Rosati's Pizza

Came here for my birthday. I'm from Chicago & am always looking for a good Chicago pizza. I haven't found anything in the Evansville area that really comes close. Until now! Rosati's Chicago pizza is not deep dish, but the crust is just right. The sauce is chunky, not mush, & the spices are spot on! We had Italian sausage on the pizza. It is the first sausage that did not give me a hint of heartburn in decades! And it's nitrate-free.
We got a order of their dough nuggets as an appetizer. Perfectly soft & seasoned! Took most of home for a meal for our adult daughter. She had a calzone. And again, it was great
To top it off, I got a free dessert for my birthday. I got the cannolis... OMG!
Can't forget to mention the staff! Very kind, attentive & informative.
Atmosphere, very laid back. Big booths & tables. TVs everywhere to watch sports & a couple with cartoons. All of the tvs were muted with closed captioning on. Music playing overhead, but not too loud.
This may have been our first visit, but I guarantee it won't be our last!

Just ate here and it was... AWESOME!! We had a thin crust 2 topping pizza amd it was excellent as always!! Good atmosphere and great peeps that work here!!

Differently not your every week dining but it's differently a must try restaurant. It's a bit pricey but if you leave hungry that's your fault plus you will differently have left overs. We ate dinner and had lunch the next day on what we took home. Super friendly and fast service. Highly recommend trying at least once.

Invited yesterday to lunch at Rosati’s with my husband’s family.

Being diagnosed with celiac disease years ago has made eating out difficult for me. Especially when I love pasta and pizza so much.

Most places that serve gluten free pizza tastes like cardboard smells and I’ve been disappointed in my fair share of pizzas over the years. It’s always terribly bland.

But…Rosati’s gluten free pizza was phenomenal. Great flavor. Robust flavors in each bite. Crust was NOT like cardboard. Plenty of toppings to choose from and just a really good meal all around.

The service was great. Refills kept coming and the young waitresses were really kind.

We will be back. It’s over an hour trip, but it’s worth that and more for good food…especially good pizza. :)

Husband’s deep dish and my gluten free pizza shown. He loved his too and ate it for left over dinner!! He said it tasted just as good hours later heated up!

Wow this place is great! Service is excellent and food is tremendous. We ordered the dough bites, cheese bread, boneless wings, the Cheef, and peice of cheese pizza. All was amazing. Especially the cheese pizza, the dough omg so good. Their marinara is beyond amazing.

Pizza was good. Not overly spicy or sweet. Dough nuggets were awesome, highly recommend if you're a crust lover. Service and atmosphere were good!

The prices and the portion sizes match well. The ravioli was easily 2 meals for $15 with a drink. And it was delicious! So happy to finally get this quality of food in Mount Carmel. We also ordered the 16in monster pizza. It was LOADED with toppings. It fed 6 adults with left overs. Enough for 3 MORE PEOPLE!!

Great little franchise spot from up north out here in Mt. Carmel, great staff, excellent service, good slices, Cold Beer!

Really great service and tastey food. Chanced going here as we are from Delaware, but of all places in town, the parking lot was full, so we figured it was a locals favorite. Our server wasn't even supposed to have our table, but everyone was running and we ended up keeping her. She explained perfectly anything we asked about. I knew the food was prepared fresh because it didn't come out in 3 minutes and was just heated up. Our food was cooked perfectly. Good places in the area look difficult to find, so I'm sure we'll be back tomorrow. The table next to us got 6 different dishes and 3 appetizers. The wings looked great, and I want to try the Italian sausage sandwich.

Enjoyed the atmosphere, the food was great and definitely not lacking in portions. I highly recommend and true one of a kind. Kudos to the owner.

Staff was friendly and the food was delicious and hot we didn't wait long either will be coming back

Service is great food was great. They have shiner bock on tap and great big beer glasses.

Great service and amazing salad and pizza. One of the best pizzas we've had. Definitely recommend!!

The food was delicious. Our waitress was very friendly and efficient. Hope to return soon.

We got the Chicago style pizza. It was delicious, prices was fair and waitress was nice.

I just figured out I don't have to drive 5hrs to Chicago for Italian Beef! Can't wait to go back!

Great Italian beef sandwich, crispy hot fries....cold IPA and a super friendly bartender. What could be better?

This has become a popular date night location for my Boyfriend and myself. The prices are a little high, but the quality fits the price. The portion sizes are perfect and we always tend to have leftovers. We like to go on Wednesday nights when the pasta dishes are $9. The pasta sauce cannot be beat! The service is always spot on, and we always leave happy!

Kyla & Paula were very instrumental in making my⁸ wife's surprise birthday get-together a total success. Kyla went above and beyond to make it happen. Thanks to all.
Food and service were 5 star.

Oh yes, don't forget lasagna.

Ordered at least 20 times since they opened. I can honestly say that 18 out of those 20 times were excellent. Especially the pasta dishes are absolutely delicious. We’ll keep ordering from there.