Brooklyn Pizza

BEST PIZZA IN THE COLUMBUS AREA!!

This is NY pizza! I'm a born and raised New Yorker, and this is legit! It's literally the only pizza in Columbus I actually want to have. Sure there are a lot of pizza places around, and in a lot of ways they are all the same, with maybe some subtle differences. BUT, Brooklyn Pizza is the only place around where you can get a true NY pie, and a darn good one too!!

I love this place. The pizza is legit New York pie and delicious but I absolutely love the calzones. The dough is perfectly browned and tender yet chewy at the same time. High quality ingredients inside and the ricotta is rich and fluffy-tastes like it’s homemade. Somehow they caramelize the toppings before baking it which really sets it off. The sauce is incredible, very simple and perfectly balanced, probably starting with top shelf tomatoes. I appreciate the small menu of very well executed items

Great New York Style pizza in columbus. In my opinion the best crust in Columbus. I love their white pizza. Great place. Pizza by the slice at lunch is great deal.

Outstanding taste, crunchy, and everything you would think a NY slice tastes like. Walk in and buy it by the slice makes it awesome for people like me on the run. Kudos to this pizza joint, y’all make a great pizza.

This place takes me back home! Best pizza in the area! You walk in they remember you after only being there once! You can also get a slice and there are many options! I love this place and every bite makes me think of home! Great job guys! Also the owners are always working in the shop and are super attentive and connect with everyone!

This is the best calzone I have ever had hands down! My daughter and I have come here several times specifically to get this calzone. Their ricotta cheese is fluffy and to die for! Though this place isn't really intended for eating in they do have two tables out front, and is nice for some people watching on a nice day!!

I'm from NY, and I have been looking for an authentic NYC pizza, and Brooklyn pizza is it. The crust, the cheese, the slice, the garlic knots, mannnnnnn. I love this place ❤

True Brooklyn pizza, even by the slice. Delicious and authentic. We can't wait to try the Stromboli and other menu items.

Fantastic pizza in Powell!! My family and I drive from Dublin to bring this back home. Some of the best pizza we’ve found since we moved to CBUS. (Pro Tip) If you have to drive a bit back home ask them half bake the pizzas and not cut them so you can finish cooking them at home. Attached pic is the Bianca. We added tomatoes and fresh cut basil to it. Soooo good.

Top notch pizza. Best New York pizza around. The staff is amazing! Nice to have a place you can get a whole pie or just a slice. I've recommended Brooklyn to all my work friends and we always make a stop when in the area. Great size slices 👌. Keep making the best pie around!

Super solid pizza, and they sell it by the slice! I could not finish a whole small by myself, but my partner had no trouble finishing his.

Hands down the best pizza in Columbus. Especially if you love new york style.

White pizza with ricotta was outstanding and reasonably priced! Got it well done, I will be back.

Authentic NY style pizza. From the pizza by the slice to the can of coke, this is a must have if you’re in the area. Lunch pictured here is under $10 which is nearly impossible to find nowadays.

Excellent NY pizza. Thin crust, crispy bottom, crunch and chewy. The store is family owned and operated so the service isn’t always the best and sometimes they max out on pizza capacity.

The calzones are the best I have ever had, worth a try. Also they have cannolis made to order that are fantastic.

Always a great pie, and a great takeout option when visiting Ill Mannered Brewing Co, across the street. Pictured: margherita pizza and March 2023 menu.

I love a good pizza pie but I LOVE a great pizza pie and Brooklyn PIzza is it! The "Bianca" (White Pie) to die for!!!

Tastes like I stepped off of the Subway in Brooklyn and had a slice! This is authentic NY pizza… perfect fold, right amount of delicious cheese. I ate a slice in the parking lot, then had to pull over 3 miles later for another! Get the sausage and thank me later

The absolute BEST pizza around. Its so nice just to be able to go in and grab a couple slices and a can of pop or get a pie to go. Found my go-to Pizza place from now on. 10/10

Yummy pizza. By the whole pie or purchase a slice from their daily by the slice option. $2.50 for a cheese slice $2.75 for one topping slice depending on what the slice of the day is.