Caffe’ Maya

Would highly recommend this place! Food was absolutely delicious. Staff were so kind and the atmosphere is lovely. Will definitely be back! Also got some provolone to-go as they also have a deli with many items!

Excellent Italian food ! Had an antipasto and chicken parm….was outstanding! Staff and owner very nice people. Can bring your own wine. Will definitely be back.

Incredible!!! Tried the lobster ravioli and the vodka riggies with chicken, and was completely blown away! All ingredients are fresh, and these are some of the best riggies I’ve ever had. Not to mention, the prices are more than reasonable! Should you stick around long enough for dessert, I highly recommend the chocolate cannoli cake. Easily my new favorite dessert!

I seriously can’t say enough good about this sweet little restaurant. I look forward to returning❤

Food was absolutely delicious and the staff treated you like family. Highly recommend!

Love this place! Feels so familiar and the food is exceptional. Desserts and pastries are the best. My favorite restaurant!

If I could give this place a 10 I would. Second time I've been here & the food was extraordinary. The service exceptional & the desserts so decadent!! Food came out hot & delicious. Today we traveled from Syracuse to Herkimer just to enjoy this place. Oh & the bread!! I love yummy bread & they have it!! Fantastic experience! We'll be back!!
Highly recommend!!

Really nice new restaurant. Food is exceptional! We had chicken parm and ravioli. Bread is really good. This is a welcome addition to the area.

Would highly recommend this cozy little place. My steak sandwich and fires were excellent. My wife had a chicken panini which she said was great. Every table was occupied so that speaks for itself.

Excellent home made Italian fare by a very talented young chef.Veal Scamada (made with prociutto, eggplant, and fontina cheese,etc.) is a great dish.Antipasto for one or for two,has various meats, egg, tuna, peppers, tomato, etc.are wonderful. Also had Angel hair pasta and homemade bread.Just like old Italy in my opinion.Also found their tomato pie,pastries(great with their excellent coffee) and deli items such as hot green olives to be delicious. This is a great venue for the valley, give’m a try.

Cafe Maya's chicken parm is divine!

Wonderful place. Food great. Will definitely return. Prices reasonable for a change

A wonderful cafe fantastic food I'm very impressed Herkimer really needed this place good luck to the owners!

Small restaurant but great owner/operate and friendly staff. Food is top notch on both visits. A small intimate dining area makes for a friendly atmosphere. 🦐

Fresh and delicious meal! We had steak tenderloin sandwich, chicken parm sandwich, capellini with marinara, and stuffed peppers. We also shared a couple homemade meatballs which were amazing!

Wonderful little place. Had eggplant Parmesan. YUMMY 😋 Highly recommend

What a nice place owner great and great service good food reasonable try it it’s great !!!!

The best! Great food and service.

italian old school deli with fabulous luncheon entrees..great everything...fresh! closed Tues /Wed
closes at 6 pm

The food and service was outstanding

Delicious food, friendly family atmosphere.