Cheesecake Connection Bakery

This bakery was suggested by a good friend. They had a booth in at a pop-up farmers market in Gahanna last week. I met the husband and wife duo and they were so pleasant and I found out we both grew up in the same neck of the woods. I purchased the plain and Blackberry Lemonade Cheesecakes and they were delicious. I definitely will be trying their storefront bakery out in the coming days. They were super friendly!

My awesome sister Shelly ordered four variety pack of cheesecakes for my birthday! Literally I’m typing this right after I ate the first one about 5 mins after they delivered them! So good and thank you for the birthday wishes and compliments towards my sister!

This was probably the best cheesecake I’ve ever had! I ordered several flavors of the 3inch cakes. My daughter and I had a hard time choosing our favorite! The owners even gave us a free one of one of their new flavors (key lime pie) my dad said it was his favorite! Between the wonderful service and people and the amazing cheesecake, we will absolutely be back!

Pumpkin cheesecake was Devine! So much depth of flavor and the packaging was adorable! Very excited to try more flavors. Would make really cute little gifts too!

We love their cheesecake. It is one of the best no matter what favor you order it’s always amazing. Highly recommend ordering any of their cheesecakes you won’t regret. Every easy to work with and it’s ready when you show up to pick up! Run dont walk and go order yourself cheesecake.

We ordered 3 mini cheesecakes around thanksgiving because I wanted to try something a little different for the holiday. My husband, daughter, and I tried all three and each were amazing! I ended up ordering another within the hour!! I will be a repeat customer 100%

These cheesecakes are THE BEST! I'm hooked and will be ordering another soon. The team also has great customer service ensuring that we could arrange a pickup time that worked on my schedule. Can't wait to order again!

This cheesecake is beautiful, delicious, and the owner is so kind and friendly! My partner and I got the strawberry shortcake flavor and it is refreshing and not overly sweet. It was made in a timely manner, with a text to let us know when it was ready. The owner was very accommodating with our pickup time and even included a bonus treat! The cheesecake absolutely cannot be beat for the price. We will be recommending them to friends and family!

My husband requested cheesecake for his birthday dessert, and these were absolutely phenomenal. My family said this was the best cheesecake they’ve had - the salted caramel one was delicious. Would absolutely order again!

My sister treated us to a sampler of four amazing flavors! Each crust was unique and delicious and the fillings were the best I’ve ever tasted. The are also truly gorgeous to look at!! Perfect special treat for dessert. The individual cheesecakes come in the cutest package and would make an awesome gift!

I’m from out of town and wanted to send something to my brother for his birthday. Customer service is impeccable. The original delivery time wasn’t going to work out so they texted me on their personal cell the evening I ordered. The second delivery time didn’t work out either. They went above and beyond to deliver the cheesecakes to my brother. My brother says they are amazingly delicious. HIGHLY recommend!!

I'm so excited to have found a new favorite cheesecake in town! Bought a classic cheesecake for a family get together and it was a huge hit! Great flavor and not too rich. The owner was very nice, and gracious for the business and promptly texted when my cheesecake was ready for pick-up. Family members and co-workers (who enjoyed the leftovers) all are asking the website for who made the cheesecake!

The cheesecakes at Cheesecake Connection Bakery are the best I’ve ever tasted. They offer a number of creative flavors and variations yet never lose the essence of the cheesecake. The pumpkin is delicious, mildly spiced, smooth and creamy. Another favorite is the coconut cream; subtlety flavored with coconut but not overpowering as coconut can be. I am indifferent to peanut butter and chocolate yet scarfed down their version of a buckeye cheesecake. Check them out. You’ll be delighted.

This was first time trying the cheesecakes and they were all smooth and delicious. My son loved the cookies n cream. The strawberry shortcake cheesecake was very good, light and refreshing. OMG the buckeye cheesecake was totally awesome. We really loved it. The pumpkin cheesecake was delicious and smooth. Great talent!!

A delightful experience! A perfectly beautiful cheesecake, which was mouthwatering! It was for my sister’s birthday and she absolutely loved it (as did everyone there)! Pierce was so kind and helpful to work with, too. I will definitely be a repeat customer! 😁

We wanted a homemade cheesecake for a birthday gift. We are so thankful to have found this business. A delicious mini dessert was ready in just a few hours.(Orders for larger cakes need at least a 24 hour notice. ) The owners are wonderful to work with.

I found Pearce and Meaghan at the New Albany farmer's market a few weeks back and after a sample taste bought 4 of the personal sized blackberry lemonade cheesecakes. The presentation was very nice the flavor was rich, consistency was light and airy best cheesecake I've had. My family liked them so much we had to track them down a week later and pick up 8 more. It's clear Pearce has a passion for his craft.

We ordered a "Turtle" cheesecake for our card group and the quality, packaging and presentation was a solid 10! Our guests commented on how delicious it was and one of them said it "was every bit as food as The Cheesecake Factory." I am grateful for the Cheesecake Connection's FANTASTIC desserts!

This is such a divine bakery! The owners are true professionals and caring people who accomodated me last minute for a Thanksgiving dessert. We tried the salted caramel, pumpkin, and blackberry lemonade 3" cheesecakes. Perfect personal size. So delicious, great density, and artfully made! We will be returning! This is a gem in Westerville. Thank you again!

The best cheesecake I've ever had. Recently ordered for my husband's birthday. It was so good I have ordered two more times. Going to be my new go to for dessert.