The Pizza Heist

After seeing a pizza review online I thought I’d give it a run. Pizza had a nice soft dough, crispy crust and a slightly sweet sauce. Employee at counter was very good at taking my order when I wasn’t sure what I wanted. Haha. I did notice that they get a lot of people that come in for the 2 slice special. That tells me this is a consistently good food spot. I will go again.

Stopped in for the Monday large 1 topping deal and got a Large cheese with banana peppers and onion for about $16. Very good pizza with generous topping portions. The toppings were very fresh and the crust had a delicious oven taste. They appear to use cheese slices, which I like and the sauce is very light and subtle. This is a great deal!

Seriously the greatest pizza & wings in all of Buffalo. I’ve been ordering from here for the past 4 years and it gets better every time. I love you pizza heist!!

The absolute best place for great food. We’ve ordered pretty much everything on the menu so far. Awesome employees and service. 100% recommend to anyone in the area.

I placed an order for delivery through door dash and the driver forgot to grab my soda that I ordered. I called the pizzeria and the young lady I spoke to was so nice and apologetic that she sent one of her employees out to deliver what was missing. Thank you very much for your kind customer
sevice.

I feel like I got a steal, pun intended, a small chicken finger salad and mozzy sticks for 11 bucks! The salad was delicious, perfectly portioned, had plenty of chicken in it with fresh lettuce, tomato slices and cheese. The mozzy sticks were a little too crispy but were definitely fresh. I'm definitely coming back!

Summer bash in August. Pizzas wings and fingers great. Big Halloween party at my house tommorow on the 28th order in for food again. I know that's one thing I won't have to worry about cheese and pepperoni...white pizza...cheese pep and mushroom..wings and fingers. My family will be delighted.

Magnificent pizza. The prices are reasonable and their staff is friendly and easygoing. A great place for a Zza.

I wish I would've taken pictures! I ordered three different sheets for a party to be ready by a certain time. These guys had the pizza coming out promptly and cut as I was there to pick up. Pricing and quality were on point! Definitely check them out for any large (or small gatherings)!

Took the wife and kids for a meal. Great food and service. Would highly recommend

The Pizza is 10/10
Found my new favorite pizza !! 👌👏
Staff is very friendly as well.

Delicious chicken finger bbq pizza with blue cheese..made perfect both times we got it!

Great price. Great food. Only thing I wish is they offer Lemmon pepper wings.

My kids and I rate a different Pizza joint every other week! This one just took the lead! We even ordered two nights in a row we loved it so much! Great Pizza and Friendly Team at the counter!!! Highly recommend! Wings perfect!
Sub was fantastic too! Thank you.
We ❤ our 🍕🍕🍕! 3musketeers.

This place is exactly what it claims to be, a meal for a steal !!! Delicious food at great prices. The owners are friendly and it’s family owned ! I really can never complain when I order pizza here. It’s a great sweet sauce and I the ingredients are fresh. I love trying new things and I ate the thin crust with hot peppers and pepperoni, well done !! It was awesome all at the owners suggestion. Good people, great food!

We have been ordering regularly from the Pizza heist probably since they opened and have always been happy with what we have received. They are a small mom and pop business family owned and we’re happy to have them in the neighborhood.

Pizza 👌
My daughter loves the chicken fingers
Steak hoagie on point.

We ordered for the first time using online ordering, also for the first time. We made a mistake and ordered the wrong sub, it was discovered when the owner(I think) relay the order to me. He made The correct sub in less than 10 minutes and brought it right out to our car with the rest of the order which I assume he kept warm for us. When we got home and opened our food we were impressed by the care and presentation that went into our food. Pizza heist is clearly about serving the customer and providing great value. Definitely going back!!!

I've been going to The Pizza Heist for years. Food is very good and consistent. I highly recommend this pizzeria. My favorite is their white pizza.

I love the food here, and the customer service. Always polite when I call, and I have an odd way to get to my door and they always get it right. I also have ninja cats the escape and they are amazing about making sure the door to my outside is shut so they don't get out. That alone earns them bonus points! But the food is always good. Even if it may take a bit to get to me when they are busy, its always hot, and always fresh. Pizza is amazing, sauce is a bit sweet but I like it, even though I don't normally enjoy a sweet sauce. I'm a little sad by the wings though. They aren't always very crispy when I get them, though I ask for them that way. Still really good, not a complaint more of an observation. For sure check them out if you haven't already.

Had a party at como park for 60-70 people, everyone coming from all over Wny, everyone commented on the pizza and boneless wings, that they were great, the quality and the price will keep me coming back as really impressed