Pizza Pie Cafe

I love this place. The staff are always quick to switch out the trays of pizza when it runs out. The pizza is delicious and they have an array of flavors. The pasta is delicious and they also have many different flavors to choose from. The dessert is my personal favorite, specifically the raspberry flavor.

So busy tonight but so so impressed with how all the employees were handling it!! Food was fresh and delicious and they were all moving around so quickly to clean and replace the food that was out. Unbelievably impressed! Thanks everyone who helped make the night enjoyable even though it was stressful for them I’m sure.

We took our kids here because our oldest is a pizza hound so we thought we would check it out. First off this place is busy so don't just plan on a quick in and out meal. They have everything from a fresh salad bar, build your own pasta bar and large assortment of all you can eat pizza slices. Overall I felt the price and quality were a fair value and with the different assortment of foods there's something for everyone. Our family will definitely be back in the near future. Edit: some time has gone by and I feel the luster of this place has worn off. The last couple of times we've been there the pizzas have either been empty or cold. During my last visit the pizza bar was never any more than 40% full. Another thing I've noticed the last 2 times is all the pizzas taste like they have sugar in or on them. All I can think of is the sugar from the dessert pizzas is somehow transferring over to the savory pizzas (maybe from the pizza oven or cookie sheets) anyways l I haven't been as pleased with my most recent visits. Pretty sure I won't frequent there once my kids are older and develop a more mature palate for pizza.

This place brings back good memories. The food was good as I remembered. It's nothing fancy but it's good. The pasta is always a winner. The salad bar is good and the pizza hit the spot. Plus it's a buffet so if you leave hungry it's your own fault.

This was a great place to have different choices. The salad bar was so good, very fresh. The pizza so many choices and the dessert pizza. Try the pasta bar and you have many choices of toppings. There is 6 kinds of pasta. Great place to bring the family.

Pretty fun place to eat. Staff was friendly, and it was full. All you can eat pizza plus pasta bar. Good times!

We have eaten at Cici, which is very similar in concept. However, Pizza Pie blows that establishment out of the water with simple quality and customer service.

There were a number of restrictions due to COVID, so the tables weren't bussed and we had to switch out plates after every use. Other than that, this was truly an excellent experience.

Great decor -- some Americana mixed with more modern twist. Music options were very upbeat and generationally mixed. I would recommend eating here. For the price, you're getting a quality meal and experience.

Plus - they offer veteran discounts on the veteran's meal.

I absolutely love this place has somebody who can't really eat carbs I really enjoy this salad bar and when I'm willing to do a decent workout I can eat the toppings off the pizza LOL. On this particular day it was extremely busy though which is why I gave the atmosphere4 stars. There it's just not a whole lot of room to move around in that little place when it's that busy I'm lucky I got there as early as I did. Great work guys I enjoy your little place. I really appreciate all of you there.

Had reserved a room for our huge family. Always a great place for all of us to get together.

Nice place nice employees food was good for a buffet 🙂 salad bar was fresh will be going to this place again

Several granddaughters were in town and Pizza Pie Cafe was on their bucket list. Friday night was not the best night to bring them in. There must have been a half dozen little league baseball teams and their families in there, plus the other half of Idaho Falls that doesn't play baseball. Nevertheless, the food was good, the salad and pasta bars were kept well stocked, and the pizza kept coming (although the line to get it never seemed to get smaller). There was about 15 people ahead of us in line when we got there at 6:45 and the line was just as long when we left an hour later.

We came here for pizza night with the family on a Wednesday around 530pm. It was not too busy and we quickly paid and found a seat.

It nice to have a choice at an all you can eat pizza place to get salad or pasta too, all included. They even have desert pizzas.

The restaurant was clean and picked up. The staff let most of the desert pizzas run out just at the time we wanted desert, but it was only about 5 minutes until it was replenished.

It was an enjoyable time with family.

We feel like we can recommend this place.

Excellent buffet salad bar and pizza. Many selection plus you can have them custom make

Really busy! But good pizza and pasta

I tried the salad bar very fresh lots of choices
Pizzas were always available and many options to chose from
Even desert ones to chose from. So yummy

Spud pizza is tasty. All you can eat with several choices of toppings.

I come here everyday and whenever i go to take a poo the stall is always taken i got very close to soiling my pants maybe add another stall? Edit still no second stall the mounds of bile stacking up in my stomach is becoming most unbearable im stuck inside this place till 10:00 tonight i dont think ill last please helpnus

Love coming here on lunch breaks to get an awesome salad to-go! Great price. Quick, easy and always fresh selections to choose from.

Fun pizza buffet. They’ve got gluten-free noodles at the pasta bar too! They’ve got a salad bar with decent toppings. About 10 different pizzas to pick from.

Great food and friendly staff! My one and only complaint is that they have out grown their Ammon location and should upgrade to a larger facility or maybe just expand the current one!