haven't been to this place in about 15 years, but judging from the pictures it's looks like Ye Olde Pizza Pub.

This review makes no pretence at objectivity. The Pub is my idea of comfort food, pizza style. From the cheese mix on the pizza, to the sausage, to the taters and blu cheese the Pub offers a superior pizza experience. The pizza isn't foo-foo and the darkish dining area and bench seating may not appeal to everyone but, for nearly half a century people have come for miles to get their Pub food. Enjoy!!

Sooooo busy with takeout they didn't have time for those who dined in. Pizza was 1 1/2 hour wait. Antipasto salad is huge.

Got some wings n taters to go. Glad to see the place hasn't changed a. It in 30 years. Best Buffalo wings on earth are made here

I love their pizza! I've been coming here ever since I was a kid. I moved to Florida 34 years ago, but I still make it a point to eat here (multiple dinners) each time I visit Hamilton. There's a couple of video games and a huge projector screen playing cartoons to keep the kids occupied.

The "Pub" as it is known, has the best pizza in the area...not kidding. I have been going since I was a young kid and now I am near 60. The open seating at large old picnic tables reveals the generations of teens that have etched their names in history. The Pub offers a large screen projection tv, that plays family friendly movies. Aside from the pizza favorites, the Pub is famous for the "tators"and the beautiful salad bar. Yes Olde Pizza Pub is perfect for birthday parties and impromptu gatherings.

The Pizza Pub is a great family meal in a wonderful setting. A slice of time is yours when you carve your name in a table then come back years later to reminisce. Amazing food