Pepi's Pizza

Got take out for lunch here today. Excellent service. The guy who helped us was very nice and attentive, he came outside to let me know the pizza was ready since we had been parked outside a couple of minutes, and he made sure I left with plates and napkins. Atmosphere was quaint and unpretentious in the best way. They should be busier! But perhaps it was the time of day. Wish I had remembered to tip, will have to tip double next time. We will definitely be back. If you haven't checked it out yet, you should! Great location the off of greenfield in downtown west allis. Pizza was DELICIOUS. We had the large thin crust with pepperoni, green olive, and onion and it was only $20 even. Don't know if that was some kind of special, but that was an amazing price, especially considering it was a high quality pizza made with clearly fresh ingredients.

Every time I come back to WI from TN, I look for a great pizza place. This is it! I My wife and I agree, best we’ve ever had. Sausage is phenomenal!

One of the best pizza’s I’ve ever had. It is also amazing in the air fryer the next day. Our waitress was amazing and the cook way to go! If you have not tried their pizza, you were missing out.

Hidden gem. Owner is super nice - they cook a great 'well done' pizza if you ask. Classic milwaukee thin crust pie.

Great prices too with reasonable hours and even online ordering. I usually order carry out and park right in front on the street.

This place deserves more recoginition in the milwaukee pizza community it stands up with the likes of Marias and Zaffiros easily!

Dave Portnoy come on done to Pepi's. It's an incredible pie! The crust is crisp, the undercarriage is firm with a bit of a char. The cheese is most delicious. I would like to consider myself a pizza aficionado. It probably stemmed from the fact that my mother ate nothing but pizza while pregnant with me. I'm no Dave, but believe me, we share the same brain waves when it comes to pizza. If you are looking for a great pie, stop by Pepi's and grab one or ten, but, you don't have to take my word for it!

Husband picked up 2 par baked pizzas. Very tasty as they always have been! REMINDER: if cooking right on rack, brush off corn meal or you'll have one Smokey house. I learned my lesson. Very tasty pizza!!!

Came here for a date night with my husband and was blown away by the value. Chicken nuggets, 2 beers, and a 4 topping large pizza for only $33 - a STEAL. Plus the folks working here are kind and attentive. Definitely coming back!

Me and a friend stopped in there for some pizza. At the time we went, it wasn't busy, so we were able to immediately seat ourselves. The atmosphere is a little plain, but you can see they added some smaller nice touches.

The owner came out and sat down with us, and we had an excellent conversation. It was nice hearing about the story behind the restaurant.

We ordered a thin crust pizza, which tasted great. The crust was nice and thin with a nice crisp to it. The crust also had the cornmeal coating, which I personally am a big fan of.

Would be nice if they delivered where I live, but, regardless, I still plan on visiting again.

Been a customer for 55 years! There’s no pizza like Pepies
If you like thin crust and good sausage you will love ❤ it

Food was deliscious and customer service was even better. Very engaging friendly and very kind to kids. Will definitely be visiting again for some more good food.

Fun family time at Pepi’s! Amazing thin crust! We felt so welcomed with our large group. We even played the piano. Thank you!

Love this place! I eat there and have delivery. Taste is the same as it was years ago on S. 16th Street. Owners/service/delivery guy all amazing people.

One of the BEST pizza places in Wisconsin. The owner was awesome and nice to talk with, came and checked on us and chatted. Just an all around good experience. Would highly recommend making this your go to pizza joint. Pizza was DELICIOUS!!
You wont be disappointed.

Wonderful experience. Food was super delicious and fast. Friendly helpful wait staff.owwner even came to our table and had a delight conversation. Well done.

My son and I decided to visit a locally owned pizza joint. After searching around a bit, I found this one. Since we were being served before 3:00 pm, a large pizza with two toppings was $13. We chose Sausage and Pepperoni. We also ordered some very tasty garlic bread ($5.25). Toss in a couple of sodas and we thought we'd be looking at around $25.

The owner was incredibly helpful and pointed out the special of large pizza w/two toppings option. He was friendly and we felt at home with him.

All of the above is irrelevant if the food is no good. Thankfully, the food was spectacular. I thought that when we started eating it, we'd have upwards of a 1/2 left. I was wrong. We ate it all. It was that good. Talked to the owner and the Sausage they use is their own blend. The crust was very thin (the way I like it). It was not stiff but was flexible. The Sauce was very good as well.

After all that, the guy said: $20 for the meal. We gave him $30. It was worth it.

If you like thin crust pizza, this is the place to go. Closed on Tuesdays.

First time for lunch today, just stopped somewhere to eat. Service from Ricky was really great he always had a smile and a joke 😂😂 conversation truly organic. On top of that, pizza was so good ❤! I wasn’t even that hungry but couldn’t stop eating it! One of my top 3 pizza joints in the Milwaukee area. Great time!

I have been eating Pepi’s Pizza for over 50 years. You can’t find a crust like that anywhere we ordered tonight company from out of town everyone raved about it they never disappoint us.
I will always give them 5 stars.

Best pizza and garlic bread in Milwaukee! The owners are fantastic and very easy to get along with. Great stop for a bite to eat with the family, or just stopping in for a slice! Same great taste every time!

A good MKE style thin crust pizza. And the owner Ricci is a super nice guy, who enjoys chatting with the customers and carrying on the Pepi's tradition.

The pizza was great and right on time! Loved the wing sauce and garlic bread! The onion straws and wings could have been cooked another minute for browning but when delivering food; rather err on the lighter side as it tends to keep cooking. We will definitely order again! Website was very easy to navigate. We did 1/2 pizza with one topping and 1/2 with another. Very easy to order and checkout. Very pleased with everything:)