Old Time Pizza

They have really good pizzas! And the staff are friendly. I can’t wait to try out more of their menu. Definitely recommend going here.

Excellent experience for where to dine in, or take out ! Pizza is very good & large you don't need to a add more cheese ! Broasted fried chicken & or Pork Chops ! Every meal is $20.00 or less, dine in or carry out, you'll be impressed !!!

The woman who took my order over the phone was so nice! Wonderful pizza and lovely restaurant. Would recommend, we'll be back.

Nice small town restaurant with a good variety of food options.
They are generous with their mozzarella on pizzas, the breaded portobello mushrooms are great!

We stopped in here on a Sunday evening with a group. We had my some birthday here and instead of carrying in food we brought the boys out. Old time pizza was very accommodating and helpful. Food came out really fast. Location is nice and clean.

Pleasantly surprised by this pizza. Not what I recall from years ago, but a good improvement. I really like the meat pizza and my kids loved the cheese.

I have been purchasing pizza here or many years. The pizza is a little pricey, but we'll worth it.

Very quaint pizza joint but worth the visit. Super friendly owner/staff. Food was hot, fresh, and delicious. I hadn't been here for years in between and I guess they have new owners but the flavor is still the same as years ago.

The most delicious pizza you’ll ever have in Indiana.

Great little pizza shop in the country. Love the thin crust. Glad we stumbled across this place.

Small town pizza vibe. Fast and friendly.

I ordered from work then was unable to leave right away. Old time pizza closed and when I started to leave a message.. the lady answered and stated she had stayed hoping I called and still allowed me to come get my food. I pulled up and it was brought to my car still hot and fresh! Delicious food. Great friendly service! They go the extra mile for the customer! Thank u!

Wonderful hometown feel. Wonderful service. Wonderful fresh food. We had tossed salad-- very fresh and tasty; bread sticks-- hot and fresh u have a choice of dripping sauce-- cheese, garlic butter and Marinera. Supreme pizza-- lots of cheese, veggies and meats it was great. We will order or come here again.

Great place to eat. Felt relaxing and felt welcomed to stay an eat. My daughter and I loved the pizza!

This place is great. I can always find a reason to complain about food services, But I only have good things to say about this place. I absolutely love it. I am never let down. Great value. And The owner is definitely one of nicest people I have met in this community. I am definitely grateful for their service.

Great pizza place. You do go up to the counter to order and get your own drinks. Prices are decent for the fact they don't skimp on toppings or cheese. They do sizing in inches somewhat like a Pizza King. The hours are that of a small town place which always seems to be when I want to go there they're closed (that's my fault lol). The only negative I would say is the sauce on the pizza tasted very tomato paste-ish to me like there was not much seasoning in it the first time we ate there. If the boss is there it's consistent and amazing but if not the consistency can be different.

This place has great pizza. Along with pizza they serve chicken, pork chops, sandwiches, and many other food items. They also have great pie. They serve a variety of sides. They have the best mini tacos. It's great to order them up with the nacho cheese. This place has been here in New Paris forever. If you live here you know it

The pizza is delicious, I had to ask for my pizza crust to the specially done, and they did it exactly as I wanted and they seemed happy to oblige me. Something you don't see today is excellent customer service in the food industry, I just wished I had eaten here earlier.

My 1st time buying pizza here last night, good Pizza! My son got free chips and juice here,😊 that made his day! Thanks for the hospitality and kindness! It goes a long way😊

Being one of the only restaurants in the new paris area, you've gotta know about it. If you havent id highly recommended eating there. Great food, great people. (They also have pictures of majestic bald eagles)