Jerry Arena's Pizzeria

Jerry's has the best pizza in town. It is the only place that we order from. Jerry personally made our pizza tonight and it was AMAZING! Never seems to fail us. Absolutely delicious!

Small crew. Same pie Tuesday afternoon, as Saturday's. Consistency is priceless. No such thing as cheap pizza anymore, but I think it's the cheapest. Even if it's not, consistency is key. Love em.

Fantastic food Everytime I'm never disappointed! Jerry & staff are absolutely amazing and go above and beyond for there customers. I highly recommend Jerry Arenas Pizzeria. Rate: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Got a large pepperoni pizza on monday.... great pizza and great customer service 👌!! Will definitely be back... David!!!!!!!! Thanks so much

First time today ever trying the food here and it was AMAZING!! My husband loved the pizza, I had the antipasto salad. The dressing was awesome, salad huge and best one I have had! They just found themselves loyal customers. Very pleasant owner and staff. Look forward to more! Keep up the great work! ❤

Honestly I'd say the cheese and cup&char pizza is probably the best in town. Had it for the first time last night. Held off on trying due to seeing sub 4 star reviews, turns out people are just being ridiculous over the cash only policy. If you haven't tried the pizza, definitely don't be like me and wait forever to try. It's delicious!

We moved to Le Roy, NY 2 years ago next month, and I'm kicking myself for not trying Jerry Arena's pizza sooner! It was fantastic! Don't let the crazy traffic in that area stop you!
The owner, Jerry and I talked while my pizza was in the oven. He is a great person, and all of his staff very polite and friendly.
Here's to another 40 years Mr. Arena! All things are possible with God!

Legit, the best pizza we’ve ever had. Friendly staff and great prices.

The owner is very friendly, politely, kind, caring....and funny. They keep to themselves and hard working. Their food is delicious 😋 they do charcoal hotdogs every Sunday, nothing bets a charcoal hotdogs. We make it a family hotdogs day on Sundays.

There pizza is absolutely delicious I love it so much I be driving out from Rochester NY my home town is Batavia staff if great my order is always right prices are extremely reasonable with the cost of everything going up best pizza ever

Jerry's is our absolute favorite. We order like 2wice a week. I just wish they had an online menu. The delivery drivers are amazing as well. Keep up the good work guys. Thank you from Ellicott st.

My friend and I were shopping in Batavia and we got super hungry and decided we were starving. We got in the vehicle and found Jerry's. After leaving all we could talk about was how awesome the pizza was because of the sauce, cheese, atmosphere and service was. Recommend to everyone who appreciates great Pizza!

Best pizza in the area my boyfriend and I travel from college pizza land because the Pizza is so good cold or warm. Defiantly don't let the building turn you away. The staff is amazing especially amy the manager. You will always get the best service unless your an ass and deserve an attitude,

If you want the best pizza in Western NY, look no further than Jerry Arena's. The unique flavor of their pizzas is unmatched, and the ingredients are always fresh. My family has been Arena fans for 20 years now and it hasn't changed. It's still the best.

I've always LOVED Jerry's pizzeria, and my dad used to get it for us kids for a treat when we were younger (: absolutely recommended to plenty of people. However their service isn't all the best, everyone seems miserable. Can't complain though, it's GREAT pizza.

Our family has been getting pizza and wings from Jerry Arena's since the early 80's
Always the best......never disappointed. The pizza sauce is where the secret is, 😋

We're from out of state and struggled to find a resturaunt to eat at for the night that we stayed in town. Everyone was really nice and personable, and the food was great. Made the hectic driving around trying to find somewhere to eat, worth it.

Awesome pizza! Fast delivery! Arrived super hot! I’m just passing through this area, but I would highly recommend! I wish my town had pizza this delicious!

Been the best pizza I've ever had since I was a kid.. (70s n 80s). Moved away n lived in many states & cities & still cannot find anything comparable.

Finally tried the pizza here , it was delicious!!! Fast and friendly service too!