Main Street Pizza Company

It was a last-minute restaurant pick for my daughter's birthday, and I'm glad we settled on it. Everything was awesome, from our waitress Debbie, i believe, who was an absolute sweetheart to food.
They even let us bring our own cake.
Build your own pizza was a definite hit for the kids.
My daughter can't have red sauce, so the chef substituted her pizza sauce with pesto. It was absolutely amazing.

The best wings with a wide variety of sauces. I recommend the wings flight if it’s your first time. The bourbon sauce was spectacular. The service is wonderful. The cheese sticks were great. Best to sit in the old side of the restaurant. The new side is extremely bright. Takes away from a comfortable dining experience.

Absolutely amazing. The waitress Skye suggested what may have been the best combo pizza and wings. Dry rub and Godfather pizza. I will be back and it could be tomorrow.

For a low-key casual restaurant, I don't know how you could do better. Fun, family atmosphere, friendly staff, and a HUGE menu of Italian options, scratch made! I had homemade tagliatelle with fresh broccoli in a savory wine broth and it was great. Our table shared an order of mozzarella wedges that were clearly also homemade with a killer marinara sauce on the side. The one appetizer was enough for our table of four, and the meals were so big we ended up all taking some home with us. This spot is clearly a local favorite because it's quite large and was packed, with a line out the door, and once you try it, you'll understand why. Next time we will make sure to save some room for the great looking dessert menu!

Delicious pizza and wings as well as appetizers. Food, service, and atmosphere were all great, and I would highly recommend the Godfather pizza as well as the garlic cheese curds. Also serves as a great meeting place for folks to meet halfway between Buffalo and Rochester. I am eager to go back and try additional menu items as everything that the servers brought out looked fantastic.

We were in the area and found this place that had good reviews. The arancini stole the show, pizza was good, and boneless wings were a bit overdone but were good. Maybe that’s how they cook them there so don’t know. FYI our bill our bill was $80 with tip. To be fair and honest, we’ve been to 47 states and had pizza all over the country. This is definitely in the top 5, or 3 IMO.

A surprise find for a date in a small town .

Came in with zero expectations and were pleasantly surprised by the ambiance, food and Wine !

They have a huge Italian Menu apart from their pizzas , of which they have a huge selection.

They do a deep dish pizza too !

They also take requests for half and half which was a nice thing .

The cheesy garlic bread was humongous and the accompanying marinara was lip smacking.

Ordered the specialty pizza of Buffalo chicken and Supreme as a half and half . The smalls are BIG here so order accordingly.

The pizzas taste great 😊.

The wine selection was good and the red and white ones we tried were really amazing.

Overall definitely making the drive from Buffalo for their pizzas 🍕!

Wow this place has got there act together, as far as a combination of Service, Selection, Alcohol selection, and Food quality…..

A rarity in the post COVID-19 Restaurant Business still trying to recover….

Service was great.

Drinks were delivered promptly.

Appetizers were timed properly.

Dinners arrived hot.

Nothing bad happened.

This is probably the best Dining experience in BATAVIA, NY.

Go here. Tip well. Be nice…..

Very very good food. I ordered the pasta with broccoli and the special with a cup of broccoli cheddar soup and rice balls? For an appetizer along with a glass of wine. The food was delicious and the meatball was huge! Great little place and the pizza is good too.

I came from Minnesota to visit a relative for Thanksgiving, Main Street Pizza came highly recommend.

I was not left disappointed, the service was very good and the food even better. We didint have to wait long for a seat or for our food to come out. Staff were very on the ball and my glass was never empty. They also went the extra mile to box up all our food for us.

The quality of the food was incredible and the bar has been raised for me now. Sadly I don't think I'll find a match in Minnesota.

I highly recommend coming here! Don't miss out!

We drive from Rochester NY specifically to come here. Literally the best (pizza/italian) fare ive come across in a long time. The food is delicous, and portions are huge...well worth the price, especially now-a-days with rising food cost. Everything is well seasoned and plentiful. Service was outstanding! I feel so bad we forgot our servers name, but she was so fun and engaged. She even knew our small table wasnt going to accommodate all of the food we ordered, so she let us move to a larger table so the 3 of us could spread out and share family style💙 Such a great experience. She even recommended Centennial Park to walk around after our huge meal which was just the thing we needed☀

Only complaint, the bathroom needed some attention. Sticky floor, and needed a good wipe down, but we understand being under staffed!

Have to hand it to this place, our server was very friendly, it was busy but took no time at all. Mozzarella wedges was the best I have ever had our pasta dishes and huge meatball was on point. Wish this place was closer as we were just going through the town and found this gem.

Could not wait to get the fish fry from last year! It was so fresh and beautiful. This year....
drastically different. Two pieces of fish, if you can call it that, and big chunk slices of potatoes. I was told this was fish and chips. For normal quality of Main Street, This is a disappointment.

This is an unbelievable gem in the middle of Batavia. As you walk in it looks like a nice Italian restaurant. The food and service is amazing. They have 1 lb meatballs that are really big. Food is well worth the price and usually too much and you need to take some home(not a bad thing). We were there on a busy night but you would not have known it since the service was great and the food came out quick. Definitely on our list to come back and enjoy our next time in Batavia.

Omg. I travel. And do wings and pizza at least every other week. I travel all 48 states. I’ve had some good pies and wings. And some not so good. I’m here to tell you. Hands down. One of the very best Deep Dish pies and dry rub wings I’ve ever had. Only gave it 5 stars because a million wasn’t available. And I’m not a review writing guy. First review I’ve ever written. It was just that good

Don't let the name "Main Street Pizza Company" fool you. Chose your atmosphere from outside dinning to indoor family dinning to even a dimmer intimate dinning area to experience. To go orders cleverly pick up thru a separate entrance, not to disturb diners. The staff is amazing! The hostess sat us immediately. Our waitress, Kaylee, is an absolute charm with experience and a sweet personality. She made us feel so comfortable. We ordered Manicotti and Rigatoni Bolognese. The homemade sauces are the best we've ever tasted. We watched a 16 oz. meatball order deliver to another table and immediately asked Kaylee to add one to our order. Great move! The grapefruit sized meatball is the BEST EVER! Romantic and classy restaurant hiding on the Main. Great for the gang, family, friends, or a romantic date night. <3

We were simply spending the night in Batavia, so of the choices available on a Monday night, this was our pick. It turned out to be an excellent choice! There was a waiting list but we got in quickly thanks to the hostess who was very cordial and helpful. We ordered an appetizer called “The Taste of Main Street”. It looked and tasted gourmet! A stuffed banana pepper, stuffed mushrooms, a fried risotto ball. Everything was awesome. For dinner, the special of 12 wings and a 1/2 artesian pizza with Pepperoni, onions, black olives. The main entree was only $26, and the pizza was huge. Came out piping hot, crispy and perfect. Our server Haley made great suggestions, was so professional, on the ball and friendly. If we lived in this town this would be our go to place for sure.

Unassuming place from the outside but pretty outstanding food and services in the inside. Inexpensive good food. You will definitely go back to try all their dishes.

Been here many times. Dine in and take out. (12-15 times per year)
For Batavia NY its awesome, if it were located in a big city it would be normal. The pizza 🍕 is noted as the best in Genesee county by most.

Excellent fairly priced food.