The Original Pizza Shack

We didn't realize restaurants here don't serve food after 10pm. Luckily, this place was still open and it more than exceeded our expectations. The 2 employees working were nice, informative, and friendly. We ordered the half size white pizza and an order of cheese curds. We were going to eat in, but they had just cleaned and we didn't want to risk them having to clean again. Eat in area is relatively small with 2 booths total, but at least there's an eat in option. Our order didn't take long. It was hot, delicious, and definitely filling. Half size is huge. Will definitely be back.

Love the slices and the prices. Quickly stop for easy in and out. Absolutely worth getting two slices if you are extra hungry. Grab a cold drink while you are there. If you are with the family the deals available are amazing and worth considering.

Don’t want to dine in fee free to take out. You can place your order over phone or in person. Quick service with no compromise in food quality.

Arrived home from work and found a coupon for a free large pizza in the mail. Figuring There was some catch I called and found out that no, there was no catch involved. I picked up my free large pizza and was immediately impressed with the size and presentation. The pizza was huge and looked amazing. When I got home and had my first bite I was absolutely shocked at how delicious this pizza was. The perfect amount of cheese to sauce ratio and the slightly sweeter dough was a beautiful combination. I never have written a review for anything but figured this was so good it was warranted. I will 100% only be ordering pizza from this place now on!
-Arthur G

Delicious! Perfect non breaded french fries! Good Subs, burgers, cheddar poppers, onion rings, chicken fingers, mozz sticks! Just get the Sampler and you can have a little of everything!

Had a busy day and ordered two tacos for a late dinner - they were awesome! Some of the best restaurant food I’ve had in a while. My husband and I were both really impressed. Will definitely be going back and trying some other things (and will def get a steak and chicken finger taco again!) Thanks, Pizza Shack!!

Just had a big order for Mother's Day , pizza ,subs ,calzone, chicken fingers and fries !!! There where 10 subs all of them with add on or substations and everyone of them where delicious and made exactly right !! We get pizza there all the time and it's the best !! First time we had a calzone, it was huge and so good and will definitely order that again !!! Thanks so much for your fast delivery!!

We have been getting pizza here for the last year and every time I am just amazed at how consistently good it is no matter what size we get. I can't remember having a bad pizza here. In my opinion it is the most well balanced pizza I've ever had. Perfect amount of cheese and sauce ratio and the crust isn't too thick or too thin. And then we tried it with the sweet sauce. I didn't think this pizza could get better, but it did. As for the prices, you can't beat them. The offer coupons in their menu and a punch card with $5 off the next order once filled. Even without coupons the prices are still really good. We usually get a large for about $22-25. One of the best in WNY.

Since our move last year, this has been our #1 pizza place! The staff has always been very friendly, kind, and helpful to me/my family. Usually, my family will order either pizza special or subs and they have ALWAYS been absolutely delicious! We just recently tried the boneless wings with our pizza special instead of regular wings, and am SO HAPPY we did! They are freaking awesome! Always have great weekly specials too!

My husband and I recently moved to NT. Our treat for the week is pizza every Friday. We ordered from every pizza delivery place in our area until we found our favorite - Pizza Shack! Delivery has been quite fast, especially for Fridays. Our food arrives hot and it's been great so far. We love that they do personal pizzas. It's just the two of us, and we only have pizza once a week, so anything larger would just be wasted. The fries are one of my favorites of all time ( I'm super fussy about my fries - I don't like anything weird or seasoned or fancy). Our routine order of pizza, fries and mozzarella sticks ended up being cheaper here than anywhere else as well. We really enjoy our end of the workweek treat from Pizza Shack, and we're so glad to have them in the community!
Update: Two years later, we order weekly, and they are still our favorite!

08/31/23 two biggish slices and a can of (pepsi OR coke) pop for six bucks.
Traditional sauce, softer crust, good amount of ingredients. Recommended

I love pizza shack, it's a very good Sicilian style pizza. The wings and subs are also great, and I enjoy the friendliness of the employees :)

SUPERB SERVICE!!! We are from the islands, recently moved to W. Amherst, difficult to find a tasty pizza around here, The pizza shack caught our eyes in the plaza and will always be out go to from now on!! def worth the extra drive on every tues n Thurs as per hubby💯😁😋

Your pizza sauce is delicious! I've ordered 4 pizzas on different days that were a bit dry when I got them (delivered)
Only resource I have is delivery.
It looks like its while baking & then during delivery.
Could you use more sauce please so I take a bite and I can taste sauce, cheese and pepperoni or everything (no anchovies) Please, Please 👵🏻 and thank you👵🏻

This has been our default pizza shop for 20+ years. Reasonably priced pizza, they’ll do sweet sauce if you ask for it, and their subs are solid, too. Our eldest kid always says “can we get pizza from our favorite?” This is the place.

I’ve been very happy with Pizza Shack lately. I picked up a Large Cheese and Pepperoni with Green Olives on half a couple days ago and it was fantastic as always! The employees here are always very friendly, helpful and courteous. I would definitely recommend Pizza Shack to anyone in the area looking for a delicious pizza.

So at 10:20pm on a Friday, when you call for a delivery, most places aren't even open, let alone will still deliver. But thankfully Pizza Shack closes at 1130p. Anyways, I ordered A steak hoagie and mozzarella Stix and I expected the food to be warmish, mainly because I live by the canal which is across town from them, And other deliveries. But it was HOT and FRESH, like the Stix JUST came out hot. Plus the sub was fantastic. Bravo and thanks to everyone over at T.O.P.S., appreciate ya's

Our families go to! We love the pizza , burgers and wings ! We are frequent fliers ! Delicious!

Great service. Great pricing. Excellent food. Good customer service. Had one very minor hiccup in all the time we have ordered from them and they went above and beyond in taking care of it. Highly recommend. We order from there very frequently

The sweet sauce is awesome! Prices were great too, and super friendly staff. Give them a try!

Everything on the menu is great. Especially love the sweet sauce pizza and the chicken sub.