Brothers Of New York Pizza

Great food, really fast, staff is friendly and helpful.

Love it

Such a great place! Pizza was delicious and the service vice was even better. I love going to places where they go the extra mile. We were wrapping up eating around 7:30pm knowing they were closing at 8pm and as we were getting up to leave one of the staff members brought out popsicles for the kids to enjoy! Definitely recommend!!

Amazing pizza! Cooked quickly and to perfection. This pizza is exactly what I think of when I'm looking for NY Style pizza. Well done, y'all! Can't wait to go back!

We love Brothers Pizza. We ordered Grandma’s sicilian with mushrooms and pepperoni. It was delicious as usual and ready for pick up when we arrived.

Fast and friendly service. Food was delicious. We will be back to try something else. Menu looks impressive.

Good authentic NY pizza. Friendly staff. Clean environment. Quick service. Offers pizza by the slice and an outdoor patio. 2 pieces of cheese and a drink for under $10. I heard the staff speaking a foreign language which I suspect was Italian. Pizza was delicious and everything was as it should be. 5 stars!

Being a pizza lover and living in the triangle was a challenge. The best pizza places here at Triangle have that gourmet version of pizza that is good but super small; I travel a lot for work, and in all the countries I go to, I try to have the best pizza; I can tell the pizza here at Brother of New York, is in a similar level of the best one I had in my travels . Especially the prosciutto, because all the versions I tried here add some local flavor ( not sour, but sometimes the combined items don't match); here, they use oregano and delicious mozzarella. The dough is fantastic and reminds me of the ones I had in Italy, NY, and other Italian neighborhoods worldwide.

Great pizza!!! So many options to choose from and I will be going back.

I'm from NY and this is the closest thing to home I've had since I've moved. The pizza here is stellar.

Best pizza and Italian combo sub around! Authentic and delicious, at a great price. Nice little bar and the staff is amazing - the are pleasant and attentive and very helpful. This place is the real deal and we eat here about once a week because it is so good, we crave it!!

Take it from a Yankee.... ABSOLUTELY the BEST food in Cary. Customer service is second to none. Highly recommend the Sausage Parm (whole link) and a ice cold Stella. Tell the guys Donnie sent ya!!!

Best meatballs and pizza I had in North Carolina since I moved here in 2015 from NY

If you're a New Yorker you'll understand. Just try to spaghetti and meatballs. And of course the pizza is excellent. I love the atmosphere and I love the subway door against the wall. No kids love it there too nice place for a slice of pizza and a brew😀

Staff is always super nice and precise. Food is delicious. We immediately smashed 90% of the pizza before I could take a photo.

Great NY style and tasting pizza. Staff was very friendly. Will definitely be back..

I think my family and I have tried every pizza place in town. Brothers of New York is without a doubt the family favorite. They consistently provide delicious pizzas. We've tried all sorts of pizzas from here and we have enjoyed them all! Even the salads are delicious!

I’m from Long Island New York moved here to North Carolina six months ago found this place and it makes me feel like home if you want a flavorful delicious pizza, I highly recommend this place and the staff is wonderful super friendly. I can’t wait to try other things on the menu.

Really authentic New York pizza. Fast, clean and delicious 🤤

Love the pizza. Tastes better than a lot of places in NY. Love that they also have it by the slice including specialty slices. Repeat customer for sure

Best pizza I’ve had in NC