Circle-A Auto Repair, LLC

Took my car in on a Tues with a serious issue and drove it of the lot on Thurs. They are a quick fairly priced classic American family business. No reason to go elsewhere

We dropped in here as we had car troubles coming down the mountains. We had a car full, with 2 littles, while we were on vacation. We were not on the schedule yet the owner got us in and was so kind and considerate. He was mindful of our kids needs while we were there. The fix was pretty simple but took at least an hour of his time. He did not overcharge us, in fact, I'm not sure he charged us enough considering his exceptional service.
I am writing this review 4 years later as the kindness we were shown still crosses my mind. I am forever grateful to the man that owns this.

Our car died as we were driving through Eagle on our way back to Denver. We were lucky to end up at Circle-A to get it diagnosed. Dave actually came up to us where we were broken down to see if he could assist us not knowing we were already in the process of getting a tow to his place. He worked with our auto warranty company, which was not an easy task, to get our engine replaced. He advocated for us when they sent a bad engine and got them to send another. He clearly communicated and kept us informed throughout the entire process. He made sure everything was 100% right before having us drive the almost 2 hours back to pick up the car. I highly recommend Circle-A for any auto repairs you might need in the Eagle area.

Dave is great!!! Very knowledgeable, honest and with the best prices around here. We've been to 4 different auto repairs and no one could even identify the problem. We have Audi S4. Finlly we found Dave, he took our car without making us wait for weeks( we've been without a car for 1,5 months already). He was updating us daily on what's going on. He fixed it! So, amazing service and a very nice guy! Can't recommend this place enough!!!

Going to Circle A was one of the best experiences I have had with an auto shop hands down. You can tell Dave cares about his clients and he was able to get my car fixed quickly when I was stranded. When they couldn't get a part that was needed for repair, he even arranged a discounted rental car for me to get back and forth to Denver to take care of some things at home. I hope no one is in the situation I was in, but if you are, go see Dave, he will take care of you and get you back on the road as soon as possible.

I showed up 5 min. before closing and had an issue with my oil level in my Audi, and I had to drive to Denver the next day, they were so nice looked at my car for me and topped of my oil. I highly recommend Circle A Auto Repair. I will definitely be back!

I had my belt go out about 3 to 4 weeks ago and Dave was able to get my car working again on a short notice. I am now getting the AC fixed in my car and he is able to do it in a very short amount of time. He was able to explain things very easily and his business has outstanding customer service. I would highly recommend him to any one who is having trouble with their vehicle.

My old Nissan truck started squealing recently, and Dave was able to figure it out as soon as he heard it. During his assessment, he found another issue with my fan, and gave me an honest answer about whether or not it was necessary to get it fixed right away as well (he thought not). After I decided to get everything done, it was able to be fixed within a very reasonable time, and at exactly the price he had estimated. It's hard to find an honest, efficient, and knowledgable mechanic these days...especially in a pinch. Excellent experience.

Our 4Runner had trouble as we were passing through. By absolute luck we stopped at Circle A and met Dave and his wife. He fixed our car right then and there. Incredibly knowledgeable, incredibly friendly, A+ service. He was upfront about the pricing and diagnosed the problem very quickly. Very impressive.

I started going to Dave over the summer, since then we've been several times for oil changes and many other things and he's always very straightforward. He thinks that cars are always going to require maintenance, so he's always going to have business, so there's no point in ripping anyone off. He's a master mechanic and he can always explain everything in a lot of detail. My boyfriend bought a used car and brought it to Dave to have it checked out and Dave brought him in and showed him everything underneath the car. My check engine light was on once and he explained what the issue was and told me that I didn't have to fix it because it wasn't affecting the car at all. Dave is amazing, his wife is super nice, their dog is really cool, I drive from Vail just to not get ripped off and they always fit me in last minute and are always very reliable.

Cannot recommend enough! I was driving through when my truck stopped shifting in a snowstorm, at night. Dave got me in the next morning and took great care of my truck. Circle A offers nationwide coverage which in it of itself is a reason to go there.

Circle A ROCKS! Another great Eagle business with local mechanic vibe. Called them on a Tuesday and they diagnosed the issue right before closing that nite. The diagnosis fee was very reasonable. They had it fixed on Thursday! All of this during holiday season. I've since requested service estimates with which they were prompt on return, even while being busy. They use quality parts, are up front and honest with estimates, and do their best to get repairs done quick! 🤘🏻

How to check engine light come on while traveling. Pulled in to Dave's shop. He got me taking care of right away his price was very reasonable very knowledgeable. My truck runs better than it has in a long time. thank you so much for your help and being super friendly. Highly recommend circle a automotive

Dave and the team are amazing. I would never take my Audi anywhere else in the valley. I have been here a few times and each time has exceeded expectations. It's hard to find someone to trust in this valley but these guys you can count on. Recently I went in for a simple oil change and they gave me a full health check on my car including brakes and belts, even down to a couple of screws missing on my belly cover plate and refilled all my fluids (including Ad Blue). I also ordered a small grill that was missing from the front of my car and they had it there in a couple of days at the same price quoted on the Audi USA website. Very honest and very caring. Thank you. John. 2012 Audi Q7 Prestige S-Line TDI

Subaru broke down on our trip and had a huge radiator leak. Dave was able to squeeze us in and help us out saving our trip. He was very nice to run us through all the problems and tell us what might need to be fixed later. Thank you Dave!

I have a 2010 Volkswagen Beetle that would not start. I called to see if I could bring it in and he knew exactly what the problem was only speaking over the phone. He was kind enough to fit me in even though they were behined about a month. Took 2 business days and they called me and told me she was ready. They explained the issue which was exactly what he though it was. I was told I could pay over the phone and pick it up after hours which was very convenient. The cost was very agreeable. I wasn't ripped off like I've been before in the valley. I will be taking my car here from now on, I finally found my mechanic!

Darren Knoll —
5 star
Circle A is a super company. We were traveling through and our diesel truck broke down. We had very poor brakes and needed to get to the front range. Dave took a look at it for us and diagnosed what the problem was. Had a little trouble, no fault of theirs in getting the part and got us back up and running. In a situation like this we were at there mercy and it would have been easy for them to take advantage of us. There price was very fair and they did it for us as quick as they could even though they were extremely busy. Thank you so much to everybody working there. They even gave us a loner car so we could do some exploring while they were fixing our truck. Dave and Taun are great people and could not be nicer to deal with.

This shop is by far the most experienced and honest mechanic in town. Dave and his wife were super helpful. They exceeded my expectations and went above and beyond to help me. Their price is fair and they will try to eliminate unnecessary charge as much as possible. Truly amazing service. Thanks.

These guys saw us on short notice while having car troubles on our road trip. They quickly got us back up and running and saved the trip. Amazing people!

Just wanted to relay my recent experience with Circle-A Auto. I had just gotten my toyota truck out of a different shop and had a grand worth of work done on it. It was running so perfectly. I was driving down the trough road, hit some wash board and all of a sudden my truck quit taking gas. It was late Saturday night and we were moving so my truck was packed with a lot of stuff, and we had to get towed somewhere past midnight. The tow-truck driver from West Vail shell recommended Circle-A, and we dropped it off past midnight. I had planned on renting a truck, leaving mine there to get looked at, and hopefully picking it up the next week. We rented the truck on Sunday morning, and were packing it up in the parking lot. Dave, the owner, just happened to be there and asked us what was wrong. After telling him the recent work I had done on it, and the context of how it quit running. He said, I bet its the so and so.... can I take a look. Sure enough that is what is was. He plugged it back in, and it started just fine!!!! We were lucky he was there for a minute on Sunday, but even luckier he is an honest mechanic. It was literally the opposite of the experience I thought I was going to have, being from out of town, and moving. He could have taken advantage of some travelers and he did not. I am so grateful!