The Inside Scoop

Loved this place! Great ice cream flavors and inside seating for rainy days!

All the best and latest Hershey's ice cream flavors. Try the Cappuccino Crunch! Fabulous!
Like this review if you find it helpful.

Great ice cream! Glad they are opened later than many in town. The pizza was good too!

Friendly staff and fast service! Mango Italian ice is my favorite

Cute shop!!!

Was closed for the winter. There was a sign to go to the restaurant behind them, but they did not serve ice cream.

There’s a board with a lot of choices of ice cream, beverages, other treats, etc. but there’s only certain ice creams in the freezer available for the day, which isn’t indicated anywhere. One of the servers was extremely rude when people asked for something that was on the board that they didn’t have. It should be made more clear what flavors are available for the day as people are deciding while waiting in line. There’s a lot of ice cream places in Cooperstown and the surrounding areas; you can get as good or better ice cream elsewhere with much friendlier service. We recommend Cooper’s Barn. To be fair, we came earlier in the week where we had a friendlier server and liked the ice cream, otherwise this would have been a 1 star review.

Had ice cream cones. They were the smallest cones I’ve ever had, 2-4 table spoons per scoop, we each had 2 scoops. Charged $4.50 each for less than 3/4 cup of ice cream to have between 3 people.

This place does not make any attempt to accommodate nut allergies. That's fine; they don't have to. But the person working there was so cold and mean to my son and me, when we asked if they are able to take allergy precautions (which in other places can involve washing the scoop or opening a new carton or scooping away the top layer from the carton). She scoffed at us loudly and said: No! Not possible!, shaking her head. Effectively, her message was "we aren't going to try to make it possible for you to enjoy ice cream, sad mom and child." It's a painful message to hear; if you need to say it (which is understandable!) - just try to be a nice person about it. We left in tears. Just try to be a little less mean when you're disappointing a child.

The lady was nice but charged an arm and a leg for freezer burnt ice cream… never again.

Stopped by twice and the open sign was on. Another customer besides us left too.
Reading other reviews and we didn't miss anything.