Heavenly Finds Thrift Shop

Every time I go I find something! It's pretty much a guarantee.

We frequented many thrift stores when looking for unique treasures to decorate our coffee shop before it opened. We found the highest quality and frankly, the coolest items at St. Peter’s Thrift Shop. It started with an oversized wood and metal coffee table that was too big for an average living room but perfect for us! Next, we found an awesome light-up globe on a wooden stand, which went so well with our “explorers club” vibe. Then we found a hand-carved chess set and a few other treasures that helped make our space even more inviting to our customers.

Thank you again to their lovely staff who were always so helpful! Definitely check out their ever-changing inventory- you never know what you may find!

Sharon from Cedar Bean’s Coffee Joint
575 Pompton Ave, Cedar Grove, NJ

Such a great experience. They've got a lot of high quality products at good pricing. It's unfortunate they're only open on Tuesdays but I understand since they are fully volunteer run (although a monthly Saturday date would be amazing).

I absolutely love this place! Kind volunteers and an amazing and ever-changing selection. The prices are very fair and the store is always well organized. For all you thrifters out there, this is store is a MUST SHOP!

This will be a Curious stop for a lot of people I think it worth visiting there is a lot of stuff here a lot more than I was expecting for a church thrift store that opens once a week so if you’re on your way to somewhere in the area and its a Saturday I would highly recommend stopping here and giving it a look there’s quite a bit to look at and you might find something really special... one of the few honest thrift stores left in this area.

Great place. Items are clean and good quality. The people working there are also great!

Huge variety, & very well organized. Quality items at a good price. Workers are friendly, helpful, & knowledgable.

Wonderful shopping experience. Great selection and service with a smile. Definitely recommend!

Volunteers are awesome! Great prices...

Well organized. Good value.

Donated many items to them. Wish I can shop there too but have too much stuff. The staff there is all volunteers thus they can't be open everyday like some other thrift shops. But they are so dedicated. Many great deals to be had if you go there on a tuesday.

They have a new space now that is smaller and you are unable to try on anything. I used to love this place…so sad I will not be returning.

The shelves at Heavenly Finds thrift store in Livingston, NJ are full of nothing but junk. That has been my experience. I don’t know who profits from this store but it is certainly not the unsuspecting customers who waste their time here. Avoid!