Myshelly's Kitchen

This is the 4th time I have been here, and each time it is very enjoyable. The food and service are both excellent each time. I usually come for breakfast (biscuits and gravy are on point). Today I came for lunch. I am abnormally picky about coleslaw usually and will only eat it when I make it but have to say I really enjoyed this one. When my kids come they love the pancakes. I really enjoy the environment. It is relaxing and not stressful and rushed like in chain establishments.

The menu was a bit limited but our food was great! My husband said the Deluxe BLT reminded him of the one he ate as a kid. I was impressed that my pretzel bun was soft and warm. The chicken was grilled and juicy. Ham and cheese on the chicken was tasty! Potato and pasta salads were average. The server was friendly, and the atmosphere was quaint like the entire downtown district - has an antique feel. We will be back!

The BEST restaurant in Arcadia!

My family frequents this restaurant often, have tried various items on the menu, and have never left unhappy.

I am a breakfast lover! It’s my favorite meal of the day! I love every item on the breakfast menu and also love that they have gluten free toast, waffles, and pancakes.

I also LOVE the Cuban sandwich! It’s my favorite!

My husband is the biggest fan of the Big Burger and the Ruben Sandwich. He also loves the fries!

It’s clean! It’s delicious! It’s friendly! And, very affordable as well. I highly recommend making this a go-to!

Oh! And Amazing sales! So big and so filling! The BEST salads in town! I like the chef and my husband loves the Greek salad.

The waffles are great they are topped with Irish butter and fresh cut strawberries .we can not forget the applewood bacon a lot of it!!!! Just an all around cute place

I visited this place on Sunday and it was very busy. The place is cute! We loved the decor and it had a very nice feel to it. The food looks great and tastes just as good. The server we had, she was very polite and we felt like the service was good even if a bit slow due to how busy it was. They also have a case with pastries and a selection of coffee, Lattes and other hot drinks. All around good experience and we will visit again soon.

The gyro omelettes, gyro platter and the Cobb salad are outstanding. Also one of the only places that has GF options!

This is fantastic! My family and I were looking for new places to eat and found this gem. The service and food was lovely and it had a wonderful atmosphere.
The service was quick and reliable plus the jazz music added perfect ambiance. Along with the food, it was perfect and I can't wait for the next time.
My family has a tradition of going to the same restaurant every year for special occasions and this is definitely a contender.

Honestly this is one of the better places in town to eat, the atmosphere is wonderful, the food is delicious as well as the iced coffee, the staff is friendly and the cooks dish out delicious food quick. I've eaten food from here multiple times and not once had the food been terrible, from ham to salads to Mac and cheese. It's all good eatin! The other day I had a cold brew iced coffee and it was perfectly made! Not only that, the place has that good southern family place vibe to it. Like going to a cracker barrel but with actually good food. Plus sometimes you get to see the owners dogs Violet and Vega which is a definite plus

We stopped on our way through Arcadia for breakfast this morning at Myshelly’s Kitchen after reading the reviews, and we were very glad we did.
The atmosphere was indeed great as was the spinach and feta omelette I had. My son had the waffle plate and that was well presented and tasty. Thankfully the coffee was first class also.
This is a great family owned restaurant and we’ll definitely be stopping next time we’re in Arcadia.
The guy who served us rides an Indian motorcycle too, so what’s not to like!

Always friendly and polite. Great customer service and even better food! I am here at least once per week!

The dining room is so cozy & sweet. The dishes are gorgeous & the prices are great!
The food is amazing. Not only does it taste delicious, but the artistic deplayed.

One of the best restaurants in town to bring your family! The atmosphere is wonderful with the owner playing jazz music on the TV's, not too loud to be distracting but enough to hear it. The staff is good, occasionally there's a mistake or two but nothing completely major like who peaces of your meal missing. The owner is good to her staff, the customers, and other shop owners and she really tries to make a connection with everyone, to the point where you could walk in and she'll probably have your drink order memorized. The cook will even come bring you your food if the day is slow enough! This place is also very child friendly and pet friendly! They have high chairs and will give your animals water to drink while you're there.

We all had a great breakfast both days and the service was great and so was the atmosphere. Enjoyed talking with Michele and sharing all the good ideas of what to go and see in the area. My husband said that was the best meat omelette he has ever had.

Love this place! Went with friends for lunch, the customer service was lovely and the food was delicious!!! Ordered a plate for takeout a week later and was just as good as the first time. A generous amount of food for the price in the area!

Recommend 100% Great food, Great service, Great relaxing, clean place. Waitress was attentive, food was cooked perfectly. Outside seating was available and parking in front, back or at the Truist bank. Check this place out if you get a chance!

First time ever coming here and absolutely amazing! The food was phenomenal and the display of the food on the plate was absolutely gorgeous.. definitely my new breakfast spot!!

Best omelette I have had in a long time, and I live in Boca Raton. Personality of the staff and the environment very welcoming and warm. Most definitely going to be coming back! In fact I took a chicken salad to go for later I was so impressed.

We live out of state and chose to have lunch at MyShelley's after local family spoke highly of the food and atmosphere. This was my first time back to my hometown since my Mom passed away. February 4th was also my Mom's birthday so emotions within myself and family were high. The staff at MyShelley's went above and beyond for our group of 10. The ambience was perfect and I must add that even though it was 10 of us, we never felt cramped. There's nothing worse than trying to sit and enjoy a meal while feeling like you're sitting on someone's lap, this establishment is cozy yet spacious especially for a large group. My husband is always looking for a good gyro and MyShelley's did not disappoint with the gyro plate. I also like a good cuban and the one I received was fantastic. (Loved the garlic stuffed olives). Service was top-notch and friendly. We are thankful our family suggested MyShelley's for our family lunch. My husband and I was born and raised in Arcadia and lived in many other places (my husband has lived all over the world) and I can say that Arcadia has a gem with this restaurant. Embrace it because it's truly not only a beautiful establishment but it's providing fabulous food at affordable prices. If you think the prices for the amount of food you receive is high, you've apparently not been out much IMO. We will be returning when in Arcadia.

Great food and service. Perfect place to eat and relax. I had the Farmers special and my husband had eggs and turkey for his low carb meal. The potatoes were perfectly cooked and crispy. Fried green tomatoes were delicious. My husband loved his cooked Turkey and eggs. Everything served on real china and large hot mug used for coffee.

Clean atmosphere, respectful and nice staff. Portions are perfect, and prices are super reasonable. Food tastes good, definitely worth the visit.