Benny DiCarta's

So I was at work this week at some guy asked how my day was..I said I was hungry lol, tell me why he reaches in his car thingy thing to get me a card for one free slice!!!!! The way he made my day, fast-forward to today I went in and got served a huge piece of pizza that I had to share with my girlfriend because of the monstrous size! It was so good and surprisingly juicy for it to be thin, we didn't need any sauce or extra toppings just plain old pepperoni 🥰 definitely coming back for more! I hope that guy comes back too, I'll get you some food on the house 😁🫵🏽‼

First time visiting and well worth the time!
Met the owner and received a very unique history of the business and their artistic passion in New York style pizza.
While there may be limited options for pizza (cheese, pepperoni, specialty, and mushroom garlic), their specialty pizzas rotate and provide a unique name and an ingredient list to match. The crust is light with a unique crunch throughout.
Be aware that these pizzas and their slices are MASSIVE! You will not be disappointed.

Read a few reviews and figured I would stop in for a quick slice before grabbing dinner later. The "Slice" was $6 even. I had no idea I would be getting not only the biggest slice I have ever had but also one of the best damn pizzas I have ever had. Sauce was on point, crust was nice and crispy. No flop at all on this baby

Staff was nice and quick, pizza was amazing. 10/10. I'll be back tomorrow 🤤

Stopped in today for the first time and we loved everything about this pizza joint. Previously from Jersey it’s great to find a NY Pizza gem near by. The service was super friendly and helpful and the pizza slices were huge. We can’t wait to go back soon!

Oh my! Walking distance to this pizzeria is dangerous....dangerously GOOD! First time visit today and I see many, many future visits! Had half Pepperoni and half Tarantino (Chicken, Bacon, Ranch). Excellent service and delicious pizza!! Great variety of canned and bottled drink selections.

OMG THATS CRUST YALLLLLLL
Every and any time I’m in town I will be forever a customer. That’s the best pizza I’ve eaten in my entire life. I would like a slice now lol but I’m back in Mississippi now. Thank you

I really loved my slice of pizza. The service was super friendly, and the atmosphere rocked. I will definitely be back!

The pizza was great. Huge slices with tons of flavor.

Just checked out Benny's for the first time today. Got a slice of pepperoni with some garlic dipping sauce. It might just be the single best slice of pizza in kzo. It's greasy and savory in the best way. The crust is also amazing, and I recommend some dipping sauce as the sheer size of the slice means you essentially get a giant breadstick.

Also ended up getting the key lime ice cream bar which was fantastic! Go for the large, as the small is basically the size of a cake pop.

Service was great. The two guys running the shop were friendly and polite. I let them know I'd never been there and they were happy to run me through the menu.

Def stop in for a slice of finely crafted pizza!

Highly recommend a slice is enough to fill you up in my case great flavors and all done right in front of your eyes.
The staff is super nice and the atmosphere is great will be coming back for the whole pizza this time.

Pizza by the slice, and the biggest full size pizzas I've ever seen in Michigan!
Good selection of canned and bottled drinks that include FAYGO!!!! This is New York style pizza that you fold in half to eat. The crust alone is absolutely amazing and worth eating on its own. They could make different kinds of bread sticks and I'd buy that too! It's also a great value! The pizza slices are so big, they're served on two standard paper plates!

The pizza was really fantastic. Thin, crispy crust; thin flavorful sauce; big fat mushrooms and this wonderful garlic layer. It was the best slice of pie I've had since I moved to Kazoo. I'm definitely coming back.

Went on New Years Eve, busy, but service was great. My boyfriend, a Chicago man, even said this pizza is very good which is a huge compliment. He had never seen a pizza that big and was glad we ordered by the slice. We'll be back.

Outrageously huge pizza that remind me of the east coast. Delicious! Indoor dining area is limited for bigger parties. Not many topping or customization options but that just makes it easy.

Great pizza huge box and 7 selections they cook it right there in front of you!

This place is a gem 😍 Absolutely delicious pizza, friendly staff, + a super cute shop! If you're looking for that super iconic foldable pizza slice this is it. Already planning a return trip to share it with more friends!

Huge pizza and it was delicious and the staff was super friendly! Thanks guys! Will definitely be back here again.

The garlic mushroom pizza is INCREDIBLE! Great prices for a slice of pizza that's more than I can eat in one sitting! Patio area out back is nice, service is always fast, and the seating inside is always clean!

Please do not be fools like us and ignore the fact that they only serve 28 inch pizzas. Therefore, those are the slice sizes you will be getting. We ordered 4 slices (not a smart move. We could have shared 1 lol) which basically added up to the size of your average pizza.
You'll pay 6-7 for each slice but for the size it's worth it and the toppings are great.

The pizzas were huge!! Biggest slices I’ve ever eaten but would highly recommend getting. Great quality and flavor. Service was quick and efficient