Fantasy Island Toys

Very helpful and friendly staff...make you feel like family. Amazing merchandise!! Best Toy Store Ever!!!

Shopping as a grandma is waaaay different from shopping as a parent. Fantasy Island still has the best selection of toys and games. It’s fun and easy to find what you need. The owners are amazing ambassadors for the community.
We are looking forward to their next stage!😉

Stopped in to surprise a friend's mom with flowers. Missed her but found another wonderful employee to help us out! Thank you!! My kids are grown, but through experience, I have to say that this is a toy store to VISIT OFTEN! Great selection. Wonderful atmosphere! A kid's dream!!

Fantasy Island Toys is a perfect example of a small hometown toy store, with all the new and popular toys. They have plenty of options for all ages of children and every time I've gone in, there's always a child playing with whatever is out to test. The prices are higher than what you'll find online - but I'd pay that every time if it mean supporting a local small business option. Great business for our area!

It was a fun experience with a large selection to choose from. The staff was very friendly and helpful.

An amazing store with a wide selection of high-quality toys for all ages. We grew up coming here for over 30 years during our family vacations to the Grand Hotel and are now returning with our own kids. A real treasure in Fairhope!

While toy stores disappear from our landscape, Fantasy Island Toys continues to offer toys and games for boys and girls of all ages. They have old favorites, traditional games with modern update, and new concept toys. There is a full gambit of price ranges from a few dollars to pricey keepsakes. Such a fun space with so many things to hold, touch, feel and see! I'm glad I have a grandchild so I have an excuse to go in and look around! I had a great time and bought several toys for my grandchild, too!

Everyone that works here is so kind and inviting, and I always find the most unique gifts for birthdays and holidays! The gift wrapping is always so fun and FREE?! Can’t beat that. It’s my kids’ favorite spot to play and explore, thank you for always making them feel welcome!

My wife and I love coming to this toy store! A great selection to choose from. Well trained staff who make shopping for our grandchildren a fun and delightful experience. And free gift wrap!

As someone with 12 nephews/nieces and no kids myself, Fantasy Island Toys is my go-to for Christmas and birthday gifts. The displays paired with the knowledge of the employees make it so easy to get the most sought after toy of the season for each and every member of my Child Army.

We LOVE to visit Fantasy Island Toys when we are in Fairhope! It’s a big deal for our kiddos to go in to pick a toy while we are on vacation and we usually allot a couple hours for the visit. There is so much to look at and just deciding on one toy can be very hard. The prices are very competitive and usually the items aren’t easily found on sites like Amazon. You can expect to see items from brands like Hape, Peacable Kingdoms, Usbourne, Hana, etc. We really look forward to our visits!

Great toy store with unique toys! Friendly staff were super helpful! We loved this place and will be back again!

Wonderful staff! So helpful, I was visiting from Idaho for Christmas and it was such a nice experience! 😊

Loved this sweet Toystore! We had a great time.
Nice selection! We found something for everyone!

Now that Toys-R-Us is gone, this store is one of the best toy stores (if not the best) in the Baldwin-Mobile county area.

They have unique toys that most stores don't have anymore.

Great selection of toys and items that you cannot find anywhere else

They have the neatest toys a lot of which you don't see any where else.

Excellent variety of toys

My son loves coming in and seeing what's new.