Cafe Amici

Went there for late brunch, and was pleasantly surprised to find a hidden gem full of good and delicious food! The French toast was to die for. 10 out of 10 recommended, Good job guys!

We went to Brunch arriving a little early but were greeted like friends .
Service was outstanding a full team effort.
There was 8 of us two children.
The children ordered the chicken soup and after two big bowls wanted more .
The rest of our group had the best fried Zucchini I have ever had.
Burgers cooked perfectly and the eggs Benedict came out of the kitchen hot and very nice presentation.
Most of all we were treated like family and shown respect and patience.
Carrot cake shared by our table sent us home happy and planning for our next visit.

Food and service are amazing. Always an energetic crowd.
Food is really good.

Great Service and food quality is the key for a food place and this restaurant is number one! They offer outdoor and indoor seating and you can bring your own wine, the appetizers were great, pizza and pasta was amazing and the coconut cake was absolutely delicious! The service was also number one as everyone was working together!

Went late afternoon on Saturday for lunch. BYOB so we brought our own wine.

Quick service. Everything was hot. Everything was delicious. Staff was super friendly. What more could you ask for?

Cafe Amici is truly a place for friends, family to meet up and have amazing meal in a nice casual environment.

All of the food coming out of the kitchen was amazing…the special Ribeye, the Scallops and even the gluten-free pasta was delicious!

This is a BYOB spot but located around the corner from a decent liquor / ween store.

Enjoy and welcome go to the family….

I have waited far too long to check this place out. It is a beautiful little Italian spot in Wyckoff and I can see why people regard it so highly. I am was very impressed with the quality of the food and I loved how relaxed our server was. We didn't feel rushed at all, but we were taken care of the whole time. It is BYOB so we brought some of our wine from home which helped keep the price more reasonable. Most of their entrees are around $30, but even the more expensive items were below $50. They have a pretty big dessert menu and the tiramisu was tasty, but the star of the show for me was the Peanut Butter Cup Pie Crust Ice Cream. One of my favorite ice cream flavors that I have every had and I would go back just for that. I also thought the bread they brought to the table was amazing and I scraped every last drop of vodka sauce off my wife's plate because it was so good. I got the burger which was delicious with blue cheese and comes with French fries. They are the thin cut kind and they were yummy.

At first impression I thought it was a little pricey but then realized it is BYOB so that makes up for the price. Cafe is is furnished in a tasteful Manner and the food is excellent! I had a beet salad with goat cheese and a rack of lamb both were delicious. The atmosphere is smart casual and not too loud for a nice dinner. Some restaurants can become very noisy but this one appeared to be just right. The service was very good, my waitress was very attentive.

From the moment was take over the phone until the moment of pick up the experience was pleasant. I was in the area for an appt and had never been here. For MLK many restaurants were closed and we decided to give this place a try. We got the Prosciutto with arugula pizza and the mushroom pizza. I asked for a well filled cannoli and I was NOT disappointed. I believe Nicole was the gal who took our order and filled the cannoli too. She was so kind, generous and professional. When I picked up my order I accidentally tipped over their tips jar and they were more concerned with me staying calm and enjoying my meal. The staff was trying to not let this ruin my experience and I’m so impressed with how they handled everything.

My husband & I came for dinner on a Friday night after Thanksgiving…. I made a reservation since I heard it gets crowded. We were greeted by one of the owners she led us to a nice window table. The server was attentive & helpful in our ordering. The menu was awesome! It had alot of choices from burgers to pizza to pasta to specials! We first shared a wedge with bacon & bleu cheese. It was well prepared & good. My husband had the special which was swordfish & I had Rigatoni with marinara, eggplant & mozzarella. The swordfish was perfectly cooked. Delish ! I enjoyed my pasta dish. The marinara sauce had a really nice flavor. Huge portion took half of it home. The owner came over to check if all was ok & she recommended we order dessert, mentioning the chef bakes it all on premises. A nice selection , we chose carrot cake & loved it.
Prices are reasonable, nice ambiance & great choices of dishes. We will definitely be back!

First time visit. The food was very good and plentiful. Service was attentive but rushed. Went for lunch and seated quickly. Place filled up fast. Atmosphere was a bit noisy mostly due to three patrons talking very loud.
Definitely will return as we felt the food was worth another visit. Prices were a bit high, but reasonable.

A staple in my household. So good we order takeout from cafe amici nearly every week! Love the chicken and tagliatelle

This place has got the best food ever. Fantastic flavors. I come here often for lunch. A must try. The pizza is better than i assumed it would be

the food was incredible. we went for Christmas eve dinner. I had the prime rib and others had the prime filet with lobster mashed. Delicious. Will definitely be back.

Went to dinner with a group of friends, Had a nice time. Restaurant is clean and quaint. Staff was friendly. The food was delicious would come back.

Great food and service for a reasonable price. I had the best cauliflower stake with brie, while my husband had the amici burger. We were both very impressed and will be coming back soon.

Cafe Amici is a great restaurant to go to for lunch & dinner with your family & friends. I usually go to Cafe Amici with my Grammy & Poppy for lunch and order a cheese steak and french fries. (hand cut fries) For dessert I sometimes order cheesecake, chocolate cake or ice cream. My Aunt Lynn and Uncle Artie work at Cafe Amici every day. Cafe Amici has been around since 2002 for over 20 years. I love eating lunch and dinner at Cafe Amici with Grammy, Poppy, Aunt Lynn, & Uncle Artie!!

I rarely write reviews but this place deserves the 5 stars and a shout out!
I took my Mom here earlier today for a birthday lunch. It was perfect and I am so thankful!!!

From the moment we walked in everyone was kind. The hostess was patient and instead of rushing us to the first open table she instead allowed my Mom to pick a seat and waited until it opened up. She was happy to accommodate the table choice. THANK YOU.

Our waitress was attentive, also patient and the provided perfect balance of great service. My mom and I are a little particular and she totally accommodated our requests graciously.

BUT WAIT THERE IS MORE:
EVERYTHING CAME OUT OF THE KITCHEN LIKE WE ASKED!

BUT WAIT THERE IS EVEN MORE!
THE FOOD IS BOMB!

We had the hummus app - so good! - and both had turkey burgers. DELICIOUS! They are served with sweet potato fries which were also amazing!

We ate and chatted and not once felt rushed or any type of way.
She even brought us additional drinks at the perfect time.

It was just a super nice experience. Atmosphere is clean, warm and comfortable. Food is excellent! Service was fabulous.

Lately going out to eat is totally underwhelming. Food is over priced, service sucks and I'd rather just stay home than be disappointed. Amirite?!?

Thank you, AMICI for restoring my faith in local food service industry and being stand out! We appreciate you and will definitely be back.

Cafe Amici’s food and service is consistently wonderful. I never leave there disappointed and neither will you!! A perfect spot to meet a friend or gather for a family brunch!

Nice casual place with easy going atmosphere but small menu