My Island Ice Cream

Boy, oh boy. The changes Anthony and Erin have made are outstanding. They are serving the BEST Ice cream and serving it with a smile and genuine appreciation for your business. 70 flavors of ice cream, pup cups, shakes, malts. It just AWESOME, you gotta try it. Still the best..... only better! ❤

Best place around. The most amazing flavor assortment, huge scoops, friendly staff and super cute decor. Always feels like a friendly place to go after dinner.

🍦Super Friendly Staff, Unique Interior, 70 Delicious Flavors!🍦

I discovered My Island Ice Cream by accident while stopping at the Publix nearby. The interior is a pleasant surprise. I've included pictures so that you can see for yourself!

The staff are super friendly and considerate. I truly believe they would have let me sample all 70 ice cream flavors if I'd asked. The Dark Raspberry and Butterscotch flavors were to die for, and all four people in my party got something that had them sighing, "YUMMMMM!"

I've been a Google Reviewer for some time now and never seen an ice cream shop with over 300+ reviews at a 5 out of 5 star rating. Tasting is believing, and this ice cream tastes amazing--but that 5-star rating is due to more than just the product. The environment and the staff make My Island Ice Cream what it is. This place is worthy of your patronage. Treat your sweet tooth--and your soul--to a bit of goodness! We'll be back :D

This is a fantastic place! 70 flavors, and if you only like vanilla, they still have the best of that too. Very friendly, locally owned atmosphere. Definitely will be back again and again!

Enjoyed Memorial Day eating ice cream at this family-owned restaurant. (I think owned by the couple that also run the shop themselves.)

Decor has that Florida charm--
Surfboards, beach motifs & Elvis.

OVER 70 flavors !
I'm amazed at how many flavors they have.

I tried the spumoni & strawberry cheesecake. Strawberry cheesecake had real strawberry & cheesecake bits.
My friend got the May flavor of the month; not sure what the name was but it tasted good too.

Look forward to coming back and trying other flavors.

Ice cream is excellent. Service fast and friendly. Atmosphere nice ….inside. Outside they have nice tables with umbrellas buuuut it is in the middle of a parking lot. Overall, highly recommend this place.
I have to try the dairy free options!
Smaller portions would be appreciated. Currently you can only get a small scoop of vanilla and no other flavor.

So happy to find this place! It's so good that if I lived on the next street, I'd be over here every day, even in the winter!! I'd give it 10 stars if I could! Their prices are less than others & their hand dipped ice cream is better! They have so many flavors, 70 to be exact, that it's hard to choose. Some are Lactose free & some are sugar free. But they are ALL regret free! They'll even give you a sample to help you make your mind up!
The owners, Micah & Sharon are super friendly and on the ball.
You definitely have to try My Island Ice Cream; in front of T-J Max!

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

What a gem of an ice cream shop on Merritt Island! From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with genuine warmth and personalized attention that makes you feel right at home. The staff here truly goes above and beyond to make a connection with every customer, which sets this place apart from the rest.

And let's talk about the ice cream - absolutely divine! The flavors are rich, creamy, and bursting with deliciousness. Whether you're a fan of classic favorites or adventurous creations, they have something for everyone. Each scoop is a little piece of heaven in a cone.

I can't recommend this place enough. If you're looking for top-notch service, a welcoming atmosphere, and mouthwatering ice cream, look no further than this fantastic shop on Merritt Island. Don't miss out on this sweet experience!

We loved this ice cream shop!!!! Great service and wow the ice cream is WOW, yummy, you go there one time you will be back!!! They even have Sugar free ice cream, I had a sample it was Delicious!!! Try once you will go back again!!!!!!

The Purple Daze (Black Raspberry with chocolate chunks) is outstanding! The staff is super friendly & the ice cream shop is very clean. There was a line out the door the entire time we were there, I guess others like it as much as we do.

So for 4 years since I have been here in Florida living I have been looking for a specific ice cream flavor I loved as a child and it has been found in this beautiful shop they have over 65 flavors available and Real bubble gum ice cream is my ultimate favorite flavor which they have. Not only is this shop beautifully decorated it is owned and operated by a very lovely older couple Whom are very welcoming and very pleasant to speak with. I will definitely be going back not only for my childhood favorite but to try some of those 65 other ice cream selections.

We found this place on a whim and have been back several times! The staff is outrageously nice and patient, and they have something like 77 flavors! We highly recommend coming here if you’re in the area. Can’t go wrong with a single thing here. 10/10 our new go to place for ice cream!

Love this place! Over 70 flavors including sugar free and dairy free. The owners literary work there and do all the scooping. Sweetest couple ever.
Lots of seating, short friendly atmosphere. Closed Thursdays.

Definitely one of the best ice creams I have ever had! Rich, full of flavor, not to sugary tasting deliciousness!! Can’t wait to go there again when we visit!

We had such a great experience on our first visit while we were visiting family in Merritt Island that my 4 year old asked to go back the very next night for more ice cream. The workers (I am assuming the owners) even recognized us from our visit the previous night. The ice cream, service, and atmosphere were great. I am 100% sure that this will be a place we will stop for ice cream when we make our annual trip from New York to the Merritt Island/Cocoa Beach area! I highly recommend this place along with an endorsement from both my wife and 4 year old daughter.

This was our favorite ice cream place we found on our recent trip. It's the same brand many ice cream shops have, but the service was excellent, not rushed, and the atmosphere was fun. Another customer congratulated me for eating my whole cone :)

I’ve been to this shop many times and always have had great service. I wanted to write a review because the gentleman who is usually always there went out of his way to make me something that my elderly uncle could eat more easily! Way to help your community and serve yummy ice cream as well!!

Yes! This place is top. Everything about this place is outstanding. The greetings from the staff, their nice smiles, positive vibes and great service. The ice cream is the best and the decorations are beautiful 😍
Will save this location as one of our favorite places and come back 🙏😊

The ice cream is great! Soft and creamy. The attention of the staff/owner is also good. They were very nice and asked us how the ice cream was afterwards. My service dog really enjoyed the pup cup as well! (A little too much, since he was eating the cup as well 😂)

Amazing shop! So warm and welcoming to new people. The ice cream here is superb. We came here every single day of our vacation. You can't go wrong with a flavor.