Persnickety Antique Mall and Flea Market

Wonderful place to visit. The ownership, lady of the house, is pleasant and accommodating. Here is a photo of what we purchased, that leaded glass thingy....

I love this place. I am so sad that they are closing. Please go visit while you still can. If you like great deals and things a little more on the country living style, you will love this place too. The owner is the nicest person, please stop by and shop, and wish him well.

Love this little treasure trove in Hanover. Have found MANY nice items here and reasonable prices. Added a pic of a few of my newest cast iron finds

The Mr. And I visited Persnickety Antique Mall for the first time this week, while on one of our antiquing adventures. We were pleasantly surprised to have found various items we had been looking for (and more) all in one place. The flea market style set up offers several varieties of vendor booths; and a wide variety of: old and new; early century to mid/late century, antique "original" to modern "reclaimed", and everything in between. The store owners were very helpful and knowledgeable with a genuine passion for their business, their vendors, and mainly their customers. They even offered to call a vendor on our behalf to negotiate pricing, making sure we (customer and vendor) we're both satisfied and happy at the end of the day. I would definitely recommend adding Persnickety Antique Mall as a stop on your next antiquing adventure, as it is now going to be a permanent stop of ours when visiting the area! 💙

This is one of the most unique antique shops I have visited in years. Very organized, well maintained, and a variety of unique, hard to find antiques. The booths belong to individual people so some antiques are not correctly identified which is fine if you know you antiques. I.e. - an antique soup tureen was labeled as a cookie jar. By the way it is a beautiful piece with the matching lid with just a knick on it from where the spoon was once in it. Sorry I did not take pictures this time, but you can go view for yourself. We spent a good 2 hours in there.

I like fhe store a lot. It has a great.deal of crafts, nice antiques, and a healthy supply of old tools. I picked upa Jersey axe in excellent condition for $10.50. Hard to beat.

There is a diversity in the consigners in this shop. Large store with furniture, decorative items, handmade clothes and crafts, and seasonal items. The owners are very friendly and helpful. When we visit Hanover, Indiana, we always go by Persnickety. Highly recommend this shop.

The first time ever there I really enjoyed looking around at things.It reminds me of home.Staff very helpful and friendly.I will definitely be back again.

This place is awesome. Lots of treasures that you will want to take home. Clean, roomy booths and good prices. Put it on your list of places to shop.

Very nicely organized, very clean facility, friendly staff, had lots of nice things at reasonable prices. I'm so glad I found this place and will be going back soon!

Lots of unique choices with an arranging selection across the place, they did a good job keeping booths different. Lots of good things to go around, and friendly staff.

I have bought wonderful pieces at this store. I had an issue I should have contacted the store over or talked to them in person instead of leaving a review. The owner handled it so professionally that I am impressed with them.

Love this shop. I always find unique treasures to decorate with. The people that work here are very nice and friendly, too.

We bought a lovely roll top desk (Montgomery ward )at persnicketys owner and helpers super nice people hard to find these days!!! (Great price )Thanks😀

This place has beautiful selection of primative and farm house decor as well as good selection of antiques. Very spacious and clean

Nice place never know what you will find. Employees are great!!! Only drawback is no rest rooms try to stop on our way to and from Evansville

Blend of vintage items and hand crafted gifts at reasonable prices. Very clean and well managed.

We love this place! Such nice things and wonderful owners! Highly recommended and our new favorite place to go!!

Great place to shop. Very warm personality and friendly. And the prices can't be beat.

Haven't been here before. They have a array of items. Prices were very reasonable.