Simple Simon's Pizza

Best service, nicest employees, and most delicious pizza in the area. Better pizza than dominos. Im glad I tried Simple Simon's. My only go-to pizza place now.

This pizza was super delicious. We called to place an order for pick up and they had our pizza ready in 30 min. They have a convenient drive thru as well. My husband isn’t a fan of greasy pizza and it was pretty perfect. We also ordered the garlic cheesy bread and cinnamon sticks. The next time we RV in Onalaska we will definitely be ordering from here again.

Took a little longer than expected, but the quality was phenomenal. I know the kitchen was slammed with orders tonight and was running way behind, but the staff was very kind and empathetic and I appreciated their honesty about wait times.

My family will definitely be buying pizza here regularly. I would just recommend placing your order early on a Friday night!

Walked in was greeted by friendly very nice lady trying hard to serve everyone quickly. Was lunch and tried the buffet.
Super fresh everything very warm. Salad freshly made and crisp and cool! Good assortment of pizza choices, and the pizza dessert....DELICIOUS!
I recommend Simple Simon highly!
This is GOOD PIZZA....SIMPLE PUT!

AMAZING pizza!!!!! Friendly Christian owners with a small yet cozy little pizzeria in Onalaska. We went for my mother's 60th birthday dinner and we had a large group. They were very accommodating and friendly. They had excellent customer service and amazing pizza. We got the Hawaiian and the apple cinnamon dessert pizza and both were to die for. We will be coming back for sure.

Oh, heaven, that crust! Yes, please & thank you!
We had the lunch buffet, we were the only 2 in the restaurant, but they did not skimp on the variety of choices.

We stopped by after some errands and got two small pizzas and decided to eat there. Our pizzas were delicious and the staff was very friendly.
We will definitely be back there again

Best ever. I accidentally ordered take out online and I called the store and told them that I wanted my order delivered and they were quick to fix my mistake. Ashley was such a pleasure and delivered our order fast. Thank you so much 😊

Can I just say I love it when people go out of their way to serve you and get your business! We were camping at the Lake Livingston state park 🏕 in our RV 🚌 & we were too comfortable/lazy 😃 to leave and we wanted 🍕! I called Crystal (we like supporting local businesses) and she said they don't typically deliver here to far (it's 17 miles) I begged a little and she said sure! They delivered a Large pizza and wings faster than I expected! I'm glad he didn't get a speeding 👮‍♂ ticket. 😉 It was all hot, fresh and delicious! 😋 😋 Clayton, the delivery driver 🚕 got a $20 Tip!
Thanks for hooking us up on a lazy Sunday!

Bring Extra pizza next time...the neighbors were chasing the driver like an ice cream truck! 🚚 🍕 🏃‍♂ 🏃‍♀ 😃 😀 😄 😁
Thanks
-Ed & Jennifer McNair

Been there multiple times! It's always been very good pizza. We get the pepperoni pounder with bell peppers and thin crust!

Ordered a medium thin crust pizza with everything on it and a medium order of wings and was delighted after two years of frozen pizza from Brookshire's to get a REAL hot and tasty pizza/wing order. Kudos!

Just moved out here and brought the family to get dinner here. Super friendly staff and the pizza is some of the best pizza we have had!!! We will definitely be back💯

Had delivery of two large pizza’s. Pepperoni and supreme. Excellent

Our family loves pizza...I do too but it's not like other pizzas you can have the second day. It's cardboard by day 2.

September 2023. Food was great. People really nice. They made our salads wow couldn’t get anything more on it great price as well!!!

Hadn't ordered pissa from there in many years... Needless to say it was a day and night experience!! Awesome 👍 service good,pizza Excellent!,price fare. Like an hand puppet full of candy;))

I ordered the Chicken Bacon Ranch sandwich and it was great! I didn't catch the ladies name who delivered it to me but she was very sweet and made sure I had everything I ordered. This place is definitely in my top favorites for sure!

Highly recommend: we wanted Italian, but most in the region are closed Mondays, so we found Simple Simon. Wherever you are coming from, this place is worth the drive and the food is worth the wait. The lunch buffet is a good deal, too.

These people are so kind, friendly and courteous. They helped me when they didn't have to and the food was awesome. My wife can't have red sauce the calzone with alpine sauce.

Being a retired chef and chef instructor who is married to a retired pastry chef I hope I can do this wonderful place Justice with my review. Having had the experience I've had in my life I have had some extremely good as well as extremely bad pizza in my life. I would have to rate this place amongst the best I've ever had. The crust is where it's at when it comes to great pizza. This place has one of, if not the best, pizza crust I've ever been privledged to enjoy. The toppings were equally good. And for me to enjoy a single topping pizza is rare to say the least. I believe had they just served me the crust alone without anything else on it I would have still been blown away. The crust was perfectly cooked to a perfection I have rarely seen. It was a deep golden brown, crispy and delicious! The toppings of cheese and spicy beef were well balanced with the underlying sauce and were generously applied.

You may well pass right by this small pizzeria and not think to stop in. From the outside it doesn't seem like much. From its gravel and dirt parking lot and it's small unassuming building you'd never expect to find the world class gourmet food inside that would rival anything you could find in Houston, Dallas, or Austin. I know, I've passed by this place so many times and was never inclined to stop and check it out. Until today. And I'm so glad I did. In fact I regret all those times I drove past it without a thought all those times before.

The staff were super friendly and helpful. There was a bit of a wait for my pizza but it was time well invested. I plan on being a regular customer from now on. This small pizzeria on a small hill just off the highway inside Onalaska is a hidden jewl that should not be missed. I recommend this place highly. If you're a pizza lover be ready to fall in love all over again.