North Tonawanda-Pizza Amore “The Wood Fire Way”

We're visiting the area and needed lunch while we were doing some errands and sightseeing. We saw this place and whipped in. We ordered a large Godfather. We both got a coke and our total came to $32.40 plus tip. We sat outside on this beautiful day. We had plenty leftover for later. The pizza was delicious.

Actually very good. Nice and cheesy, delicious crust and pepperoni cups has a real nice spice. White pizza with anchovies was real good. Definitely order from there again.

Went back and ordered cheese and pepperoni and a single order of bbq wings with hot sauce on it. WOW. Wings are baked in the wood fired pizza oven and they taste amazing, the wood gives it a very delicious flavor. My new go to place, easily. Service was the best, friendly, quick, i wish I would have got the young lady’s name that served me. Place was very clean and you literally look right into the oven as they make your food. Can’t wait to try the other food on the menu.

Amazing pizza and amazingly friendly tall blonde girl working here alone 2pm 11/29/23
She also recommended me the old world square slice as well as the 2 slices for lunch special with a soda. It was like $10.60 for 3 slices of fresh delicious pizza, great service, and an ice cold bottle of soda.

Best pizza/price in the area

The buffalo chicken and spinach ricotta pizzas are excellent and reheat well

Absolutely in love with their prosciutto pizza! It's to die for! I just wish they would have an outdoor seating. It would be perfect.

So I recently started a job across the street and I didn’t feel like making dinner tonight just so happened I checked the reviews on Google and they weren’t great but I was feeling lazy wanted to try something new and didn’t want to cook boy am I glad I got pizza from Pizza amore Literally The best stinger pizza I’ve ever had in my life no joke I got pepperoni pizza for the kids it was also really good no complaints we will be ordering from here again for sure!!! The staff was amazing!!!

Best wood fire pizza around my kids love this place more than I do

Such good pizza. I’ve ordered from this place few times and every time the pizza was delicious. Definitely worth the drive.

Visited Pizza Amore in Tonawanda this evening and I can’t say enough great things about the entire experience. We stopped there after a long, sad day and it’s almost as if the gentleman at the counter could tell we needed extra kindness. DJ was attentive, courteous, helpful and took very good care of us. The rest of the staff followed his lead and were just as wonderful. The chicken wing pizza was phenomenal and the rest of our food was cooked to perfection. I highly recommend Pizza Amore. 5 stars 🌟

My work tried this pizza for the first time yesterday and it was awesome ! So many options that you can get in any size including personal so perfect for lunch! I had the spinach and ricotta pizza and added banana peppers. It was so good! Definitely will be ordering again. Give them a try !

Had two pizzas today and they tasted amazing!! Only issue is that I have a weak stomach and am experiencing the consequences after eating the Smores pizza😅 But its well worth it!! I met the owners before they officially opened the NT location at Panes restaurant when at the time I was their waitress! Sweet people and I am so glad that I finally had the chance to indulge in such good pizza! Thanks again guys and I will be back for sure!

Ordered a LG cheese and pep with BBQ fingers everything was cooked and tasted perfext

Phenomenal OMG thank you lord good pizza! Wow! Really delicious. Outstanding wings. I'd had their pizza from their food truck. Loved it. This is like top 5 pizza in a region that is known for incredible pizza/food. The whole brick oven technique is amazing. Then to see the menu. They have desserts and salads. Service was fantastic. Big easy to park parking lot. Very clean. Great location on Payne near North Tonawanda High School. This pizzeria is a destination!

We’ve always been fans of the Grand Island location Pizza Amore, so we were naturally excited to find out it was moving to North Tonawanda. The first time we tried the NT location was a bit disappointing, but we wanted to try it once again to see if they’d perfected their system. We ordered “The Dave” and it was fantastic! Perfectly sweet sauce, perfectly charred pepperoni cups, perfectly thick crust, and the tastiest pepadews and sausage to compliment the rest of the pizza. The pizza is more expensive than other pizza places in the area, but definitely worth the occasional splurge when you want some more quality pizza!

Ordered for the first time tonight, we got the chicken bacon ranch pizza OMG that was a bomb pizza. We also order 1/2 tray of cheese and pepperoni also very good. Staff was friendly and the place was clean. All around pleased with my experience.

The great news is there are no deep fryers here and the Pizza, wings, chicken fingers and everything is cooked in a real wood fired oven, in fact they have two! The place has been redone very tastefully and it's nice to have another pizza place in North Tonawanda. Their signature thin crust pizza was actually pretty good and crispy. The staff was very friendly and responsive. Good luck.

Anyone complaining about this pizza must've lost their sense of taste. It's woodfired right in front of you. The sauce is great, the toppings are great and generous. The staff are super friendly and helpful. This is one of my favourites in the area. Fantastic pizza.

I rarely ever post reviews but WOW! I had to for this one. I got the stinger pizza and wow! It is the absolute best I've ever had! They do not hold back on toppings. Delicious taste. Seasoned well.

The chicken fingers were amazing, brick oven, fire burned pizzas are out of this world! My fiancé is obsessed with the gabagool! He has one at least 3-4 times a week! Honestly refuse to go anywhere else! Also the staff is beyond amazing, very friendly, and always going above and beyond!

Wow! Outstanding pizza. Thin and delishious! Got the traditional Pizza Margarita & a Pepperoni Pizza w/Amore Sauce. Great Ribeye sub too. It's not cheap, but in this case, you get what you pay for. This is my new favorite pizza. As long as they keep cranking out great za, I'll keep lining up to buy it.