Andy's Pizza

Pizza is not your traditional pie. The crust is very doughy as some mentioned. I would ask them to cook it a few minutes longer if you prefer a firmer crust. But regardless, the crust is very good. The cheese is Old Forge style.

Great small town NEPA pizza with a very unique style. When you call to order, the line is always busy that should tell you everything you need to know.
Lots of topping options, reheats well. BRING CASH!

Seat yourself service. Andys pizza is a good contender for the best pizza in america and i havent found anything close. The crust is delicious, the plain pizza is amazig, but my favorite is their spicy sweet pizza. Its absolutely divine. Worst part is how little parking there is, but most people park at the bank across the street. Bar has a good selection.

You haven't experienced the entire Mid-Valley experience until you've had Andy's pizza. This is a FACT. Order a tray for takeout or even better walk in/ eat in, get the full hometown family run experience.

Pizza along the Lackawanna Drainage is a little different. Cooper Cheese vs. Mozzarella on the pie? Whatever is going on, it is good, and historic.

Love the nostalgia of this bar/ pizza shoppe. I really enjoyed the pizza. I gotta try the dark pizza next!!! Support great mom and pop shops!

Great pizza, great service.
Cozy unassuming atmosphere and the coldest beer around.

We love the pizza. (Delivered to Massachusetts). Thank you. Great pizza and great service.

We love Andy’s! Plain cheese cooked well done is our go-to order. If we’re not in town, we ship Andy’s to us to satisfy our cravings.

Great food, great service. Long-time favorite. They shouldn't ever change a thing... it's just right the way it is.

Super awesome pizza and super awesome local people! They go the extra mile for everyone! I love this place!!!!!!!

Excellent Pizza. Not ny style not old forge style it's Andy's style! Been visiting here since I was a child my parents took me I take my children and soon enough they will be taking their's. Always perfect a pitcher of birch beerand red cream and a few well done pies and 1/2 beer? Why not.... Try the double crust white. Mmmmmmmm

I love this pizza. It’s not a type of pizza you could have everyday & really is not anything like a regular pizza. I feel like people who may be disappointed are expecting a traditional style, which this is not. The dough is really get - but not typical pizza dough & the cheese is a blend of a few different types that give a creamy texture. It is not a stringy mozzarella type & really is better if eaten with a fork(assuming it’s still hot). Not great to have as leftovers the next day as it just doesn’t reheat the best. All that being said, I would highly recommend this to anyone. I would just be sure to clarify with them beforehand not to expect your typical type pizza

First time experiencing the phenomenon also known as Andy's and I'm absolutely enthralled by their take on pizza. We ordered two plain trays and I normally don't eat plain pizza, but this was like nothing I've ever had before. Truly excellent and I even ate the crust.

A favorite my whole life! Andy’s has the best pizza!

Favorite! Been going here since I was a toddler alway ls delish!

Andy's pizza is the best around! I drove in from Tucson and the 1st thing I had to do was grab some of that sweet sweet pizza! The young lady tending bar is a sweet and caring person who makes everyone feel welcomed as a regular even if it's been years between visits or your 1st time!

Love it but i cant eat it anymore. Make a gluten free pizza taste just as good as ur cheese pizza and I'll buy it from u every week. Amazing other wise. Must have cash.

Me and my family have been coming to Andy's for 20+ years. They're pizza has never changed, nor should it. Best pizza in nepa, truly can't find anything that tastes like it anywhere else

Always Amazing. Ready on Time. Worth A Trip bimonthly. Thank You