Benny's Off the Water

Very good food served by a sweet and funny waitress. I ordered a grilled chicken salad (no tomatoes) with ranch dressing. It was delicious, but the salad was like a shredded topping kind of lettuce if you don't mind that. The ranch was also kind of chunky (though I may have just gotten the wrong kind and didn't realize) but it was still good. The fries were the best I've had at any restaurant and the All Meat Pizza was my husband's favorite, he recommends it to anyone who comes here.

Had heard their pizza was good, but was pleased to find it was superb! Crust was not too thick or thin; edge was just a touch crispy while rest of crust was delightfully chewy. They are generous with the cheese and toppings. Everything was just perfect! They have a nice kids menu and lots of sandwich, appetizer, salad and beer options. A lovely gem in an out-of-the-way locale. Well worth a drive. Serve was excellent, too, even though they were rocking a half hour before closing!

BBQ pizza was outstanding, and the BBQ sandwich with slaw was delicious, too! Will definitely be back!

One of our favorite go to places for a Saturday or Sunday afternoon quick bite to eat. Anything smoked on the menu is always a no brainier, but it's hard to beat the wings. BBQ pulled pork pizza is another favorite that is hard to pass up. The staff are always great and the laid back atmosphere on the deck makes for some relaxing dining!

I really enjoyed our food. The employees were really nice and the food came quick. I would recommend if your in the area.

We had a large group for lunch on Saturday and the service and food was great! The Hoosier tenderloin was amazing. 100% recommend this restaurant.

Cod fish sandwich and the onion rings were suggested, and they did not disappoint. Everything I have tried has been good. Love the service too!! Give big tips!!

Great spot for lunch or dinner - especially outside. Nice covered patio area. Wings are very good and service was very friendly and attentive. Would definitely go again.

We were looking for a quick bite for lunch at a good place and found it here. We had pizza and it was very good. Looking forward to it being warmer so we can eat outside! It was a busy place for lunch.

We recently had a family wedding at the Patoka Lake Winery and hired Benny’s Off the Water to do the catering for both the rehearsal dinner and the wedding, and we could not be happier with our decision. The menu selection was extensive for both events, and the food was outstanding! It was a pleasure working with Marty as he was not only professional and personable, but his culinary expertise was outstanding. We highly recommend this unexpected catering treasure.

Loved Benny's! Staff was fantastic and the food was delicious. Couldn't ask for more.

Stopped in on a Sunday early evening. Got in right before it became a little busier. Service was great, very friendly. We did not plan on stopping and we had our puppy along for the Jeep ride. We sat in the outdoor covered area with her. They were great in asking if we needed a little plastic bowl for water. My wife had a fish sandwich and I had the breaded fried tenderloin. My wife said the fish sandwich was good. I did not try it but my tenderloin sandwich was the best in the area for sure. It is fresh and tenderized with great breading. Not frozen like you see a lot anymore. If a restaurant has a tenderloin sandwich I normally have to try it to see how it compares and they knocked it out of the park. Thanks for the hospitality.

Love this place. Good beer and great pizza !

Beautiful day to eat outside.
They were busy but we got our appetizers really fast and sandwiches soon after. Good food!

Great food, great atmosphere, great service. Highly recommend! Owners were awesome. We showed up after closing, and they were nice enough to fire the ovens up and cook us some pizzas. Midwest hospitality at its finest!

We loved our first experience here! Definitely will be going back as we loved the outdoor dining area and the service was fast and on spot! The food was even better with my brisket sandwich w/barbecue just melting in my mouth the meat was just right! We loved the breading on the large fries as well and my fiance had the buffalo boneless wings and said they were great! The only not great thing was the mac n cheese which was to runny but not bad flavor! Beyond the great service we even were checked on by Benny himself I believe making sure everything was cooked right! Oh yeah I almost forgot the amazing best breadsticks around we had for appetizer! We ate 3 of the 4 before I could take a pic!

Benny's is our go to takeout when we are camping. They are always fast, efficient and orders are correct. The loaded fries are huge and delicious! Last time I even tried the fried fish sandwich and the fish was nicely breaded and seemed fresh, not from a bag. The patio is also very nice and the servers are always cheerful.

EXCELLENT all the way around! Service, food, cold beer-just what we needed after lake time! Hours on Google aren't accurate! Open later than posted online so call to double check! Great place for dinner! We had the pork tenderloin, chicken bites and a grilled cheese and everything was delicious! Even the kids were happy! Friendly staff!

Really nice place. Pizza was good. Wife had a barbeque burger and said it was good also. It was busy when we went but the staff outside handled the lunch rush well.

Excellent food!! Pizza was delicious! BBQ and Bake Beans very good!! We tried the Wings last night and they were awesome!! Excellent service great staff!! Trying to open and run a new business under the conditions of Covid 19, this restaurant is working very hard starting out. Great job!!! It will only get better.