Natalie's Worthington (Coal Fired Pizza and Live Music)

Got a Aurora borealis pizza and a house salad through Uber eats. The pizza was perfect, the crust was nice and chewy but not too overdone. I really like how they chop the toppings up small so you get an even amount in every bite. The pizza also had a nice spicy kick...nothing too spicy just right. House salad was good it’s salad so not too much to talk about. Check this place out! Enjoy!

Great music, intimate setting, no bad seats. Good pizza, NY style. The Bianco was lovely with a buttery crust and fresh basil.

Wish we could have stayed for live music as the stage setup was impressive. But the pizza made the visit 100% worth it. War and Peaches pizza cooked at 850° in the brick over was delicious! Just enough char, not too much spice, awesome.

This place was outstanding. The vibes were awesome, the pizza was delicious, the music was great. When it gets busy during a show, the bar can back up a bit, but that's to be expected. Really enjoyed seeing Honey and the Blue with some friends while enjoying some really unique pizzas. 🍕

Excellent pizza, service and atmosphere! Great place to see a concert! My friend's band, Martin Barre of Jethro Tull put on a great show there!

First time going very very nice and fun. Get there early as possible if you don't have a table reserved.Food was great along with the service. Music was perfect

Thoroughly enjoyed the food, music, service and atmosphere! This is definitely a place I'll go back to. The smoked trout dip is phenomenal! The prices were appropriate/ good value, for the quality of all of the food. We had 4 people, shared an appetizer, dessert and got 2 specialty pizzas, 1 beer and 3 soft drinks and coffee for under $80.
And the music was wonderful too! It was a songwriter showcase with 3 VERY talented young men- local artist: Barefoot McCoy, Youngstown area artist: JD Eicher, and from Nashville: Steve Everett.

This place rocks! Great pizza, great music, great atmosphere, great staff. This is a great place for date night. We loved or experience here and will be back soon. We saw Randy McAllister and the best damn band in the land and they were incredible.

Great wings, pizza and show! Cauliflower wings w/poblano sauce, Verdura Trebbiano pizza w/side of marinara, and The Whirlybirds!

Natalies is a little gem in Worthington. Great pizza and live music! They even have happy hour with half priced appetizers and 2 dollars of drinks. The parking is convenient. If their lot is full other businesses surrounding it allow parking. All the staff are very friendly.

Me, my mom, my grandmother, my sister and my lady all attended the Jazz Concert on 05/21/2021.

We all had an amazing time!

The food was great, drinks were great, food was amazing and the staff was incredible. Definitely looking forward to attended more and coming back in the future.

Fantastic venue for dinner and entertainment. Tuesday night introduced me to the "Sirens" and and the casanova pizza. Both were awesome.

Food and drinks were delicious! We ordered the hummus, arancini and the mushroom pizza. I was with my boss, so no pics. But the plates were all clean! We were there too early for music, but I'm ready to go back!

Service was amazing. Without that, 5 stars is unattainable. Food was delicious. Flavors were spot on. Pizza was cooked perfectly. And the dough finds that delicate balance between crispy crust and soft inside. Will definitely be back to enjoy. Atmosphere was pleasant for an evening out. Only wish was that the dinning room was a tad bigger, felt like too many seats were in "high traffic" areas.

I had an Amazing time! The food was incredible. Everyone was friendly and attentive. The entertainment was incredible! The entertainment was Christina Myles. Thank you for an excellent experience! Look forward to visiting again.

Excellent to go pizza. Looks like a fun place to hang out post covid!

Good food and drinks with live music. Don't forget your vax card!

Went for a show,amazing. If this place was in Cincinnati we would come more often. Will be back in Nov for more music.

Went to Natalie's for the first time and loved it! The crust and toppings were amazing. The atmosphere was very chill and I loved the artwork. We were seated immediately around 6PM on a Saturday evening with no live music. Our server was Lee, who provided excellent service!

Absolutely delightful place to eat, listen to amazing music and hang out with friends!! Pizza and appetizers were delicious, so fresh, listened to jazz band-Deuce n a Quarter which was superb!! Can't wait to get back soon!!