Higbie Bagels

Reopened recently after a fire. 5 Stars! Nice selection! They do have minis here. Bagels are always fresh and soft. Not doughy like some of the other bagel shops. I almost dont want to give away this other little secret...the strawberry cream cheese...has REAL strawberries in it! Not the fake pink artificially colored cream cheese I see in every other bagel shop on the south end. They move pretty quick also considering there ia always a line.

Not only are the Bagels fantastic but the assortment of cream cheese choices are amazing. Love the West Islip colors on the special bagels. I really enjoyed the taste, texture and flavors of these bagels and had the opportunity to try the organic chicken soup that the chef made and it was incredible good and not too salty. My kids loved the bagels as well and especially the organic chicken soup. There is so much attention and work done to these bagels and cream cheese choices that I’m excited to come back for more. The prices are super reasonable and the quality of ingredients exceeds the value this spot charges. This Brooklyn born 45 year bagel eating native approves Higbie Bagels! My kids want to come back again just for the chicken soup. Bravo Higbie Bagels for sharing your quality bagels to Long Island.

An authentic old school bagel with bubbles cooked proper made with love. The best bagels on Long Island super nice owner and employees. Enjoy!!!!

Best Bagels in the area. Expect a line out the door on weekend mornings but worth the wait.

Me and my family were on vacation and my Cuzin highly recommended my kids wanted to go there every day but managed at least a couple times the staff was extremely kind and helpful not to mention there bagels were phenomenal from the French toast bagel to the rainbow bagel, st patty’s day bagel, egg plain, and my favorite egg everything bagel 5 star. There cream cheeses were to die for bacon scallions, strawberry, original and others five star all around clean shop variety exceptional Thank you Higbie bagels wish you guys opened one in Tampa Florida we definitely don’t have bagel shop like that here

Nice fresh bagels, great service, would recommend

Just moved to west Islip a few months ago. Now I was in search of a new local bagel shop in close proximity to my place. First off, this place has THE BEST Lox spread I have ever had. Lox spread had so much salmon snd the rstio was 50/50 with cream cheese. Absolutely delicious.
5 out of 5 stars, just wish they had Georgio’s roasters coffee instead of your run of the mill bagel shop coffee. Bagels are top notch!!!

Higbie bagels are simply the best.. crisp on the outside & soft in the inside & even more amazing if their hot.. staff is friendly & kind..

Great bagels. Ex excellent cheese Danish, whenever they make them. Not every day
Quick and easy the veggie cream cheese is to die fp

Omg absolutely the best breakfast place! I ordered from them thru Doordash and I can happily and honestly say they are the best breakfast sandwiches I’ve tasted from anywhere that delivers to West Babylon. The egg sandwiches were right on point - over medium was perfectly cooked, not too dry not too wet (we tested this on 3 different occasions). We also ordered a fried egg sandwich and it was again perfect! Bagels are soft and delicious, lunch was perfect tasting and again right on point. I’ve tried their egg sandwiches on 3 different occasions, and their lunch on two different occasions. What can I say, I’m hooked! Tysm for the delicious food!

Everything flagel with eggs, avocado and pepper jack cheese was perfection! The girl who helped me was super friendly and efficient (loved the thumbs up she gave me... twice)... I would definitely recommend this place. Fresh food made with love! Keep up the great job!

Perhaps the best bagels I've ever had in my life.

The new owners have done a fantastic job. Not only are the bagels just as good as before, but they now do breakfast sandwiches. Best bagels on the island hands down.

Staff is very affable and courteous. Bagels are fresh and very very tasty. Variety of cream cheeses with a wide selection of sandwiches and wraps with fresh ingredients. You will enjoy the aroma and taste

Been coming here for years and the quality of bagels has always been great. Staff is courteous and prompt to take your order.

I had to come on Google to give this place the review it deserves. Best bagels on LI for the best prices. Hands down. Want a bagel? Come here. This is the #1 option.

Addicted to Higbie Bagels! Very nice, smiling, friendly staff that are always accommodating. They have VEGAN creamcheeses that are so yummy! 🥯

BEST PLACE EVER. The people in here are the most friendliest anywhere. Besides the hospitality the bagels are amazing.

Every bagel you could want! Salads, coffee cake, muffins, cream cheese (plain and flavored), juices, milk. Awesome!!

All of the people here are great. I dont think I have noticed an employee turnover in 9 years! Food is awesome and they really take care of their first responders.