Brothers N.Y. Style Pizzeria

Omg this is my favorite pizza hands down!!!! I am so happy I stumbled upon this place. I have been looking for a solid NY style pizza place in the area since I moved here. Brothers is by far the best in the Winter Haven area I’d go as far to say all of Polk County maybe Central FL! You will not be disappointed trust me.

Love Brothers! It's the closest to NYC style pizza here in Winter Haven. We always do take out pick-up orders, love that they call us to let us know our order in ready. My family loves pizza, so we order once a week. My favorite is the chicken bacon ranch 😋 extra crispy. My family's favorite is half cheese, half pepperoni. Check them out won't disappoint.

Delicious thin NY style pizza
Yummy cheese sticks
And yummy garlic knots
The service is was good, very friendly and nice.

Pizza was really good and garlic knots were so good. Service was great and would reccomend this pizza place to anyone. Will come back here again.

I’m from NY and I haven’t been able to visit in years. This was like a slice from home and the garlic knots were great I usually don’t like them. True to its name.

Best pizza in the county! (Sorry Floridino's). Friendly server gave us the whole story - retired owners(30 years) of Northern pizza restaurant get bored and open up pizza restaurant. Other Italian food, calzone's etc; my wife had a Eggplant wedge (think folded over pizza dough) which she thought was terrific and she's really picky about eggplant. We'll definitely be back (and hopefully they're working on a beer license) and bring friends with us. Now in 2022 tried the wings along with the pizza. Pizza still terrific, and now add wings to the list. Wings were Garlic Hot and Spicy, and they sure were! Best garlic wings I've ever had!

I had a very positive experience here. The staff was very friendly and attentive. The restaurant is clean and organized. The prices were great as well. They accept Android pay as well as apple pay. The pizza was amazing. I will be returning to try the wings next time.

Best pizza in Winter Haven. Great New York style with fresh ingredients.

Pizza is really good, crispy crust and the sauce is really tasty. Not too greasy. The combo deals are super reasonable and the staff was friendly. Reminds me of a real NY pizza spot.

First time at this location and I am more then impressed. Asked for lite sauce and the pizza came out perfect the taste is amazing the crispness of the pizza is just rite. Very good pizza.

Wow incredible pizza ! Closest thing I've found to real NY pizza down here. Great pizza great price great service.

Truly a treasure and local gem for Winter Haven. WELL worth the price!!

Easily the best pizza I have had in Winter Haven. I’ll be a regular here for sure.

Excellent pizza, even gave the kids a candy bag with toys and candy for Halloween. 👍🎃

I'm obsessed with the cheese fries, the garlic knots are mouth watering, and when you get a fresh pizza where the cheese is all gooey, its legit heaven. We get this at least three times a month if not more. You get a pretty big pizza for the price. My favorite part is that it's new york style but it's not too greasy. It's my favorite pizza place for sure.

Finally found a pizza/restaurant that reminds me of the good “real”pizza I use to eat in my home town. Crust is just right with the right amount of cheese. The plus is that you can actually sit down in one of their booths and enjoy it while it’s still hot.

Stopped in today for the first time. Ordered a couple of slices. Pizza's were good, service was good. Next time I'll try the wings

When I first read some of the reviews, I have to admit I was a little intimated about some of the remarks regarding management and the customer service and costs however, I also read reviews about the distance others had driven to eat from this pizzeria so we decided to give it try for the first time in March 2022, let me say, it’s worth the cost.. My husband and I have driven from Polk City at least once a week for this pizza every since! On a bad work week, we may have to miss that week and go the following but this is our pizza go to restaurant. Today, we ordered pizza and also tried the all meat Stromboli, we added onions and extra cheese. Oh my goodness!!!! Now, this is some of my co teacher’s go to, even driving from the Lakeland area!!!

We were visiting for Legoland and looking for a good meal before driving home. Yelp as well as Google led us here by the mostly positive reviews. That can admittedly be a risky bet but in this case it paid off!

Pizza was on point for a hungry family of 4. Thin NY style base, great sauce, outstanding cheese and a nice crispy crust which was a result of craftsmanship in what could only be a well-seasoned and piping hot oven.

We will definitely be back the next time we are in town. Highly recommend it to any who are looking for a nice pie before heading home from Legoland and if you are a local, well then, you probably already know what’s up with this place.

I love this pizza!! My 1st time eating their pizza I went in and ordered 2 pieces by the slice. It was great and I was hooked.
I had to check it out again so my 2nd time I ordered a pizza and had my wife pick it up on her way home and we both loved it.
My 3rd and most recent order we ordered my wife’s favorite which is Hawaiian pizza and I ordered some garlic hot wings. The pizza and wings were great. This was my first Hawaiian pizza and I can Definitely say we will be ordering it again. The wings were very good but could’ve been hotter but that’s just me.
If you want New York style pizza and you live in Winter Haven or close by I would definitely suggest trying this place out. I’ve never ordered pizza and eaten it inside the restaurant but I can only imagine it’s even better to eat it there but when the delivery pizza is still awesome then you know it’s great pizza.
So 3 times and every one has been great. I’d say I found my favorite pizza place in Polk County.