Nick's Pizzeria

My son and I were once again looking for a new lunch spot to try. I drive by here on a daily basis so I thought what the heck. It's a little hole in the wall in a tiny building. Stuck behind a gas station. Both my son and I agree this is one of the best slices of pizza we have tried. The service was quick and the slices generous. The toppings were fresh and tasty. If you have not tried Nick's then you definitely should.

Ordered through their third-party app and they definitely delivered. All the food here is amazing! The garlic knots are baked perfect. Their strombolis are spectacular, and the large can easily feed 4-5 people.
The pizza was baked to perfection; crispy crust and all; fresh delicious toppings. The wings were just the right crispiness and the sauce was on the side so they weren't all soggy by the time they arrived.
The delivery was on time and the courier was polite and kind.
I definitely recommend Nick's as the absolute best pizza shop in Altamonte!

Nick and Justin are the great pizzaiolo near the Altamonte Springs SunRail station Orlando
I tasted and it’s really good!
Altamonte residents are very well by them besides the gas station near SunRail

Best marinara sauce anywhere. Family owned, friendly staff. Will make your pizza anyway you'd like. Extensive menu for so small a place. Vegan and vegetarian options. Haven't eaten a single thing there that wasn't absolutely delicious. Ziti, stuffed shells, garlic knots, pizza, all outstanding.

This place is excellent. It's in a little shop right behind a gas station. No Frills, just very good food. We ate pizza on the patio. It was hot, fresh a delicious. "Mom and Pop" kind of hole in the wall place.

It's one of the best 🍕 in the area, hands down! The 🍕 is tasty! The cheese, the toppings, and the crust are fresh, and they cooked to perfection. The garlic knots have good portions and are full of garlic flavor. They also have other sides like Meatballs, Wings, and even Alcapurrias!

And, I almost forgot about this!...the price! The 🍕 have really good prices, they give you good bundles, and offer delivery, too.

The restaurant is located in a corner on a gas station on Altamonte Springs (near the Altamonte Mall). The restaurant doesn't have parking space (use the gas station parking), and, don't have an inside seating, only a couple of seats outside with tables and umbrellas, so it's small, but don't let this get you wrong! It is small on the outside, but it's big on flavor!

The staff is very friendly and humble. Very nice persons working there!

I definitely recommend this restaurant to anyone at 100%.

The myth, the Man, the legend, Nick is the OG of flavorful affordable Pizza. You can tell that he and his wife work hard to accomplish a trustworthy name in the Pizza industry. I Pray successful years ahead for his Establishment, and anxiously wait to see where this young couples dreams go.

Hole in the wall type place. Has the best beef patties around. Friendly staff. To go only.

My mom and I arrived late this evening to try a place next door, but we were curious about the Pizzeria. We got the beef patty they were advertising on the window, and we ended up getting the Grandma's Pizza as well. They were both so good! The pizza was crispy, thin and not to salty. The amount of cheese was perfect for my mom and doesn't overpower the other ingredients. It takes a few minutes to prepare everything, but it's worth the wait!

The guy, I believe was Nick, was super kind to us and made the experience wonderful by including an extra slice and sweet desserts as well. We could tell the whole family behind this Pizzeria is passionate about their food. I don't have any NY pizza experience, but I know a fantastic slice when I eat one. We'll definitely be back again and tell others to check it out!

This location is adjacent to the gas station, so just pull into the gas station and you'll see the Pizzeria on the left corner of the building,

Only NY style pizza in all of Orlando, matter of fact, is the best pizza shop in FL! Trust me, you will feel like you are back in the Bronx when you have a slice from here, not to mention the beef patty with cheese is the best!!! Nick, keep doing your thing, and thank you!!!!

Pizza is off the chain and the Jamaican patty was delicious you can call me a pizza expert I’m from Jersey city we know pizza 🔥❤ 🍕

April 12 2021.......Went by to pick up a Monday special - 16 inch Cheese Pie for $7.99. The service was awesome from Nelly and Noel (pie man). The pie was really good as always. I ask for it a bit crispy. I was just in Tallahassee and had a mediocre pie there. Had to come to Nick's right away to cleanse the palate.

March 1st 2021......Picked up a Large Cheese Pizza (on Mondays $7.99). It was a somewhat uneven cut but delicious. Also had a bag of Zeppole (Fried Dough with Powdered Sugar). Yum.

Last week.......First time there. I picked up a 10" cheese pizza to go and asked for it extra crispy (I always do). The pizza was very good. It did have a bit of a skunk line (a gumminess between the dough and sauce). This is caused sometimes by cool sauce and cheese on the dough or a dough too moist. But it was very good as was the service. Forgot to take a pic but this shows their slices.

Not my new go-to which is New York Pizza in Fern Park, but I will definitely be back.

Nick is a really good guy and he treated me with the upmost respect. I'm new to Florida and I already found a new spot with great food at an affordable price. I definitely recommend this Nick's Pizzeria and I'm very picky about my food especially when it comes to New York style pizza or Philly cheesesteaks.

Best pizza around... crust could be a little more sturdy/ crispy... but all pizza needs to be crisper everywhere

Really good slices for the price! I believe it was about $2.00 for a slice of cheese. It's like pre-pandemic prices! Came to like 4.75 for a slice and a can of coke. Super family friendly!
The parking is a bit of a pinch here. The few spots were full,so I parked along the edge of the gas station lot. No issues there.
There are a couple tables outside. No indoor seating.
I'd go back, yes. :)

Excellent customer service. Was there right before closing and they were super nice.
Crust was the best one I’ve tried so far.

We had a slice of ranch bacon and one Buffalo chicken (a little spicy) and LOVED IT.
We will be coming back every weekend ❤

First and foremost Nick and his wife are absolutely attentive to all your needs. Pizza worth every penny and don't get me started on the Canolli🤤
If you haven't tried, I'm telling you now you won't regret ever trying this place.
God bless you on more succes Nick's Pizzeria. Thank you for fresh ingredients everytime!
Bacon ranch pizza for the win!!!

I finally found a real Ny tasting 🍕 pizza, hands down it's the real deal. The best part of it is that the owner Nick is from Brooklyn, NY, and so am I . I'm so glad I found this hidden gem. My second & third favorite here at Nick's pizzeria that I miss so much from back home is the beef pattie with coco bread and their zeppolis. Nick certainly doesn't disappoint! He nailed it!! Thank you for your amazing service. 👏 BklynzMrsDesire

The best pizza and my favorite chicken cutlet parm. They never disappoint everything is made fresh. I highly recommend nick’s pizza

Best NY Pizza 🍕 in town ! Omg is so good . And they also have Alcapurrias’s/ Papas Rellenas / Pastelillos 🥰 We always order to go and enjoy this NewyorkRican cuisine @home