Casey's

We had a positive experience with our pizza order tonight. We ordered on line and paid on line. I parked in the back of the store and walked straight to the pizza pick up window inside. Our pizzas were promised at 5:54 PM. When I walked up to the counter she was cutting the second one of our pizzas. I was handed our order at 6:03. I didn’t really mind because I allowed a few minutes for it to be late and it ended up perfect timing. The pizzas were both good. Nice store. Great location. Convenient to I-70. Store stays busy.

I had a great visit at this Casey's. The two gentlemen working there this morning went out of their way to help me, they made two fresh pizzas early just so I could purchase some. I will definitely be visiting this store again.

Casey's Pizza is Better than Minsky's Pizza
There's consistency, affordability, employees are nice, and it's damn delicious pizza!
Super impressed w a Gas Station Pizza?! Not what we expected at all! 5/5 Way to go, guys!

This is my go to place. Whatever I need. Snacks, drinks, pizza. I've seen a lot of bad and negative reviews for this location and I don't know why. I come here a few times a week at different hours and everyone has always been professional. The pizza rocks! Try the breakfast pizza.

Want to offset the mistake I just made. Accidentally rated this Casey’s a 1 star on Uber eats and MEANT to rate my driver that. Uber eats dude ATE MY CHEESY POTATO BITES. These guys picked up the phone quickly, remade them lickety split and were kind. 10/10 service for this Casey’s.

Blown away. THE FOOD has no right being this good. To say, "gas station pizza" would be a huge disservice. It's on par with the major chains and costs less. I'm still sad you took out the free tire air but your food won me over. Fantastic job Casey's!

Always friendly and helpful staff, there is never anything broken or out of order. Everything is clean and orderly and they even give you free air that pumps super fast! We are blessed to live right next to this Casey’s.

Awesome food, awesome service, always friendly and COVID-19 conscious! Thank goodness for our essential workers still providing se of life's normalities at Casey's!

Beth is the BEST employee there. She ALWAYS has a smile on her face. Is quick to help when needed! She's GREAT!

Delicious food! Great prices! Extremely clean store with incredibly clean restrooms! All that and a smiling face to check you out before you leave.

Caseys pizza... THE BEST PIZZA EVER🤗

Great selection and prices. Great selection of great tasting fresh hot food as well. Friendly and courteous staff. No complaints and highly recommended!

You can order online and foods ready when u arrive!! Awesome way to save time. Very clean friendly staff.

Always a great experience and AMAZING pizza

Very clean and sanitary bathrooms, and the staff were very courteous and helpful, specially Bonnie!

Good pizza, good service

Great bathroom had 2 rolls of toilet paper. Great clean environment.

Great place for all your needs when traveling.

Fantastic Store, friendly management and employees. I look forward to returning.

Amazing pizza. Won't break the bank!