Barbatto Pizza

We were visiting from out of town and had the pizza cravings hit very hard. The cascade pizza employees were disengaged and treated us like it was our privilege to eat their pizza so we visited this pizza place. Unfortunately, their ovens weren’t operating but they offered take and bake and cooked slices. So we grabbed all the slices and went on our way. On our way out of town we grabbed five large pizzas to freeze and headed back south. These women deserve support from the community to get this shop up and going! Not only is their customer service delightful, the pizza is worth having in the freezer.

Me and the wife always order food from here and it's always without a doubt amazing tasting. Customer service is always excellent, rarely do they forget something and if they do their always quick to correct it. 10/10 recommended.

What a nice surprise. Ordered a tiny cup pepperoni and a chicken alfredo. Both were really good. Excellen dough recipe. You are now my pizza place of choice. I do hope they can get a more permanent location and slide in ovens. That would make this place a destination for many travelers. Well done, guys.

Very good pizza 🍕 highly recommend! We got the Islander (our new goto) and a classic pepperoni. Both very good! They use the best pepperonis that crisp up! The bone in wings and garlic sticks were also really good too. My least favorite thing was the Mac n cheese bites- to me lacking flavor however this is just my preference! Either way definitely our new go to pizza place! Best part they deliver too!

Our first time here. The pizza was excellent. We took it home to McCleary to eat it. Had to reheat it a little, but it was beyond good. So many choices, so hard to choose.

Delicious! Best pizza in the area. Fresh, perfectly cooked, great customer service. We will definitely be ordering again soon!

Pizza was good and boneless wings were good. Would definitely recommend

I can’t say enough about this business. Great food (top notch ingredients!), great staff, great customer service. They are also very good to our local community in the way of giving back and supporting the community!

Best pizza around. A little expensive but definitely worth it.

If you’re looking for pizza in Elma!!! This is gonna be the best, hands down!!!

Always a great place to stop off and get some food

The absolute best gas station pizza

Don't let the business pic discourage you! We had their pizza for the first time tonight, and we were pleased 😌 The Mann, Vegetarian and Combination all had a lot of fresh toppings, great crust, and tasted better than any other pizza we've had in the area. The staff was friendly and professional! I recommend.

3rd time having them. 2nd time getting delivery. The first 2 times was good! This time, the crust on the pizza was burnt (you could taste it), and the mac and cheese bites only came with 5 pieces when last time it came with 6. Overall, it's okay. Not the best. But, not the worst.

Got delivery tonight. Ordered 2 orders of the bone in wings with a side of ranch. And one order of the garlic parmesan bone in wings with a couple extra. When we got the order all the wings were garlic parmesan. Called about it. She mentioned the freebies that we got since it was a big order (that was really nice of them!) But when I mentioned the wings being wrong, I was hung up on.

No pizza menu. No customer service. Do not recommend. Only one that paid any attention to us was the dog that was wondering around inside