BLVD Pizza

Have been coming to LBI for 10+ years and this is easily the best pizza on the island — and I don’t say that lightly! The Jersey Plum is HEAVENLY and the staff couldn’t have been nicer!

This pizza place is a true hidden gem. We hav made this our go to place for pizza when here. We have repeatedly gotten the Grandma and Grandpa pizzas. These are very large square pizzas that we have cut into 16 slices (yes I said 16 slices!) they are absolutely delicious. They are thicker crusts but not heavy and doughy. The crust actually has a crispy chew to it. The tomato sauce is oh so wonderful...not too tart, not too sweet, just right!
Our only dilemma is that there are so many other flavors of other pizzas on the menu that because we live these two types, we haven't tried any of the other pizzas. We will, I promise! Can't believe it has taken me so long to review. Thank you BLVD Pizza for being right here in Surf City!

Stumbled upon BLVD Pizza. It's a hole in the wall but man, was I delighted!
Ordered a pepperoni slice of "Brooklyn's Finest' and finest it indeed was! Have never had a pizza as crisp as this one! Super delicious! Very much recommended.

The plain and pepperoni pies was one of the best I ever had. This pizza changed my life

I live in NYC and I’ve tried a lot of za (even the ones you stand in line for a few hours just for a slice). This unassuming pizza joint is quite literally one of the best spots I’ve tried to date. Don’t be turned off by the location and get the Grandpas pie with a side of meatballs and bread. 10/10

We ordered the Fig Poppa, Jersey Devil and a cheesesteak. The flavors of the pizza were so balanced and delicious - just the perfect amount.

The cheesesteak was great and had the special authentic cheese that old school cheesesteaks have. So impressed!

Wow! The pizza is great. I normally don’t like Sicilian pizza, but was at a party that had gotten their pies here. It was so good (I’m a convert). The Sesame Street Chicken and Fig Poppa were unique and quite tasty. Also had a taste the Grandpa and Pepperoni and they were great. Sauce is very good.

Amazing toppings, sauce and crust. Best pizza on the island!! No real place to eat inside - takeaway only.

After coming to LBI for the past 8 years and trying every pizza spot on the island, I can say without a doubt this is our families favorite place! So happy to have such great pizza on the Island finally. The Grandma pie is Chefs Kiss.

Grandpas pie was incredible. Crispy bottom with a fluffy middle. Toppings and sauce were out of this world.

#1 PIZZA SHOP ON LBI. The Buffalo Soldier was the best pie we had and everyone loved it! We also got the Jersey Devil which was also a crowd favorite. Would definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for great tasting pizza on Long Beach Island.

Small place, but good pizza. Will definitely go there when I visit again.
They seem to run out quickly, so don’t plan on being able to get something if you eat late.

First timer today and it’s the best Pizza on (or near) LBI. Don’t think about it, just go try it

Brooklyn pie was very fresh tasty cheesy crunchy
Loved it.

If you’re looking for top of the line Pizza Pies or individual slices this is where you HAVE to go when heading to LBI. Plain Jane all the way to Wu Tang Clam a diverse selection with homemade ingredients. I wouldn’t recommended anywhere else!

If you’re looking for great pizza on LBI, you’ll find it here. Fresh ingredients, homemade sauce, unique creations.. need I say more? It’s delicious and worth your $.

Delicious pizza, Well done and crispy crust! Without question best pizza in surf city and one of the best one the island.

Best slices on the island and surrounding areas. Finally getting some good pies on LBI! Nothing like a slice before heading to Pops!

Absolutely killer pizza. Personal favorite is the buffalo soldier! Quantity ingredients and phenomenal presentation. 10/10 for me!!

Quality you can tastes. Unique vintage styled pizza with Great Custer service. Try the gma crust !