Stacey Cakes

Stacey Cakes is a must while you’re in McCall!! Stop in and grab a quick yummy bite! We stopped in for the special for the weekend. Salted Carmel cheese cake! So delicious!!! Also picked up the ham and Gruyère scone along with ice coffees. The place was packed for good reason!
There is also a huge selection of pastries and food options.

Stacey Cakes is our go to every time we visit McCall. Highly recommend any of the pastries. Have never been disappointed!

Everything here is really good. They sell out fast. You can't go wrong with anything you try here. They are a bit pricey, but it's worth it.

We had Stacey Cakes cater the dessert bar items for our wedding. Everything look and tasted amazing! We barely had any left overs because everything was a hit! We highly recommend them for any event! Be sure to try the strawberry rhubarb pies and the huckleberry cheesecakes! So so good!

Wow, wow, wow! Stacey out did herself with our amazing cake. We requested a single tiered cake for our elopement, with almond cake, raspberry cream cheese layers and naked buttercream frosting. We wanted to decorate the cake ourselves and it turned out beyond anything we could have asked for. Not only was the cake gorgeous, but it was so friggin' delicious and everyone who tried it said it was the best wedding cake they'd ever had. BUT, what's more... We ordered a Mediterranean quiche for the morning of, and that was all anyone could talk about for the remainder of the day. Seriously!! Here we are getting married and we couldn't get over how delicious the quiche was. The buttery flaky crust, plentiful artichokes, olives, feta, peppers, fluffy creamy eggs... it was to die for. Thank you Stacey for making our day so delicious!

We come here every visit. My husband loves the lemon cloud tart. I like huckleberry cheesecake coffee cake. We always leave with a bag of gingersnaps. The best!

Lovely little bakery with tasty breakfast options. We got a Mediterranean quiche and the lemon poppy scone. Tons of lemon flavor!

We got their mediterranean quiche, chocolate raspberry shortbread, cherry pie, lemon cream pie, and pecan sticky buns. The quiche and shortbread did not survive long enough for me to take a picture of, but believe me when I say they were the best shortbreads and quiches I have ever tasted. In fact, everything we got were the best things we have ever tasted. I like to bakery hop whenever I travel, and I’ve been to many of the highest rated bakeries in cities all across the US (NYC included) and few of them can hold a candle to Stacey Cakes. If you are in McCall, you have to stop at Stacey Cakes. You have to.

Stacy Cakes has the best baked goods I’ve ever had. You can’t go in there and not get at least one or five of everything because it’s all amazing. The staff is nice. It’s very small though so don’t plan on really sitting and eating unless you get the one table. You’ll buy so much you’ll be taking it all home to go anyway ☺

This isn’t just the best bakery in the valley, it’s probably one of the best anywhere

Our niece sent cookies from Stacey Cakes for Christmas gifts. What a treat! One bit and you know they are made with all natural fresh ingredients. Mc Call has always been special place and your bakery adds to the magic. Keep up the amazing items until we can return in person.

Passing thru McCall, we were happy to find a bakery open on Sunday morning. We ordered the lemon danish and cinnamon roll….. absolutely delicious!!! They had so many tantalizing pastries to choose from, it was hard to decide!! Whenever we are out this way again, we will be back.

A gem of a place. Looking forward to going by next time I’m in McCall.

Yum - especially the ginger cookies. I buy enough for snacks and memories when back home. Remember they are closed Monday & Tuesday!
Show up early - the aroma of the baking goodies will lead you to the front door!

Good place for simple pastries! Although a little pricey and maybe as a request make croissants. But besides that the food is good! Also if possible it would be nice to have sugar free options for those who can not consume sugar.

Everything we’ve had here is absolutely delicious! Going here is a must of you are in McCall.

The vanilla shortbread cookies and cinnamon rolls are to die for!

AMAZING baked goods. I had the salted caramel cheesecake which was seriously one of the best cheesecakes (and desserts) I have ever had. Seriously crazy taste sensation. Crumb was perfect, and the whole cheesecake was a perfect combination.

Also, had the huckleberry blondies... eating one right now as I write this. Really tasty, has an incredible fresh, juicy taste from the huckleberries. It's also a clever combination.. not a very common combination.

Stacey makes the best of everything! Her ginger cookies are eaten far and wide from McCall to the Boise Valley. We ship and take them to our kids and grandkids in Hawaii. Her sunrise muffins are delicious and healthy. If you want a dose of chocolate, try her chocolate mousse cake for a special occasion. For a quick lunch I love any of her quiches and knishes -- they are incredibly delicious. We are so lucky to have such a great bakery in our small town.

Guys and gals, this place is amazing! They serve high quality fresh baked goods, both sweet and savory. Make sure to get there between 8&2.