Coney Island Diner

I just visited Coney Island about 10 days ago, and just have to say, the dogs now taste just like they did 60 years ago when I first ate there. I was really surprised by the turn around that has transpired there. they’ve got it right now!

So this time I went in for brunch I had French toast with strawberry compo and they are homemade corn beef hash which is absolutely a must. My wife had The fried chicken BLT and then you can't go wrong with fresh fried chicken. Also trying out their very delicious Mexican hot dog jalapenos bacon cheese mustard delicious sauce it's so good next time I'm getting at least 2 to 4 of those.

For the first time in years it was good beef hotdogs sauce was excellent told the server /owner great job 👍

As good as I remember. Coney dogs are one of those nostalgic things I have to have whenever I visit the area. Great service. Staff was friendly and accomodating. Prices are still very reasonable. Highly recommend!

Fantastic customer service and fantastic food. Will definitely eat here again!

Taste of home. This location does not have the ambiance of the original and it may seem a little shady, but the Coney Island hotdog has not changed and is my benchmark for any chili dog. Missing the rice pudding.

Excellent
Hadn't been there in years, stopped in for a couple Coney dogs
Just like the old days and I mean the 1960s
Good job
Brings back good memories and I will be back

I used to come here regularly... I mean weekly sometimes 2 or 3 times a week... Always good service and good food... Since I've moved i haven't been here but hopefully i will be there soon

Happy I found this place during quarantine. really amazing breakfast! The customer service is great as well. The lady Just wish they had more vegetarian options.

Go there every couple days for the 3 meat spicy skillet. Great staff that follows a great owner. The staff and owner go out of there way to make sure you feel welcomed and satisfied!!

Nice place been goin there for yrs food is goood prices r kinda high.

Brooklyn's amusement park. You got to love it. Come prepared to spend money. Prices are not what they were back in the day. But you'll have fun and there is also the free beach.

This is my go to place when I'm in Middletown. I love love this place. The service and the food is excellent. Just a shame that I don't live close by.

My mom grew up here and has been having the hot dogs with the secret recipe since she was a kid. Town has changed a lot since her childhood, but she says that the hotdogs remain the same

What a quaint little dining establishment. The food was delicious and the waitress was excellent. Highly recommend stopping in for a bite to eat and try the fried green beans

Omg, really good food and, very nice service.

My favorite place to go...great service..great food!!! The staff always friendly.. I love it.

I love CI, been going there 15 years, my morning coffee and never had a bad moment. Thank you for being so wonderful and loyal. 👍👍😁

Staff is friendly. The food is delicious and the prices are very reasonable.

Love with food the service is great I eat breakfast there every day