Whit's Frozen Custard

I have eaten at many of the Columbus area Whits, and the New Albany location is definitely my favorite. Friendly, smiling employees always greet you as soon as you walk in the door and the portion sizes are better than at other locations. I've heard the manager training employees, telling them to add more custard to a cup, which is good, because scoop sizes can vary depending on who is scooping! Whitsers are also done with the right amount of toppings. Other places add too little or too much. Employees are always busy--no one standing around looking at their phones. Prices vary from location to location, but I'm sure rent and taxes are all part of the pricing equation. Never been disappointed at the New Albany Whits.

As usual, my experience is great! By far the best place for ice cream/custard. I saw a post from someone complaining about running out of a flavor. I think if they run out by the end of the day that’s good because you then know it always freshly made. Sort of like a bakery. Whits of New Albany….keep up the good work!

First stop with our new harnesses. Loved the owner & staff. Delicious custard.

Fantastic spot to grab some frozen custard! They have chocolate and vanilla along with a flavor of the day. What they may not have in terms of custard flavors, they make up for in toppings. The custard was excellent! They also sell dog treats, pies and cakes. Service was friendly as well! Can't wait to go back!

This is such a nice Whits! They have a lot of great options and delicious ice cream. The staff is really nice. The inside is nice and has seating. I will definitely be back.

First time having Whit's in many years. It was delicious. Got their blended treat. The staff was super friendly and helpful. Really enjoyed it.

The staff was extremely helpful. The store was very clean and the custard was incredible. I would highly recomend coming here. And you can get a just pies pie too!!!!!

Amazing iced cream though the store is very plain

It always makes my day to have some Whit’s Frozen Custard and our friends always get it from this location for our game nights. It’s always so delicious and is the perfect treat for the end of the day, 10/10 recommend :)

Kept it simple, vanilla custard with strawberries and cookie dough. What a combination *chef's kiss*. Custard was the right amount of creamy and the 2 toppings blended together nicely for a very tasty treat.

Really had a craving for some frozen custard today. I was relieved to see that there was a Whit’s less than a mile away from me. I had previously only been to the in Johnstown, Ohio. The store front is beautiful. Initially, I couldn’t tell if they were closed as every other store was around the area. Thankfully, the door was open and my boyfriend and I were greeted by a kind man. He informed us that they weren’t totally open, but we were welcome to purchase their quart-sized custards-which was totally fine by me. The custard is delicious. Be sure to treat yourself to their toffee caramel vanilla. I will definitely be returning again! Thank you for being so kind!

The custard is so tasty!
We had Whit’s cakes for my son’s birthday and couldn’t have been happier with how delicious they were - very pleased!
And the staff here is wonderful!

Just great. First time at Whit’s

The employee Abby smith was great!

I come back to this place time and time again because of the wonderful customer service demonstrated by your employee Harika. The custard is amazing and the employees create an amazing atmosphere. overall, 11/10.

ATTENTION VEGANS: For freshly made ice cream on a vegan cone, head to Clintonville. The Vegan orange creamsicle in the freezer was wonderful!

Whits has awesome ice cream at a reasonable price. The staff is always very friendly.

This is probably my favorite location in the city. The service is always great and the custard is phenomenal!

This place was amazing the custard is delicious and there’s this one staff member Sam he was by far the best he was very patient when we went there. The environment is also very welcoming!

Staff is so kind and friendly! Awesome ice cream as well!