Elm Street Bakery

The food was very tasty! I got some desserts and coffee to go and they were amazing. If you buy a bag of coffee they give you a free complimentary small coffee to go with it. Customer service was exceptional too.

Im not usually one to leave reviews, but 10/10 would recommend! The pizza is amazing, very light with a charred crust. Grilled cheese was exquisite. The overall
aesthetic is truly captivating. To summarize my experience, I could die here a happy man.
Honored to be the 1000th review.

Wow! What a great place! Delicious food including breakfast pizza and bacon Asiago scones...try the sticky buns if they have them.

We went twice on different days and they had different pastries and breads both days.

Superb coffee and drink options, and wonderful, polite and exceedingly friendly staff.

We loved it!

Was taken on a surprise breakfast date and this place was super cute! We went on a weekend and it was very busy with people and families constantly coming in and out. Ordered a couple breakfast sandwiches, pastries, and a latte. Wish the sandwiches were warmed up (maybe we just had to ask?), but overall everything tasted really good. Would definitely stop in again to get more pastries and another coffee!

Elm Street Bakery is my favorite place to get espresso coffee and breakfast. They have exquisite baked items on display to choose from! I love their breakfast sandwich with eggs, bacon, arugula, and spicy mayo between fresh sourdough slices! They specialize in brick oven breads! Brick oven pizza too. Wonderful choices with fresh flavors from local farms! Friendly staff! Very clean and lots of seating downstairs, upper level and alfresco!

Really cute spot for food and drinks right off Main Street. We came on a busy Saturday and had to wait in a bit of a line to order and then again to get food but overall was very fast considering. There is plenty of seating and the staff is very friendly. Food was phenomenal, especially obviously the bread in the sandwiches and the other baked goods. The bread had a great crust and just the right amount of firmness to support the contents of the sandwich. Both the Cuban and the Philly were very flavorful and well balanced. It is a bit pricey but worth it for the experience and quality of food. Would highly recommend if you find yourself in East Aurora. 4.8/5 -BJ

Such a gem. Luxurious baked goods, well crafted coffee drinks, and gracious staff. Only issue is that everything behind the counter looks so amazing, it is difficult to select just one or two items. Can't recommend this place enough. Top marks all around.

My husband and I stopped here for some coffee and a baked good while we were driving through the area and were very happy we did. Our lattes were delicious and the service was excellent! It was a very busy Saturday afternoon but that didn’t stop them from providing exceptional service! We were very pleased and impressed with our experience here today!

The atmosphere in this place is absolutely gorgeous! The staff was very attentive, friendly, and quick- even for a busy Saturday morning. I had ordered a vanilla latte and their avocado toast. Their coffee is truly great and the barista making it was very kind. The avocado toast was prepared very quickly and the presentation was beautiful. I will admit, even though it tasted pretty good, the toast was a bit more on the expensive side. Truly a nice experience overall, though. I'll definitely be back again to try more items on their menu!

First time visiting today and can’t wait to go back! Everything was delicious!! It is very hard to find a nice place that checks off everything! Great coffee, amazing pastries with a delicious breakfast menu!! Have not been for lunch but cannot wait! For everyone that says it’s pricey I don’t think that is very fair to say. The quality of food you’re getting is the reason you are paying that price. Which in my opinion portions are perfect and fulfilling. I have paid more for mediocre coffee and pastries at other places. So excited I found this place and can’t wait to bring my friends for our coffee and lunch dates!!!

My husband and I love coming here for breakfast! I usually get black coffee but here I love the cappuccino. The barista makes the drinks look so inviting and pretty!

Came in with a group of friends for lunch on a busy Saturday. The staff helped us all find a spot to sit together and accommodated a few other needs. Everything we had was delicious!

Snowing outside.
Rain or in a very special day with open sun… anyway
Elm Street Bakery is one of the best places to be in East Aurora Ny.
U can see the “ pizzaiollo “ making a delicious pizza in a few minutes in front of you!
Beautiful construction in wood and elegant decoration.
Have a good time there

As a local, I am at ESB at least 3 days a week and there's a reason for it! I truly love all the staff members, especially the barista, Steven. The owner, Kim, is lovely as well!
The atmosphere is comfortable and welcoming. The food is simple, yet delicious.
I recommend the Angry Jay pizza with an iced raspberry tea. Cheers! :)

This place is phenomenal! They have such an interesting and exquisite menu and so many wonderful bakery options. The inside is rustic and charming with a really homey feel. The prices are very reasonable and the entire place is quite clean. The staff are friendly and helpful. My compliments to the chef that created this menu because the flavor combinations are incredible. I never would have thought of putting beets and pistachios on the same sandwich but it works so beautifully. It was a totally new taste experience for me and I'm definitely coming back for more!

My only complaints are that first time customers might have a difficult time figuring out where to pick up their food since the register is on the opposite side of the building from where you pick up your sandwich. The counter space in between causes further confusion that could be solved with a simple sign. I also felt that given the number of staff and the number of customers my food was a little bit slow in coming.

Other than those two small things I had a really great experience!

This place is an absolute gem, truly worth experiencing for its exceptional service provided by a team of incredibly friendly and attentive staff.

From classic favorites to inventive creations, there's something to satisfy every palate. One standout feature is the presence of a highly skilled and artistic barista who not only serves up expertly crafted beverages but also possesses a wealth of knowledge about coffee and its intricacies.

Enjoy delights such as the perfectly toasted avocado toast, complemented by a creamy cappuccino, or perhaps opt for a wholesome granola bar for a nutritious start to your day.

The aesthetic of the place is very pleasing, with great details from plants on table to furniture adding diamonds to the ambiance.

What a cute little bakery this place is. We've passed by here before and they were closed so we made note to come back and I'm glad we did. We got a chocolate chip cookie with their apple bread which was very very good. And then we got a Caesar salad which was a bit pricey at $14. And we also got a personal Pizza cheese Which was delicious.

Absolutely the best bread ever! Actually, we’ve never had bad anything here, whether it’s bread, pastry, coffee, pizza, or other entrees. Outstanding service and staff, beautiful location, just an all around home run.

I’ve been coming to this place for a few years every time I’m in the area and the food is absolutely amazing. I can’t say enough about ANY dish or bakery item we tried. Everything tastes amazing! Prices are good and service very attentive and welcoming. The location is also very nicely decorated and cozy.

Fantastic place. Great food. Great friendly service, and their coffee is out-of-this-work.
I am from out of state (Virginia), but I will definitely come back to this local gem next time I am in town.