Dewey's Pizza

This is hit or miss depending on if you order delivery. The good is always good but delivery drivers (Door Dash) tend to stack orders for delivery and if you aren't first then it's cold. This is no fault of the restaurant. Just more reason to dine in. Dining in here is always a great experience. The staff and food are amazing.

Great Food! Fresh & Tasty Toppings on pizza! Our server, "Josh" was *Awesome*
Friendly, Welcoming and was so knowledgeable regarding the menu and craft beer selections. Our daughter enjoyed watching the pizza dough being tossed in the air.
Great for families or a "Date Night". Would definitely recommend & can't wait to return.

Wow! Great pizza, great service! You can even watch the chefs make and spin the pizzas! Awesome selection for any taste. Definitely worth a try. I have eaten there twice and both times, the experience was great 😃

Dewey's has great pizza! The kids love watching them toss the dough. We usually get the meatball pizza and a giant house salad. My only complaint is that I wish they had a better beer selection and/or a full bar for mixed drinks.

Staff was awesome, Friendly atmosphere. The pizza was amazing, probably the best I've had in the Columbus area. Come here, a must try.

Small place that provides excellent service and strives to make sure everyone has an excellent experience. Also one of very few pizza places that allow you to reserve a table online. Honestly, that was the deciding factor for us. We were traveling in from Indiana for the Eric Church show and the Buckeyes had a home game, so we knew places would be busy. They offer a lot of specialty pizzas, but we opted to build our own. The dough was excellent. The crust was crisp on the outside and oh so doughy and delicious on the inside. My 9 year old isn't a crust eater, but she saw me pull it apart and decided she was trying it. She said if all crust was like that she'd always eat it. Perfect amount of cheese, very tasty sauce, and fresh ingredients. If I could make one suggestion it would be to offer bread sticks made from your amazing dough.

Pizza and service was fantastic!!! The atmosphere is kinda average at best... But that's not stopping me from going back.

Great place. The quiet atmosphere--always feels cozy. The pizza served here is fresh and top quality. We frequent this place often.

OMG this pizza! I just got a plain cheese pizza, the crust, sauce and cheese all had that perfect amount of flavor and spices. It was so good, the sauce had the perfect blend of spices, the crust was the right amount of soft with a bit of a crisp to it. I'm definitely looking forward to getting Dewey's again. My husband got the calzone (only half shown in the photo), he's had Deweys before and absolutely loves their calzones. Great place to go with friends and family, great atmosphere, very open and light.

We tried their seasonal pizza ELOTE along with White pizza. They both were fantastic.

Delicious food and such friendly staff! I got a calzone, as well as some cheesy bread and both were amazing! I would recommend this restaurant for anyone looking for a good pizza/calzone/salad spot!

Great fast service! The servers work together to make sure that everyone is happy and satisfied. Food was also delicious! Great birthday dinner.

My family had a fantastic experience at Dewey's Pizza. The comfort level of the restaurant itself is top-notch—no annoying bad lighting, comfortable seating, pleasant noise levels, and tastefully decorated. The service exceeded our expectations; the staffing levels seemed higher than most restaurants, and drink refills and plates were removed before we noticed it needed to be done! The hostess, our server, and the manager were all friendly, professional, and courteous.

The quality of the food we ordered was remarkable. Our salads were delicious and very fresh, and the quality of the ingredients was higher than what we expected from a pizza restaurant. Get the side salad with your pie, you will NOT be disappointed! The pizzas made it to our table quickly and everyone at our table commented after their first bite on their freshness and quality.

Needless to say, we will definitely return to Dewey's. Our check was a little higher than we expected from your typical pizza joint, but this is NOT your typical pizza joint, for us it was one hundred percent good value for the money.

Great pizza and calzones! Professionals are splendidly flying pizza dough. Plenty of cheese is mellow. I want to come again!

Went here for birthday, best cake I have ever eaten and the pizza was slammin. Highly recommend this restaurant.

Have ordered many times and never disappointed. Not the cheapest pizza but you definitely get what you pay for!

Had a party of 10 tonight, some gluten free some not. Shared all varieties of pizza and everyone commented how good they were! Gf pizza was as tasty (I'm told by gluten loving hubby) as the regular pizza. Kids loved watching the kitchen toss the dough.
Service was excellent. A+++.
We were vacationers so won't be back soon, but we would definitely be regulars if we lived nearby!

Pizza was very tasty. You could see the cook in back throwing the crust in the air. Very fun to witness. Lots of unique speciality pizzas to choose from. They also offer half and half pizza, so if you can't pick one flavor you can try two! Yum.

Best pizza, great place, nice people.

My boyfriend and I got a 13" pizza and got different toppings on each half. It worked out perfectly for a dinner portion! No fighting over the last slice. The restaurant was busy but the servers were attentive. I love the toppings variety, something for everyone!