Amazing Olive

This is a go-to establishment for all your oil needs. It is a very comfortable setting. Store personnel are very friendly and not pushing you to buy items. They were very knowledgeable of the various products that are carried in the store. So if you need special oil, this is the place. Main Street car show pics added to review, for your delight....🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲

The staff are fantastic, Austin in particular goes above and beyond for her customers, very polite and has a great sense of humor. The hot sauce they sell is worth every cent, definately up there on the scoville scale. And they have an amazing variety of olive oils & vinegars. Definately will go back.

Tons of different selections of oil to choose from. Every time I go, I try something new, but have found that the white truffle oil is, by far, my absolute favorite. I use it in my mac and cheese, and everyone loves it.

Just what the doctor ordered! I have been shopping at Amazing Olive for the past few years. It makes me feel so good to go and try the different flavours. It tastes so healthy and delicious. I buy my family and friends gifts from here all the time and make sure to take a bottle home for the season.

Just popped in this cute shop to pick up a house warming gift. Very helpful and attentive. He whipped up a great basket full of delicious goodies that looks very neat and pretty. Can't wait to give the gift to my friends. Thank you Amazing Olive. You made my gift selection and buying and eventually giving process very pleasant.

My go to gift shop. I’ve been going here since they opened. They have a great selection and I’ve been able to get some nice gift baskets made up. Their staff member, Kyle, was so knowledgeable and helped me pick different oils and vinegars.

Love this store! Kyle was very helpful and very knowledgeable! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Excellent place to visit and taste all the many different and flavorful olive oils from Italy. They are amazing! Also the many flavors of balsamic vinagars are out of this world. This is one of my favorite stores!! They have many spices, gift packages and so much more all in a beautiful setting. Ralph and Steve, you guys went far and beyond.

The variety of olive oils and balsamic vinegars is a delicious. The different sizes are also great for gift-giving. My favorite is the Sicilian Lemon balsamic vinegar and I put it on everything!

The Amazing Olive in Patchogue is a brand new shop that every one should visit and buy all the new olive oils, vinegars, soaps, and rubs. The shop is much bigger than Port Jefferson. Its very beautiful on the inside and they continue to expand and grow! They also do the events that Patchogue has to offer. The staff that works there knows a lot about the history of the oils, and vinegars. They are very nice and kind to their customers. I would recommend going there when you are at Patchogue. You will have a fun experience there! I sure did!

The name says it all! The amazing olive is like a candy store for essential oils for cooking. If your tired of cooking with the same olive oil I'd suggest making a quick stop and picking up a bottle to cook with.

And.......

You can try them all..... In the store..... They give you bread.... Really go check it out

I like the raspberry vinegrette , lemon vinegar, jalapeño ! Can't go wrong cooking using these ingredients.

This is the place to purchase oils and vinigers without the snobs found in similar stores in other nearby towns. These people let you know that they appreciate your business.

This place is an addiction! I buy gifts here sometimes and get requests for refills when they are finished. I highly recommend the Citrus Habanero olive oil.

This place is a hidden gem. The oils, vinegars, etc. everything is exceptional. Perfect for gifts or party favors. If you haven’t stopped in yet, stop in soon. You won’t be disappointed.

My taste buds can't believe the possibilities. Staff is friendly and awesome not to mention knowledgeable. I'll certainty be a returning customer. If I find myself on the north shore, i'll be sure to stop by their Port Jeff location. Who knew! :)

Friendly and knowledgable owners and staff. I love cooking with olive oil, so when I visit Long Island I always stock up on goods from Amazing Olive!

This is the only place I can find the raspberry vinegar that I love! We also tried bacon flavored olive oil. It's fantastic!

Very helpful and knowledgeable staff, made me feel welcome in the shop.

I did not even know this store was on main street I stumbled upon it as I was walking to another place and I'm glad I did very nice and what a great selection of stuff.

My first time today what a beautiful store amazing variety and nice staff will be going again..